I don’t see the Pirates as a team chasing defensive players at all. Last year they added Brandon Lowe, Marcell Ozuna and Ryan O’Hearn, three players whose best position is DH. And they pushed defense whiz Ke’Bryan Hayes out the door in favor of offensive upgrade Nick Gonzalez. When I think of teams chasing gloves, the first team I think of is Tampa, who adds players like Ben Williamson, and Cedric Mullens to play alongside Taylor Walls, Chandler Simpson, etc.
The Athletics? They’re building the team you want. C/1b Tyler Soderstrom in LF. Adding Brent Rooker, Jeff MacNeil and Shea Langeliers. Extending Lawrence Butler. These are not glove first players in any way.
Ignore defense and pitching suffers. When pitching suffers, most teams lose. The biggest mistake I see out here is the repeated example of the two playoff games. Two game sample, yes, it’s meaningless. The Cubs and the Astros had two of the best offenses in MLB and didn’t do any better, and neither is blowing up their roster solely because of first round losses.
This doesn’t mean the Sox should ignore offense. But it probably means hetting two elite bats is just as much the fantasy tjis year as it was last year. First of all, the additions of Mead and Rutschman are already in place. And assuming Duran gets moved, we likely know who 8 of the starters are already (barring additional trades, which are actually pretty likely). Once the Sox decide where Mead fits in, they probably add either a 2b (Marte? Arraez? Lowe? Paredes? Semien? Abrams?) or a DH (Teoscar Hernandez? Arozarena? Suzuki?). DH kind of leaves the door open for numerous possibilities, although not so much on the FA market…