Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
10 minutes ago, Old Red said:

$30M+. I think that’s a little exaggeration at the least. Schwaber, and Alonso didn’t get $30M+ for what they’ve done

Do the math, clown:

$155M/5 for Alonso.

$150M/5 Schwarber

Posted
1 minute ago, moonslav59 said:

Behind on things?

I guess that's plus to be behind on idiocy.

Who says you’re behind? Survey says different.🤭🤮

Posted
18 minutes ago, Old Red said:

$30M+. I think that’s a little exaggeration at the least. Schwaber, and Alonso didn’t get $30M+ for what they’ve done, which is a lot more than Bauers has done in just 1 year, so I think you’re a little of base on that $30M+.

I Don't believe it's an exaggeration in the least bit.  I was very deliberate. 

Every year I take FanGraphs average war and multiply it by the market rate, which has almost consistently moved up 10% per Anum recently.  If we worked backwards, last year Schwarber average 2.6 FWar, that would pay him 20 per, but if you believed his 2023 was an albatross year then he averaged just a hair under 4 WAR which pays the man 31.6 million per in last year’s market.  He got 30 per. 

Alonso was worth about 25 by that model, but he got much more than that.  He's getting closer to 11 per WAR.  If Bauers was paid 11 million per war he would have been paid $39 million after last season.  Why wouldn't a team go out and pay him 2/60????

If you weight Bauers earlier seasons, he's not worth that, I admit that which is why I repeatedly have said repeatedly that "IF" that's the keyword here IF his 2026 was a true unlocking then the deal is well worth the money

I predict free agents will get paid about 8.5 War per season this year. If a team was just paying for his 2026 for one year, he'd get 3.6X11 $39.6 million.  Sox pretty much paid that plus 18 million for 4 more years. 

But let’s be fairer and weight Bauers last 3 seasons, which equates to 1.5 FWar per year, that will pay $8.5X1.5 $12.75 per year.  For four years that 51 million dollars. 

Free market value for Bauers might be $51 million dollars. Sox paid a extra $7 million banking that something he showed in 2026 was real. 

You can criticize the Sox all day long for not doing more, past and present, but in a vacuum, this isn't a bad gamble at all.

Posted
1 minute ago, Hugh2 said:

I Don't believe it's an exaggeration in the least bit.  I was very deliberate. 

Every year I take FanGraphs average war and multiply it by the market rate, which has almost consistently moved up 10% per Anum recently.  If we worked backwards, last year Schwarber average 2.6 FWar, that would pay him 20 per, but if you believed his 2023 was an albatross year then he averaged just a hair under 4 WAR which pays the man 31.6 million per in last year’s market.  He got 30 per. 

Alonso was worth about 25 by that model, but he got much more than that.  He's getting closer to 11 per WAR.  If Bauers was paid 11 million per war he would have been paid $39 million after last season.  Why wouldn't a team go out and pay him 2/60????

If you weight Bauers earlier seasons, he's not worth that, I admit that which is why I repeatedly have said repeatedly that "IF" that's the keyword here IF his 2026 was a true unlocking then the deal is well worth the money

I predict free agents will get paid about 8.5 War per season this year. If a team was just paying for his 2026 for one year, he'd get 3.6X11 $39.6 million.  Sox pretty much paid that plus 18 million for 4 more years. 

But let’s be fairer and weight Bauers last 3 seasons, which equates to 1.5 FWar per year, that will pay $8.5X1.5 $12.75 per year.  For four years that 51 million dollars. 

Free market value for Bauers might be $51 million dollars. Sox paid a extra $7 million banking that something he showed in 2026 was real. 

You can criticize the Sox all day long for not doing more, past and present, but in a vacuum, this isn't a bad gamble at all.

I don’t go by any models, or any kind of War, or any of that kind of stuff, and I don’t think the markets are set by that. Schwaber gets paid for the homers he hits, and whatever RBI is the result, and the same with Alonso. I got it the key word was 2026 for Bauers, but I don’t seeing teams paying him $30M+ for what he did for just 1 year. No $58M isn’t  an expensive gamble, but it’s $58M that won’t be spent on something bigger, and better. 

Posted
7 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I don’t go by any models, or any kind of War, or any of that kind of stuff, and I don’t think the markets are set by that. Schwaber gets paid for the homers he hits, and whatever RBI is the result, and the same with Alonso. I got it the key word was 2026 for Bauers, but I don’t seeing teams paying him $30M+ for what he did for just 1 year. No $58M isn’t  an expensive gamble, but it’s $58M that won’t be spent on something bigger, and better. 

The markets are 100% set by that and using fangraph war to predict contracts is insanely, scarely accurate. 

I get that YOU don't like that, but you know teams do.  Teams all have models that drive what they pay for players.  That's just the way the game is played in 2026, teams are model driven.  Like it or not that's just an objective truth Red. The fact of the matter is, if a team was just paying for one year of Bauer and they thought he could repeat his 2026 again he would get paid 30+ in this market.  He just would. 

You want bigger and better? ok, me too.  I still want a SS and wouldn't mind upgrading at C/LF/2B as well.  I'll take any upgrade really to upgrade the lineup.  But what better upgrades are there in this market? I'm not saying there isn't but it's slim pickings.  You can't really definitively put together a list of better options. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

The markets are 100% set by that and using fangraph war to predict contracts is insanely, scarely accurate. 

I get that YOU don't like that, but you know teams do.  Teams all have models that drive what they pay for players.  That's just the way the game is played in 2026, teams are model driven.  Like it or not that's just an objective truth Red. The fact of the matter is, if a team was just paying for one year of Bauer and they thought he could repeat his 2026 again he would get paid 30+ in this market.  He just would. 

You want bigger and better? ok, me too.  I still want a SS and wouldn't mind upgrading at C/LF/2B as well.  I'll take any upgrade really to upgrade the lineup.  But what better upgrades are there in this market? I'm not saying there isn't but it's slim pickings.  You can't really definitively put together a list of better options. 

Slim pickings I agree with, and teams knew it was going o be that way this year a year ago. I still don’t think contracts are as complicated as any thing more than the homers, and RBI guys like Schwarber, and Alonso produce, and how much some owners want to pay.

Posted
3 hours ago, notin said:

Yoshida’s OPS in the JPPL and JPCL was over .100 points better than Sato’s.  But you think Sato deserves more?

No, Yoshida deserves less; he didn't hit 40 homers or win the Triple Crown.

But Sato's market value in today's unaffordabilities was established by Murakami and Okamoto... though it's possible the Masa mistake has affected the entire Japanese market for batters transferring to the majors.

Then again, there have only been two position players who were instant stars that I can remember... Ichiro and Ohtani; who'd I miss?

Posted
11 minutes ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

Then again, there have only been two position players who were instant stars that I can remember... Ichiro and Ohtani; who'd I miss?

Matsui did pretty well.

Posted
2 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

The feeble-minded clown said it, and ten minutes laters his mushy mind forgets he said it.

I was talking bout being behind on idiocy, which you’re not.You’ve been analyzed by people I don’t even know, and it all comes it comes to the same conclusion. If only it was as simple, or good  as a feeble-minded clown, which it isn’t. 🤭

Posted
1 hour ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

No, Yoshida deserves less; he didn't hit 40 homers or win the Triple Crown.

But Sato's market value in today's unaffordabilities was established by Murakami and Okamoto... though it's possible the Masa mistake has affected the entire Japanese market for batters transferring to the majors.

Then again, there have only been two position players who were instant stars that I can remember... Ichiro and Ohtani; who'd I miss?

Hideki Matsui? 
 

Arguments exist for Seiya Suzuki as well…

Posted
1 hour ago, Old Red said:

I was talking bout being behind on idiocy, which you’re not.You’ve been analyzed by people I don’t even know, and it all comes it comes to the same conclusion. If only it was as simple, or good  as a feeble-minded clown, which it isn’t. 🤭

Show this post to your feeble-minded wingmen.

Posted
1 minute ago, Hitch said:

Jesus Christ, will you two just put each other on ignore or add each other on social media and send each other messages. 👨‍🍼

i second the motion.

Posted
7 hours ago, Old Red said:

I don’t go by any models, or any kind of War, or any of that kind of stuff, and I don’t think the markets are set by that. Schwaber gets paid for the homers he hits, and whatever RBI is the result, and the same with Alonso. I got it the key word was 2026 for Bauers, but I don’t seeing teams paying him $30M+ for what he did for just 1 year. No $58M isn’t  an expensive gamble, but it’s $58M that won’t be spent on something bigger, and better. 

Like who?

Skubal is certainly is bigger and better.  But he is looking for what? $40-60mill AAV, depending on length? Maybe $70mill if it’s a really short deal? (Kyle Tucker got $60mill, so it’s not unrealistic. Not necessarily smart, but not unrealistic.)

But for hitters?  It’s easy to argue Suzuki and Arozarena are better, but which one signs for $58mill?  Who else in this class?  There are certainly some arguments.  Chisholm? Torres? Ty France?  Are they that much better (if at all) and available for that money and years?

Who are these better hitters available for that deal?

Posted
10 hours ago, notin said:

Like who?

Skubal is certainly is bigger and better.  But he is looking for what? $40-60mill AAV, depending on length? Maybe $70mill if it’s a really short deal? (Kyle Tucker got $60mill, so it’s not unrealistic. Not necessarily smart, but not unrealistic.)

But for hitters?  It’s easy to argue Suzuki and Arozarena are better, but which one signs for $58mill?  Who else in this class?  There are certainly some arguments.  Chisholm? Torres? Ty France?  Are they that much better (if at all) and available for that money and years?

Who are these better hitters available for that deal?

I was in favor of adding Arozarena, but don't like what I'm reading about his friction with teammates in Seattle. Same with Marte, who has had public incidents for two years now in Arizona.

For better or worse, this is Contreras' team now, and the last thing Boston needs are new guys who may tangle with his fiery leadership. 

Plus, it makes me tired. Be kind, unwind... but don't rewind.

Posted
13 minutes ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

I was in favor of adding Arozarena, but don't like what I'm reading about his friction with teammates in Seattle. Same with Marte, who has had public incidents for two years now in Arizona.

For better or worse, this is Contreras' team now, and the last thing Boston needs are new guys who may tangle with his fiery leadership. 

Plus, it makes me tired. Be kind, unwind... but don't rewind.

I think the Sox are locked in (to a degree) at catcher (Rutschman), 1b (Contreras), 2b (Mead), 3b (Durbin), LF (Anthony), CF (Rafaela), RF (Abreu) and DH (Bauers).

SS is the last question.  Story? Arias? A player you can get for Arias? 

Posted

I think it's Story for SS. 

I've advocated for Arias to be the starting SS on open day but I've heard and argument against that and the more I think about it the more on board with it I am. 

I think Arias is going to be a very good player, but I'm not sure he's going to be a superstar that people are making him out to be.  I think he's going to be a .270 guy with 10-15 HR's and very good defense.  That's a good player at SS but some people are going to be dissapointed he's not a super star because of how highly he's ranked. 

I also think he shouldn't just be handed the job, he should earn it.  I think they should learn from handing the keys over to Kristian Cambell too soon and not make that mistake with Arias. 

Franklin should be on speed dial however, the moment Mead/Story gets injured he's up.  Or if he's mashing and the DH goes down and one of Story/Mead moves there then he's up. If he continues to hit, his time will come. 

If Story does what he seemingly does every year, Arias time will come sooner.  If Story produces like he does in 2025 then he regains value.  One way or another.....Arias time will come. 

Posted
11 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I think it's Story for SS. 

I've advocated for Arias to be the starting SS on open day but I've heard and argument against that and the more I think about it the more on board with it I am. 

I think Arias is going to be a very good player, but I'm not sure he's going to be a superstar that people are making him out to be.  I think he's going to be a .270 guy with 10-15 HR's and very good defense.  That's a good player at SS but some people are going to be dissapointed he's not a super star because of how highly he's ranked. 

I also think he shouldn't just be handed the job, he should earn it.  I think they should learn from handing the keys over to Kristian Cambell too soon and not make that mistake with Arias. 

Franklin should be on speed dial however, the moment Mead/Story gets injured he's up.  Or if he's mashing and the DH goes down and one of Story/Mead moves there then he's up. If he continues to hit, his time will come. 

If Story does what he seemingly does every year, Arias time will come sooner.  If Story produces like he does in 2025 then he regains value.  One way or another.....Arias time will come. 

Arias is the shining bauble next in line just like Casas was at one time, and then came RAF Man, Mayer, Teel, KC, and little A. That should be the core of the team right now, but it is not. Fans fall in love with these suspects before they even get to Boston, and they don’t ALL work out.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Arias is the shining bauble next in line just like Casas was at one time, and then came RAF Man, Mayer, Teel, KC, and little A. That should be the core of the team right now, but it is not. Fans fall in love with these suspects before they even get to Boston, and they don’t ALL work out.

As someone who is a prospect lover, and reads more soxprospects than I do big league stuff I can personally attest that the biggest prospect people know that more than anyone else in this world. 

A good organization needs prospects, they need to draft them, develop them, break them into the big leagues etc etc etc.  And prospects will also break your heart. 

Posted
19 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I think it's Story for SS. 

I've advocated for Arias to be the starting SS on open day but I've heard and argument against that and the more I think about it the more on board with it I am. 

I think Arias is going to be a very good player, but I'm not sure he's going to be a superstar that people are making him out to be.  I think he's going to be a .270 guy with 10-15 HR's and very good defense.  That's a good player at SS but some people are going to be dissapointed he's not a super star because of how highly he's ranked. 

I also think he shouldn't just be handed the job, he should earn it.  I think they should learn from handing the keys over to Kristian Cambell too soon and not make that mistake with Arias. 

Franklin should be on speed dial however, the moment Mead/Story gets injured he's up.  Or if he's mashing and the DH goes down and one of Story/Mead moves there then he's up. If he continues to hit, his time will come. 

If Story does what he seemingly does every year, Arias time will come sooner.  If Story produces like he does in 2025 then he regains value.  One way or another.....Arias time will come. 

Yeah, his upside is Otto Lopez or Geraldo Perdomo. Does he have a 5 fWAR season? IDK. It may take a few years and I wouldn't expect him to have a bunch. Out of the gate, he's probably a 2.5 fWAR guy just because of the D. 

Posted
15 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Arias is the shining bauble next in line just like Casas was at one time, and then came RAF Man, Mayer, Teel, KC, and little A. That should be the core of the team right now, but it is not. Fans fall in love with these suspects before they even get to Boston, and they don’t ALL work out.

Who is honestly complaining if he follows Rafaela's career path? The problem with Casas, Anthony and Teel is that they got injured. Hard to project that for any guy, even a vet.

Posted
15 hours ago, Old Red said:

Slim pickings I agree with, and teams knew it was going o be that way this year a year ago. I still don’t think contracts are as complicated as any thing more than the homers, and RBI guys like Schwarber, and Alonso produce, and how much some owners want to pay.

I think They use the model just as a base then teams go from there. Like the Os. They said we believe Alonso is worth more than the model, 25m per, and we believe 5m more per is still a good deal. They just used the model as a starting point with him. 
personally, I was all in on giving him 5/150 to come here last year. Well worth it. He’d hit 50 playing 81 in Fenway.

Posted
12 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

As someone who is a prospect lover, and reads more soxprospects than I do big league stuff I can personally attest that the biggest prospect people know that more than anyone else in this world. 

A good organization needs prospects, they need to draft them, develop them, break them into the big leagues etc etc etc.  And prospects will also break your heart. 

It was very risky for JH to put all of his eggs into "the Big Three." I don't think "prospect people" thought that was a great idea. They needed to be surrounded by players that were ready to compete and veterans that were strong voices in the clubhouse. The Sox didn't do that. 

Posted
10 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

As someone who is a prospect lover, and reads more soxprospects than I do big league stuff I can personally attest that the biggest prospect people know that more than anyone else in this world. 

A good organization needs prospects, they need to draft them, develop them, break them into the big leagues etc etc etc.  And prospects will also break your heart. 

I get what you’re saying, and I saw all the ones  I mentioned play at least twice in Portland, and I heard all the talk while they were there. All I’m saying is they all don’t live up to the hype no matter how muchYou want them to.

Posted
13 hours ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

No, Yoshida deserves less; he didn't hit 40 homers or win the Triple Crown.

But Sato's market value in today's unaffordabilities was established by Murakami and Okamoto... though it's possible the Masa mistake has affected the entire Japanese market for batters transferring to the majors.

Then again, there have only been two position players who were instant stars that I can remember... Ichiro and Ohtani; who'd I miss?

Matsui?

Posted
2 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Who is honestly complaining if he follows Rafaela's career path? The problem with Casas, Anthony and Teel is that they got injured. Hard to project that for any guy, even a vet.

I agree on following RAF Man’s path whom I’ve never had a problem with as some have, because  His bat wasn’t good enough.

Posted
6 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

I think They use the model just as a base then teams go from there. Like the Os. They said we believe Alonso is worth more than the model, 25m per, and we believe 5m more per is still a good deal. They just used the model as a starting point with him. 
personally, I was all in on giving him 5/150 to come here last year. Well worth it. He’d hit 50 playing 81 in Fenway.

Bingo! Alonso was there for the taking, and the need for his bat is still there, and the picking is a lot slimmer. Botched opportunity by Brez.

Posted
7 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

It was very risky for JH to put all of his eggs into "the Big Three." I don't think "prospect people" thought that was a great idea. They needed to be surrounded by players that were ready to compete and veterans that were strong voices in the clubhouse. The Sox didn't do that. 

You nailed it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...