Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
8 minutes ago, JimEd said:

he sucked with the Dodgers, he sucked with the Red Sox, he sucked with the Cardinals, he sucked with the Brewers and he will suck with the White Sox. it's what he does.

If he'd sucked for us like he did for the Cards, we'd have been a better team.

Posted
4 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

I don't think so.  If DLC is available, maybe.  But I calculated our OPS based on FG projections, using .658 for Story, and .680 for the bench using 10% of the PAs.  I come up with .748.  That would've been 3rd in MLB last year.

I think Breslow might go overboard for Neto and maybe even Lopez…

Posted
4 hours ago, Old Red said:

Yes, but he didn’t make the club out of ST, and he had nowhere near the expectations on him going into last year as little A did. I’ve seen everyone come up since Yaz, and NO ONE has had the expectations placed on them that little A had last year, and when those expectations don’t happen then the results aren’t usually very good. A magic carpet ride saved them last year. 


Did any prospects get hyped in 1960?  And if they did, any before they reached AAA? 
 

Baseball America Top 100 lists were 30 years away, and obviously no Internet.  Who was hyping those A ballers in 1955?  Getting that low down on Herb Score?
 

In fact, it seems like for a long time no one really talked much about any prospect still in the minors.  Before 1989/1990 when salaries started getting out of control (Puckett hit $3’mill, and the dominoes fell), prospects were not the trade capital they have been for the last 37 years.  Oh they were occasionally traded.  But salaries were not to the point that they needed occasional dumping so a lot more trades were player for player…
 

Posted
2 hours ago, Hugh2 said:

Oh ok, Clemens was before my time.

i also think the times are different in how accurate prospect ranking are, how they’re ranked, how much attention they get, media. Social media etc etc.  

Certainly the fans access to information, videos, stats and rankings has exploded since the days of Evans, Rice and Lynn, and even from the days of Clemens and then Nomar. It adds to the building of expectations for prospects like never before, but I still don't get the issue. Some turn out fine- some do not. Most fans know this.

So, a GM like Brez trades for Contreras, instead of signing Alosno, and most of us are bummed, while still others think of him as an idiot. He ended up beating expectations. Vaughn Grissom fell way short. Mayer fell way short. I keep asking, so what?

Look, I get it, If Brez thought Anthony was going to replace Devers on offense, he was wrong, at least for 2026. If fans expected it, they were wrong too, but it was really a guess for all of us, and to me, anyone who thinks it was more than a guess doesn't know just how unpredictable baseball is.

Take a look at the top money FA signings over the last few decades: they are riddled with under expected production and downright massive failures. I'm not seeing how putting hopes in know players vs unknown players and watching some do well, some okay and others poorly is worth making such a big deal out of the fact that the big three have not done squat, so far. What's wrong with the fact that fans and the FO had higher expectations that what we got? I'm more pissed at the FO's expectations for Story, Yoshida, HRam, Sandoval (Pablito &  Patrick), Kluber, Richards, Paxton and on and on... These guys got some media hype, too. Some fans got a little excited, too.

I just don't see anything wrong with getting hopes up on players on your favorite team. Maybe they are too high or too unrealistic. Maybe some drunk fan at a Sea Dogs game said Roman was about to begin an MVP empire. Who the Efff cares? (Not me.)

 

Posted
21 minutes ago, notin said:

I think Breslow might go overboard for Neto and maybe even Lopez…

I would like Lopez, but I kinda agree with BTV: Arias is worth more. I'd want more than just Lopez for Arias, but maybe a one-for-one deal would work for both teams.

Lopez does have 3 years left. 

Posted
3 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

Are we done with the idea that May was a bad acquisition yet?

We rip on May, myself included.  But the man does have four World Series rings, including the last three.

Yes, he was no longer on the Dodgers for the 2025 World Series, but as he did pitch for them that year, he still gets a ring…

Posted
6 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

Hits RH, but the Sox do need a LHB to balance the lineup that is unable to hit RHP (22nd in MLB). 

I am counting on Anthony and Abreu to cover that base.....hopefully.

Posted
51 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

I am counting on Anthony and Abreu to cover that base.....hopefully.

Abreu had an unexpected reverse splits this year (.735/.854) He should hit RHPs better in '27. His career splits are .794/.746

It's hard to know what to expect from Anthony.

Mead hit .816 v R in 2026.

Bauers .863.

Contreras .878 (.966 v L) Career .800/.882

Without Anthony it looks like we have 4 batters at about .800 or more v R.

Posted
11 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

It's the one central point that comes closest to a consensus or site members.

This club excels in support pieces. We need a  big bopper to compliment everyone else.

And just to shut us all up, Breslow said yesterday "it's hard to envision" adding another impact bat.

Maybe he should eat some mushrooms before reading this forum again, because envision is what we do best.

Posted
28 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Abreu had an unexpected reverse splits this year (.735/.854) He should hit RHPs better in '27. His career splits are .794/.746

It's hard to know what to expect from Anthony.

Mead hit .816 v R in 2026.

Bauers .863.

Contreras .878 (.966 v L) Career .800/.882

Without Anthony it looks like we have 4 batters at about .800 or more v R.

I'm actually not terribly worried about the split between hitting LHP/RHP on this team.  If we have a decent bill of health and performance I think we should be much better than we were last year. 

Posted

I remember the Nomar hype train being very, very large. Andrew Benintendi for sure. Mo Vaughn had tshirts before he was even called up. 

Posted
47 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Abreu had an unexpected reverse splits this year (.735/.854) He should hit RHPs better in '27. His career splits are .794/.746

So we should expect him to crater against LHP and hit better against RHP again? 

Posted
12 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

I remember saying the same about Martin Perez and Springs, after they did very well the minute they left Boston.

Since '26, that year after he left is the only year he had an FIP under 4. Springs got a one year bump in TBR and then blew his arm out unsurprisingly. Sox did really like Springs when he was here and tried to turn him into the closer in '20. 

Posted
12 hours ago, notin said:

I think Breslow might go overboard for Neto and maybe even Lopez…

Breslow last couple trades/ FA acquisitions have followed a trend on Savant. Mead/ Bauers both looked really good analytically. I don’t believe Neto is option, bad defense, so much swing and miss, lower OBP, he looks like a younger version of Story.
 

Otto Lopez could definitely be on Breslow’s radar based on analytics fit. 

An out of right field name I could see Bres go after is cooper Pratt with Jesus Made/ Pena waiting in the wings maybe Brewers say yes? We know Bres wants Red Sox to Al Brewers.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

And just to shut us all up, Breslow said yesterday "it's hard to envision" adding another impact bat.

Maybe he should eat some mushrooms before reading this forum again, because envision is what we do best.

Maybe he's looking at a pitcher.

BTV accepts: 

Campbell + $3M x 6 yrs ($18M)

Duran

Primera

for

Logan Gilbert

(We keep Arias, Gonzales, Godbout and Valera. We lose no starters, unless you count5ed Duran to beat out Anthony in LF.)

I'd add Sogard (worth $8M on BTV) and lessen the cash given to offset KC, if SEA wants him. I doubt they want 3 guys on the 40 for one.

BTV also accepts:

Duran, Sogard & Gasper

for

Gilbert & S Dominguez (RP)

 

Posted
17 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

I don't think so.  If DLC is available, maybe.  But I calculated our OPS based on FG projections, using .658 for Story, and .680 for the bench using 10% of the PAs.  I come up with .748.  That would've been 3rd in MLB last year.

I like you settling for top 3 a lot more than I like you settling for top 10.

Posted
47 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

So we should expect him to crater against LHP and hit better against RHP again? 

I'm still waiting for his "bust out" season, so I'm not expecting any craters. I could could see his split v L go down some while vs RHP spike to the point he ends up over .800 overall, for the first time. If he hits .850 we could have a special season.

Posted
48 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

I remember the Nomar hype train being very, very large. Andrew Benintendi for sure. Mo Vaughn had tshirts before he was even called up. 

Epstein always talked up Pedroia as a future stud, but when we finally saw his first impressions it was like, "This guy -- really?" Nowadays there'd be a lot more hype for a first team All-American MVP coming out of Arizona State.

I remember reading that Yaz had a tough start because he wasn't instantly Ted Williams, the guy he was supposed to replace in Boston (as if anyone could). It only took seven years in the majors before Carl became a better all-around ballplayer than Ted ever was...

... unless having the highest career On Base Percentage in the history of baseball automatically negates all other skills at the pinnacle of greatness.

Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

I remember the Nomar hype train being very, very large. Andrew Benintendi for sure. Mo Vaughn had tshirts before he was even called up. 

Lots of guys have had hype, but how many were there talk of being the face of the franchise, and an MVP candidate in his first full year. Lynn burst on the scene, but he wasn’t to be the face of the franchise like little A was. Nobody had more pressure on them as Yaz did at age 21, because he was replacing Ted. little A was as I read  a perfect storm between the talent evaluators , the Boston press, and the Red Sox themselves who hyped, and placed the expectations on little A.

Posted
1 hour ago, UtahSox said:

Breslow last couple trades/ FA acquisitions have followed a trend on Savant. Mead/ Bauers both looked really good analytically. I don’t believe Neto is option, bad defense, so much swing and miss, lower OBP, he looks like a younger version of Story.
 

Otto Lopez could definitely be on Breslow’s radar based on analytics fit. 

An out of right field name I could see Bres go after is cooper Pratt with Jesus Made/ Pena waiting in the wings maybe Brewers say yes? We know Bres wants Red Sox to Al Brewers.

 

The Brewers extended Pratt for 8 years $51mill prior to his MLB debut.  There is absolutely no reason whatsoever for them to even consider trading him, especially to clear the path for 19 year old Jesus Made.  If the Brewers get to the point of trading Pratt or Made, they are more likely to move Made.  (But most likely to push him to 3b.)

Neto somehow put together some defensive analytics that looked good last year, and he is a prior target for Breslow.

Lopez is just good at everything.  I actually would not be surprised if the Sox dealt Arias for him at all, BTV values be damned…

Posted
35 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Maybe he's looking at a pitcher.

BTV accepts: 

Campbell + $3M x 6 yrs ($18M)

Duran

Primera

for

Logan Gilbert

(We keep Arias, Gonzales, Godbout and Valera. We lose no starters, unless you count5ed Duran to beat out Anthony in LF.)

I'd add Sogard (worth $8M on BTV) and lessen the cash given to offset KC, if SEA wants him. I doubt they want 3 guys on the 40 for one.

BTV also accepts:

Duran, Sogard & Gasper

for

Gilbert & S Dominguez (RP)

 

BTV accepts anything by value only. Of course it has NO clue to wants, needs, or acceptance from the teams themselves. MH can do the same thing.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Old Red said:

BTV accepts anything by value only. Of course it has NO clue to wants, needs, or acceptance from the teams themselves. 

Of course. This has been known and discussed numerous times. You are 5 years behind.

Posted
7 minutes ago, Old Red said:

BTV accepts anything by value only. Of course it has NO clue to wants, needs, or acceptance from the teams themselves. MH can do the same thing.

Fans have been proposing trades for decades with no idea what teams want AND without any ideas on value.  How is that better?

Posted
5 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Of course. This has been known and discussed numerous times. You are 5 years behind.

I would rather be 5 years behind just on here than suggest trades that NEVER happen. There are also reasons those trades NEVER happen.

Posted
10 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I would rather be 5 years behind just on here than suggest trades that NEVER happen. There are also reasons those trades NEVER happen.

There's countless reasons why any trade may or may not happen.  Not every trade that doesn't happen doesn't mean it wasn't a plausible trade and I'd rather explore possibilities and be aware of what may be out there for the team to improve than just complain about players and never offer any solutions of my own.

Disclaimer: I'm not aiming this directly at you. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Hugh2 said:

There's countless reasons why any trade may or may not happen.  Not every trade that doesn't happen doesn't mean it wasn't a plausible trade and I'd rather explore possibilities and be aware of what may be out there for the team to improve than just complain about players and never offer any solutions of my own.

Disclaimer: I'm not aiming this directly at you. 

I think most of the trade suggestions on here aren’t plausible, because most of the time they are just trying to unload players they don’t want on the Red Sox anymore onto other teams, and that’s why they never happen. If you were a fan of the team on the other side of the trade you wouldn’t except it either.if it’s aimed at me, or not meh.

Posted
37 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I would rather be 5 years behind just on here than suggest trades that NEVER happen. There are also reasons those trades NEVER happen.

Several reasons, I'm sure.

I'm not suggesting them as predictions, but that's something to complex for you to grasp.

Posted
1 hour ago, UtahSox said:

Breslow last couple trades/ FA acquisitions have followed a trend on Savant. Mead/ Bauers both looked really good analytically. I don’t believe Neto is option, bad defense, so much swing and miss, lower OBP, he looks like a younger version of Story.
 

Otto Lopez could definitely be on Breslow’s radar based on analytics fit. 

An out of right field name I could see Bres go after is cooper Pratt with Jesus Made/ Pena waiting in the wings maybe Brewers say yes? We know Bres wants Red Sox to Al Brewers.

 

He’s not going after anyone of significance. I hope Bauers works out but he has sucked for most of his career. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...