Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
6 minutes ago, notin said:

I agree Suzuki might and should be better.  But how much better? And is it worth what I can promise you will be a much larger contract?

You’re making excuses for Henry being cheap. It’s long overdue for him to spend some of his billions on higher quality players. 

Posted
16 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Who should he be going after in free agency?

Dubon 2/20

Morejon 4/64

Kittredge 1/6

Mark Leiter Jr 1/3

Jakob Junis 1/3

 

 

 

Posted
7 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

No Duran and Masa might add $15M to the budget, then maybe we could have afforded Suzuki over Bauers for the short term budget outlook, but it's the later years that scares the beJesus out of JH & Co..

Too bad. Sometimes you have to take a leap of faith if you actually prioritize winning rings. 
Do you think Henry really prioritizes winning over his wallet?

Posted
2 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

That’s subjectivity if I’ve ever seen it. You have no idea no one does.
 

 Many on here said a year ago said “the back end of Alonso contract was gonna be terrible”. And that “he was declining already.”All he did was play everyday, play his best 1b of his career and absolutely rake in a lineup without a lot of protection. Objectively no one knows how it would have looked in Boston. 

Many said Contreras was over the hill and not even worth the $17M we paid him.

A ton of people got upset when others called Gray a number 2. Some claimed he wasn't even a decent #3. He was our ace. Who thought Bennett was going to help, ever? Let alone 2026?

Man-o-Man, Brez made some horrible choices. NOT!

Even Suarez and Durbin did okay. IKF helped for a little while, but he was maybe the worst deal next to the inconsequential Oviedo trade.

Posted
Just now, FredLynn said:

Too bad. Sometimes you have to take a leap of faith if you actually prioritize winning rings. 
Do you think Henry really prioritizes winning over his wallet?

No, and I've answer this many times. My beef is you blaming Brez. I'm driving the blame JH wagon right next to you.

Posted
12 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

If you do research they have a hotshot 3b prospect as well. Looks like he is a year behind last name is Pena.

None of that changes that Pratt worked out and is controlled until 2035 making IKF money…

Posted
6 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Dubon 2/20

Morejon 4/64

Kittredge 1/6

Mark Leiter Jr 1/3

Jakob Junis 1/3

 

 

 

Morejon gets a lower AAV than Dustin May? 

Posted
11 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

Suzuki> Bauers. Better still, both. Get rid of Masa and Duran. 

Ok, assuming we got off both Duran AND Yoshida.So you say get both Suzuki and Bauers…. I respect that.

You still can’t sign and pay Seiya to play if/when Anthony gets injured. So you’re still 1 too heavy.  

So I believe this is the real question would you rather:

A. Sign Suzuki in right field, and trade Wilyer for an outstanding top 2-3 type starting pitcher? Essentially the bat/ Defense of Abreu for Suzuki+ quality proven SP?

B. Sit with what we have… knowing pitching is easier to obtain later if needed?

 

 

Posted
26 minutes ago, notin said:

Breslow did.

I keep asking how much better are the Sox with Alonso instead?  I’d say 1-2 wins better.  I could be convinced of 3 maybe.  That still leaves the Sox as second wild card, going to NY, giving up 18 runs in two games and season ending the same way…

Huh? HUH? Yes Breslow did, but you left out the reason why. Con Man was a  lot cheaper option, and had nothing too with the bat, or his run production. You guys are also hung up on the only 1-2 more wins.

Posted
30 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

1. Many GM couldn't afford Alonso. (Some couldn't afford Contreras either.) So, they wouldn't "rather have" someone they cant pay.

2. The Contreras deal ends earlier and STL paid off some of it. That allows for spending after Contreras leaves that wouldn't be there when Alonso is still being paid and is likely in decline.

Many GM would take Contreras over Alonso, and not just in hindsight. YES!

If you can't see that, go talk to your circle jerk clown friends and see what they say.

I’m just talking bat for bat, and run production for run production, and no contracts involved. I don’t think very many would take the Con Man let alone many, and I can see that, but just for you I’ll take a poll.

Posted
14 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

Ok, assuming we got off both Duran AND Yoshida.So you say get both Suzuki and Bauers…. I respect that.

You still can’t sign and pay Seiya to play if/when Anthony gets injured. So you’re still 1 too heavy.  

So I believe this is the real question would you rather:

A. Sign Suzuki in right field, and trade Wilyer for an outstanding top 2-3 type starting pitcher? Essentially the bat/ Defense of Abreu for Suzuki+ quality proven SP?

B. Sit with what we have… knowing pitching is easier to obtain later if needed?

 

 

I’m probably missing something here but if we get rid of Duran and Masa (two OFers) and Anthony plays (certainly not a given) then we have Anthony, Rafaela, Abreu, and Suzuki as OFers and Bauers as  DH and occasional 1B man. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Huh? HUH? Yes Breslow did, but you left out the reason why. Con Man was a  lot cheaper option, and had nothing too with the bat, or his run production. You guys are also hung up on the only 1-2 more wins.

Isn’t that what matters?  Wins? Sort of how we measure better and worse teams.

I doesn’t matter why Breslow chose Contreras over Alonso, unless you’re obsesssed solely with payroll and don’t care if the team is better.

Do you dispute the 1-2 wins? How much better do you think the Sox are with Alonso over Contreras?  This isn’t the first time Ive asked this, but I am waiting for the first time you answer.  (Unless you did and I missed it.)

 

Posted
5 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I’m just talking bat for bat, and run production for run production, and no contracts involved. I don’t think very many would take the Con Man let alone many, and I can see that, but just for you I’ll take a poll.

It’s always funny when people frequently respond to some issues with “I don’t care what other teams do”, but then rely on it as a sole argument other times.

 

Posted
26 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

No, and I've answer this many times. My beef is you blaming Brez. I'm driving the blame JH wagon right next to you.

My beef with BresLOW is lack of straightforward honesty. With Henry it’s that plus being cheap. 
The bottom line though is that whatever the reason is BresLOW hasn’t completed the job. He hasn’t put a team on the field that can compete for a ring most years. If other GMs (the Rays for example) can do it with even less money why can’t our GM do it?

Posted
14 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Many said Contreras was over the hill and not even worth the $17M we paid him.

A ton of people got upset when others called Gray a number 2. Some claimed he wasn't even a decent #3. He was our ace. Who thought Bennett was going to help, ever? Let alone 2026?

Man-o-Man, Brez made some horrible choices. NOT!

Even Suarez and Durbin did okay. IKF helped for a little while, but he was maybe the worst deal next to the inconsequential Oviedo trade.

Without moving the goal posts here…. Let’s talk about what I said and your response:

notin: “we still would have been bounced in 2 games anyway and given up 18 runs.”


my response: “you don’t know…. that’s subjective. Maybe we win 4 more games and games are in Boston” we will never know. But Alonso looks like a good signing thus far for Orioles. (So much so that anyone on team is available for trade except Alonso.)

You jump in: “Bres killed it”……. “Good value out of WC40” which I agree….. “Gray as an ace” he also started the game 2 where we got blown out in Bronx,….. “Bennett, Suarez were great” THEY DIDNT EVEN PITCH in postseason. so had zero bearing on our postseason success/ failure. 
 

You and I are on opposites sides of Alonso at 5yr 150m I wanted him…. Still do. I would rather have Alonso and WC40 than Suarez……. In 3 years when Alonso is old and terrible you’re gonna throw it in my face. But I still would have liked to have traded 1 of our 4 OFers last year (in transparency I wanted Abreu traded ,and Duran in left w/ Roman in Right field) trading Abreu for starting pitching. I was wrong on Duran. 
 

Posted
2 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

Without moving the goal posts here…. Let’s talk about what I said and your response:

notin: “we still would have been bounced in 2 games anyway and given up 18 runs.”


my response: “you don’t know…. that’s subjective. Maybe we win 4 more games and games are in Boston” we will never know. But Alonso looks like a good signing thus far for Orioles. (So much so that anyone on team is available for trade except Alonso.)

You jump in: “Bres killed it”……. “Good value out of WC40” which I agree….. “Gray as an ace” he also started the game 2 where we got blown out in Bronx,….. “Bennett, Suarez were great” THEY DIDNT EVEN PITCH in postseason. so had zero bearing on our postseason success/ failure. 
 

You and I are on opposites sides of Alonso at 5yr 150m I wanted him…. Still do. I would rather have Alonso and WC40 than Suarez……. In 3 years when Alonso is old and terrible you’re gonna throw it in my face. But I still would have liked to have traded 1 of our 4 OFers last year (in transparency I wanted Abreu traded ,and Duran in left w/ Roman in Right field) trading Abreu for starting pitching. I was wrong on Duran. 
 

It didn’t have to be Alonso OR Suarez. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

I’m probably missing something here but if we get rid of Duran and Masa (two OFers) and Anthony plays (certainly not a given) then we have Anthony, Rafaela, Abreu, and Suzuki as OFers and Bauers as  DH and occasional 1B man. 

I’m saying you’re not gonna pay Seiya to be 4th OFer….. especially when you just signed Bauers to play DH….that’s why I say it’s either A or B type scenario. Assuming you decided to sign Seiya AND Bauers.

Posted
1 minute ago, FredLynn said:

It didn’t have to be Alonso OR Suarez. 

It did though cuz JH wasn’t gonna spend like days of old. 5 yr 150m which guy you want? I know who I’d rather have. 

Posted
Just now, UtahSox said:

I’m saying you’re not gonna pay Seiya to be 4th OFer….. especially when you just signed Bauers to play DH….that’s why I say it’s either A or B type scenario. Assuming you decided to sign Seiya AND Bauers.

Why not? It’s not a bad thing to have four outfielders with talent. Look what happened last year with RA. There’s definitely room for all four on an elite team.

Posted
1 minute ago, UtahSox said:

It did though cuz JH wasn’t gonna spend like days of old. 5 yr 150m which guy you want? I know who I’d rather have. 

Both

But as you pointed out Henry is too cheap to buy the talent it takes to compete for a ring

Posted
16 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I’m just talking bat for bat, and run production for run production, and no contracts involved. I don’t think very many would take the Con Man let alone many, and I can see that, but just for you I’ll take a poll.

God, you really have zero comprehension skills.

Posted
15 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

I’m probably missing something here but if we get rid of Duran and Masa (two OFers) and Anthony plays (certainly not a given) then we have Anthony, Rafaela, Abreu, and Suzuki as OFers and Bauers as  DH and occasional 1B man. 

Suzuki signed to be the 4th OFer? 

Posted
6 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

Why not? 

It's a bad use of financial resources. You spend $$$ to make your starting lineup better, not to park a 20M bat on the bench. 

Posted
58 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

Something like that would have been honest

Something like that is delusional.  WHo hires people and then puts them down, why would anyone ever want to go work for that company? it's an absurd notion. 

Posted
8 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

It did though cuz JH wasn’t gonna spend like days of old. 

He wasn't all that big a spender, ever. Manny came with the team.

Price was the only mega deal signed.

C Crawford & Story are JH's 2nd and 3rd biggest deals.

The AGon extension was huge, but he met the same fate as Devers.

Posted
1 minute ago, mvp 78 said:

If they sign Suzuki to play OF, one of Abreu or Anthony is getting dealt. 

All these people don't like Bauers because he had an above average year, well....Suzuki had a year where he doubled any other years war.  

It's amazing, the people complaining about Bauers can't conceptualize that if Suzuki regresses back to his mean he's no more valuable than Abreu, Rafaela, and most likely Anthony. 

Posted
19 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

Without moving the goal posts here…. Let’s talk about what I said and your response:

notin: “we still would have been bounced in 2 games anyway and given up 18 runs.”


my response: “you don’t know…. that’s subjective. Maybe we win 4 more games and games are in Boston” we will never know. But Alonso looks like a good signing thus far for Orioles. (So much so that anyone on team is available for trade except Alonso.)

You jump in: “Bres killed it”……. “Good value out of WC40” which I agree….. “Gray as an ace” he also started the game 2 where we got blown out in Bronx,….. “Bennett, Suarez were great” THEY DIDNT EVEN PITCH in postseason. so had zero bearing on our postseason success/ failure. 
 

You and I are on opposites sides of Alonso at 5yr 150m I wanted him…. Still do. I would rather have Alonso and WC40 than Suarez……. In 3 years when Alonso is old and terrible you’re gonna throw it in my face. But I still would have liked to have traded 1 of our 4 OFers last year (in transparency I wanted Abreu traded ,and Duran in left w/ Roman in Right field) trading Abreu for starting pitching. I was wrong on Duran. 
 

Or just go into the season with 4 capable outfielders....oh the horror.

Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

Winter Fest is going to be lit! 

We mine as well have President Camacho as the G.M. 

Public floggings for players who underperform might help too. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...