Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
1 hour ago, moonslav59 said:

Of for the new hire to say, "Hey guys, don't blame me for our ownership being cheap bums. I'm spending all they give me, and I beg them for more, but they always say no."

Imagine getting a promotion at work and being put down by some of the old timers there because you don't have the same polished resume as the rest of them.  You'd kind of come off as an entitled, pompous meany. 

Imagine if we sined Suzuki as well and Bauers outperforms next year.  Imagine being the person who says "yeah but Suzuki used to be better"

I don't care what he did in 2020-2026.  I care about what he does from 2027-2030.  And so should everyone else too. 

Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

Winter budget may also completely change depending on the CBA negotiations. We don't know where the Lux Tax tiers end up. There could be additional $ to spend? 

I heard that they were following Bauers back to the middle of the season. They reached out with a good offer and got a FA early. It's a good process, even if YOU don't like the player. 

Is there more money to spend? Probably, but who knows?

I firmly believe that if they were going to try and cap spending in any way it would be more in the form of a freeze on the luxury tax lines not a decrease.  Even then, I could still see them moving up a hair before being frozen.  We are in a wait and see mode. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Hugh2 said:

Imagine getting a promotion at work and being put down by some of the old timers there because you don't have the same polished resume as the rest of them.  You'd kind of come off as an entitled, pompous meany. 

Imagine if we sined Suzuki as well and Bauers outperforms next year.  Imagine being the person who says "yeah but Suzuki used to be better"

I don't care what he did in 2020-2026.  I care about what he does from 2027-2030.  And so should everyone else too. 

Agreed, and if I had to bet, I'd bet Suzuki does better over the next 4 years, but he'll probably make double Bauers- or more. Maybe he gets 5-6 years.

My comp will be Sato. I'd like to see what Sato ends up getting. I like him more than Bauers, but it's a guess.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I firmly believe that if they were going to try and cap spending in any way it would be more in the form of a freeze on the luxury tax lines not a decrease.  Even then, I could still see them moving up a hair before being frozen.  We are in a wait and see mode. 

One interesting thing would be if they grandfather over the cap teams for a while. Then, we'd have wished we spent a ton.

Posted
4 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I firmly believe that if they were going to try and cap spending in any way it would be more in the form of a freeze on the luxury tax lines not a decrease.  Even then, I could still see them moving up a hair before being frozen.  We are in a wait and see mode. 

Wait and see mode while El Cheapo Henry went out and signed a top FA before the lockout. 

Posted
1 minute ago, mvp 78 said:

Wait and see mode while El Cheapo Henry went out and signed a top FA before the lockout. 

But he wasn't good before 2026 so it doesn't count. 

 

Posted
8 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

But he wasn't good before 2026 so it doesn't count. 

 

Neither was Mead.

AR was good before, but for some reason that doesn't count.

Crochet is only as good as 2026. What he did before means noting.

Rafaela and Contreras had career years, but we need to expect regression.

Tolle was overextended and will get hurt. Bennett will decline.

See a pattern here?

Posted
2 hours ago, FredLynn said:

You’re making excuses for Henry being cheap. It’s long overdue for him to spend some of his billions on higher quality players. 

not gonna happen. henry is just too f***ing greedy.

Posted
50 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Neither was Mead.

AR was good before, but for some reason that doesn't count.

Crochet is only as good as 2026. What he did before means noting.

Rafaela and Contreras had career years, but we need to expect regression.

Tolle was overextended and will get hurt. Bennett will decline.

See a pattern here?

Definitely a pattern……. it’s called being a fan. Short for fanatic. 

“A fanatic is someone who has an extremely strong passion, enthusiasm, or devotion to something—sometimes to the point of being obsessive or unreasonable.

The word can have two meanings:

Positive: Someone who is incredibly passionate and dedicated. For example, “He’s a baseball fanatic” means he absolutely loves baseball.

Negative: Someone whose beliefs or devotion are so extreme that they become irrational, intolerant, or unwilling to consider other viewpoints.”

But full vulnerability post that I think I’m crazy for thinking. I’ve never felt like Abreu was an All star outfielder. I would personally rather trade him right now for a strong SPer. And sign Seiya Suzuki. 
 

Or even if JH didn’t approve anymore $$ take a chance on a trade for a guy like a O’Neil Cruz who has more offensive upside even if defensively he’s a big downgrade. IDK why I feel that way, Abreu has shown major improvement vs LHP last year, he’s a good teammate, seems like a good dude.
 

Just can’t explain it. 
 

 

Posted
1 hour ago, moonslav59 said:

One interesting thing would be if they grandfather over the cap teams for a while. Then, we'd have wished we spent a ton.

Dude that’s a scary logical thought…….
It will make me so mad at JH if we have to ride through 5 years of Yankees with a 50m advantage over us

Posted
2 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

Dude that’s a scary logical thought…….
It will make me so mad at JH if we have to ride through 5 years of Yankees with a 50m advantage over us

How can they tell the Dodgers they have to get under the cap by 2028?

They'd have to trade Ohtani and hope someone can afford him.

They almost have to provide a transition time frame.

Posted
7 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

Definitely a pattern……. it’s called being a fan. Short for fanatic. 

“A fanatic is someone who has an extremely strong passion, enthusiasm, or devotion to something—sometimes to the point of being obsessive or unreasonable.

The word can have two meanings:

Positive: Someone who is incredibly passionate and dedicated. For example, “He’s a baseball fanatic” means he absolutely loves baseball.

Negative: Someone whose beliefs or devotion are so extreme that they become irrational, intolerant, or unwilling to consider other viewpoints.”

But full vulnerability post that I think I’m crazy for thinking. I’ve never felt like Abreu was an All star outfielder. I would personally rather trade him right now for a strong SPer. And sign Seiya Suzuki. 
 

Or even if JH didn’t approve anymore $$ take a chance on a trade for a guy like a O’Neil Cruz who has more offensive upside even if defensively he’s a big downgrade. IDK why I feel that way, Abreu has shown major improvement vs LHP last year, he’s a good teammate, seems like a good dude.
 

Just can’t explain it. 
 

 

I'm not totally consistent myself, but I try to be. Keep the same criteria you like for everyone.

I realize going by recent numbers may mean more for someone in their prime, who has several years of like numbers mean more than some second year guy or a player who just turned 35.

Don't use career numbers for one guy and just 2026 for another.

Don't use BA for one guy, HRs for another and K rate for a third.

I tend to use the flawed OPS number a lot and value last 2-3 years more than career, unless the guy is way past prime. I tend to discount value for players that were great long ago and have gone years without doing jack, but players like Sale can always bash me upside my head.

I was convinced Bregman was in serious decline after 3-4 lower years with HOU, but he seems like an outlier with this 2 year resurgence. Any criteria has flaws and examples of almost the opposite happening, but just be consistent.

Posted
4 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

This lineup looks amazing to me. I tend to lean Suzuki vs Sato just because he’s proven himself.
IMO Suzuki+ Kirby >> Abreu + a rental SPer for 20m. 

IMG_0299.png

I agree...I can live with that.

Posted
2 hours ago, FredLynn said:

Why not? It’s not a bad thing to have four outfielders with talent. Look what happened last year with RA. There’s definitely room for all four on an elite team.

I don’t think Suzuki is going to sign anywhere that benches him for no reason.

Plus the Sox still currently have 4 outfielders.  Five of you count Yoshida.  I know your premise was to “dump Yoshida and Duran.”

Ive assumed all along Breslow will eventually DFA Yoshida.  But the dude haas a .919 OPS as a pinch hitter.  That does make give him a solid role on a roster, if the Sox choose to take advantage of it.  And someone is going to point out “$18mill for a pinch hitter?” and then advocate dumping him  for nothing and signing Suzuki to be a $25mill fourth outfielder, and never connect that that means spending $43mill on that one roster spot.  Folks, pinch hitter or not, the Sox are paying him a lot of money.

Anyway, .919 OPS as a pinch hitter puts me back on the Yoshida Train…

Posted
1 hour ago, UtahSox said:

This lineup looks amazing to me. I tend to lean Suzuki vs Sato just because he’s proven himself.
IMO Suzuki+ Kirby >> Abreu + a rental SPer for 20m. 

IMG_0299.png

Two bench players listed as DH?

Abreu for Kirby seems like a fair trade, although Seattle might be hesitant to further dismantle their rotation.

I will point out that “Suzuki plus Kirby > Abreu plus rental pitcher” is a marketed statement.  I mean, why do the Sox pay for a 5-6 year deal for an OF but settle for a rental pitcher in Plan B?

And Kirby has been fairly mediocre the last two years.  Pretty durable, which is good because he only has two years left.

I don’t think the Sox could do better than Kirby, especially if they save the $120-150mill and not get Seiya Suzuki…

Posted
13 minutes ago, notin said:

I don’t think Suzuki is going to sign anywhere that benches him for no reason.

Plus the Sox still currently have 4 outfielders.  Five of you count Yoshida.  I know your premise was to “dump Yoshida and Duran.”

Ive assumed all along Breslow will eventually DFA Yoshida.  But the dude haas a .919 OPS as a pinch hitter.  That does make give him a solid role on a roster, if the Sox choose to take advantage of it.  And someone is going to point out “$18mill for a pinch hitter?” and then advocate dumping him  for nothing and signing Suzuki to be a $25mill fourth outfielder, and never connect that that means spending $43mill on that one roster spot.  Folks, pinch hitter or not, the Sox are paying him a lot of money.

Anyway, .919 OPS as a pinch hitter puts me back on the Yoshida Train…

Someone would pay Yoshida $3-5M to DH for them, so why DFA him?

Posted
1 hour ago, moonslav59 said:

How can they tell the Dodgers they have to get under the cap by 2028?

They'd have to trade Ohtani and hope someone can afford him.

They almost have to provide a transition time frame.

This is what I was saying.  My guess is that if there is a cap, it will come into effect for 2028, and the dodgers will certainly have an issue getting under.  Especially if the rest of the league jsut refuses to take their contracts. 

Posted
45 minutes ago, notin said:

I don’t think Suzuki is going to sign anywhere that benches him for no reason.

Plus the Sox still currently have 4 outfielders.  Five of you count Yoshida.  I know your premise was to “dump Yoshida and Duran.”

Ive assumed all along Breslow will eventually DFA Yoshida.  But the dude haas a .919 OPS as a pinch hitter.  That does make give him a solid role on a roster, if the Sox choose to take advantage of it.  And someone is going to point out “$18mill for a pinch hitter?” and then advocate dumping him  for nothing and signing Suzuki to be a $25mill fourth outfielder, and never connect that that means spending $43mill on that one roster spot.  Folks, pinch hitter or not, the Sox are paying him a lot of money.

Anyway, .919 OPS as a pinch hitter puts me back on the Yoshida Train…

Yoshida doesn’t deserve a roster spot

Posted
3 hours ago, Hugh2 said:

Something like that is delusional.  WHo hires people and then puts them down, why would anyone ever want to go work for that company? it's an absurd notion. 

Oh-I completely understand that honesty is too much to ask from the Flops. That doesn’t make their dishonesty any more palatable. 

Posted
12 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

This is what I was saying.  My guess is that if there is a cap, it will come into effect for 2028, and the dodgers will certainly have an issue getting under.  Especially if the rest of the league jsut refuses to take their contracts. 

I really don't think the6y will force teams to dump contracts to meet the cap. There will be a grace period.

How they count deffered money could affect some teams way more than others.

Posted
3 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

Wait and see mode while El Cheapo Henry went out and signed a top FA before the lockout. 

Yes a top FA in a very down year is not nowhere the same as signing a top FA in a very good year like last year. Someone has to be the cream of the crop even if the crop isn’t that good.

Posted
47 minutes ago, notin said:

Two bench players listed as DH?

I will point out that “Suzuki plus Kirby > Abreu plus rental pitcher” is a marketed statement.  I mean, why do the Sox pay for a 5-6 year deal for an OF but settle for a rental pitcher in Plan B?

That’s the position listed on the website I didn’t put that. But you know that Mickey can play catcher at a very avg level, along with 1b. Romy can play 1b,2b, or 3b in a pinch. 
 

Thats fair to say it’s a marketed statement… I just looked, and don’t see a high quality starter for elongated 5 yr + situation that would take around 20m per year. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

That’s the position listed on the website I didn’t put that. But you know that Mickey can play catcher at a very avg level, along with 1b. Romy can play 1b,2b, or 3b in a pinch. 
 

Thats fair to say it’s a marketed statement… I just looked, and don’t see a high quality starter for elongated 5 yr + situation that would take around 20m per year. 

Gasper is not avg on defense at Catcher- an important defensive position. I'm not sure he's average at 1B.

Romy might be okay at 1B but below at 2B.

We also have Sogard, Seigler and Monasterio.

Posted

Looking at Bauers’ history he was good for just two years-after six years as a bum. Not really liking the signing much. Suzuki would have been a much better addition imo. 

Posted
27 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

Looking at Bauers’ history he was good for just two years-after six years as a bum. Not really liking the signing much. Suzuki would have been a much better addition imo. 

I know forums are anonymous pubs where we get to talk ball any time and use any unbanned language we want. But I personally wouldn't call a guy who's been bouncing around the Major Leagues since 2018 a bum.

Here's why: he's never been paid much more than MLB minimum wage. Bauers was never a star and never paid like one. But big league teams keep hiring him to play in the big leagues. And he stuck it out, because his wife said they needed health insurance...

He didn't get paid $25 million dollars a year to miss half a decade on the IL, or $18 million dollars a year to sit on the bench and watch an entire starting line-up play for less money. 

I've got nothing personal against those kind of guys. But as a fan, certain scenarios bum me out more than others.

 

Posted
5 hours ago, UtahSox said:

Without moving the goal posts here…. Let’s talk about what I said and your response:

notin: “we still would have been bounced in 2 games anyway and given up 18 runs.”


my response: “you don’t know…. that’s subjective. Maybe we win 4 more games and games are in Boston” we will never know. But Alonso looks like a good signing thus far for Orioles. (So much so that anyone on team is available for trade except Alonso.)

 

It’s not subjective.  If the Sox win 4 more games, they are still 2 games behind the Yankees and on the road for the postseason.  
 

Youre pro-Alonso over Contreras argument hopefully has more to it than “we don’t know what could have happened if.”  It’s just as supportable to say “maybe the Sox lose 7 more games and miss the postseason altogether.”

In fact, that’s probably a lot easier to support…

Posted

Bauers never played FT until this year.

Sure, he never earned a FT role over those first 5 years, but it's not easy proving yourself, when you never get a chance to find your groove.

There is certainly a decent chance he will never hit like 2026 (.874) or 2025-2026 combined (.840 w 33 HRs in 660 ABs) again. We may not need him to hit .840 to .875, if our other players can stay healthy and hit to their norms. .800 to .835 might be enough.

I wasn't a big fan of this signing, but not knowing what the budget limit is makes it hard to say, "I wish we got _____ instead." The more I think about this signing, the more it's growing on me.

Every player is a dice role. Hell, Tucker had a better outlook than Suzuki does now, but what do we really know about his projections? I'm pretty sure he gets more than double what Bauers got, so that alone might have been beyond Brez's reach.

We've essentially added Bauers (.874) Mead (.851) and AR (.740,) and while .740 might look low, it's a massive upgrade over Narvaez/Wong. Time will tell. 

Posted
5 hours ago, Hugh2 said:

Imagine getting a promotion at work and being put down by some of the old timers there because you don't have the same polished resume as the rest of them.  You'd kind of come off as an entitled, pompous meany. 

Imagine if we sined Suzuki as well and Bauers outperforms next year.  Imagine being the person who says "yeah but Suzuki used to be better"

I don't care what he did in 2020-2026.  I care about what he does from 2027-2030.  And so should everyone else too. 

The Sox aren’t signing Suzuki.  Even if they try to.  He didn’t relocate from Japan to sit on the bench…

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...