Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
Yeah. Benki has only been worth 6.4 fWAR the last 2 seasons. Conforto has been worth a whopping 6.7 fWAR. Worlds of difference
Benintendi is the better fielder and much better base runner. Confortois a much better power hitter. Also, it was only in the second half of last year that he was fully recovered from his shoulder surgery.
  • Replies 2.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted (edited)
Verdugo wasn't a part of that. He was there, but he was drinking at the party but not involved in the sexual assault.

 

MVP is spot on with this the kid was in another room the young lady said he had no knowledge of or participated in the crime ....move the f*** on we all had run ins with dip shits at party’s it’s freaking disgusting to smear this kid because some ass hat projected his guilt in a column yet the victim said otherwise.Stop this BS smear on Verdugo it’s bordering on slandering and demolishing his reputation before he even puts on the cap .

Edited by Swiharts Ghost
Posted
Benintendi is the better fielder and much better base runner. Confortois a much better power hitter. Also, it was only in the second half of last year that he was fully recovered from his shoulder surgery.

 

 

A700 Benny has about the prettiest swing I’ve ever seen this includes Jr .I just wish that someone like JDM could help that swing power up .I watch the kid and either he’s really weak through the turn in the hips or really lacks the raw power .I hope he can show us that pop we all hoped for .

Community Moderator
Posted
I don't think the Red Sox can turn back from this deal, even if their return goes down.

 

I would agree. It would be quite the PR nightmare. Those who wanted Mookie to stay would still be pissed. Those who wanted to get under the lux tax would now be pissed.

Posted
The Twins are unlikely to trade two Top 100 prospects for Kenta Maeda.

 

Then I’m on the phone to the Dodgers and telling them we need Gray and we will still be keep Brusdar I need a starter for Mookie with years of control and front end stuff.Dodgers either play or we sit on this deal .

Community Moderator
Posted
MVP is spot on with this the kid was in another room the young lady said he had no knowledge of or participated in the crime ....move the f*** on we all had run ins with dip shits at party’s it’s freaking disgusting to smear this kid because some ass hat projected his guilt in a column yet the victim said otherwise.Stop this BS smear on Verdugo it’s bordering on slandering and demolishing his reputation before he even puts on the cap .

 

The problem I've seen is that a lot of the newer articles ignore where the original source states that it was Baldwin who committed the assault and that it ended when the other players walked in. There's a reason Baldwin is out of baseball and Verdugo isn't.

Community Moderator
Posted
Then I’m on the phone to the Dodgers and telling them we need Gray and we will still be keep Brusdar I need a starter for Mookie with years of control and front end stuff.Dodgers either play or we sit on this deal .

 

Terrible idea.

Community Moderator
Posted
Because its such a fantastic deal?

 

Honestly, the deal is fine enough. If Brusdar's arm isn't ready to fall off, you just go through the deal. Maybe hold out for a B level prospect?

Posted
Verdugo wasn't a part of that. He was there, but he was drinking at the party but not involved in the sexual assault.

 

So was he the guy filming it? How many 'parties' have you attended where your two buddies (I believe there were only 4 people there at the time, right?) raped a drunk, drug-addled teenager and you stood by and did nothing? (Sorry I'm vague on the details here; that story was so revolting I have no interest in going back to it.)

Community Moderator
Posted
So was he the guy filming it? How many 'parties' have you attended where your two buddies (I believe there were only 4 people there at the time, right?) raped a drunk, drug-addled teenager and you stood by and did nothing? (Sorry I'm vague on the details here; that story was so revolting I have no interest in going back to it.)

 

Oh, you're vague on the details, but keep on going there...

 

The allegation is that there were a bunch of underage people drinking. There were roughly 4 Dodgers players there. As one girl was blacking out, Baldwin was fondling her. The other players walked in and Baldwin stopped. That's the entire story. There's no indication that Verdugo was assaulting her.

Posted
No way we get Brusdar plus another pitcher, unless it's some grade C prospect. Most likely, we either keep B or have him replaced with a genuine young starter.
Posted
No way we get Brusdar plus another pitcher, unless it's some grade C prospect. Most likely, we either keep B or have him replaced with a genuine young starter.

 

Possibly from another team?

Posted
No way we get Brusdar plus another pitcher, unless it's some grade C prospect. Most likely, we either keep B or have him replaced with a genuine young starter.

 

Bring in Cincinnati to take Maeda and we get Hunter Greene? Similarly ranked SP to Graterol...

Posted (edited)

Ah yes....and we thought the Iowa Caucus was a cluster.

 

The only thing I don't get is that everything I read when the deal was announced was that Gatorade WAS now a relief pitcher. So was the deal structured around him being a starter? Is his arm/shoulder so screwed up that even being a relief pitcher is suspect and by what measure or standard does one determine when a guy crosses the line between reliever and starter?

 

I don't think the Sox are going to get satisfaction out of this.

 

Is there any part of MLB that is not entirely and completely f***ed up other than the fans desire to see them play.

Edited by jung
Posted
Honestly, the deal is fine enough. If Brusdar's arm isn't ready to fall off, you just go through the deal. Maybe hold out for a B level prospect?

 

Man why would you settle for a s*** sandwich ? This deal is on Blooms resume forever no flipping way if I’m in his shoes do I let this go through hell I’d call Sandiego today !!! Screw the twins the Dodgers the Angels sooooo what !!! We are giving up a Hall of Famer type talent are any of them ?....NOOOOO so do what’s best and call it off NOW

Posted
Alright guys we don't need 10 threads about Mookie Betts. I'll leave this one and the curse of Mookie Betts thread up, but please stop making new ones regarding the same deal
Posted
Ah yes....and we thought the Iowa Caucus was a cluster.

 

The only thing I don't get is that everything I read when the deal was announced was that Gatorade WAS now a relief pitcher. So was the deal structured around him being a starter? Is his arm/shoulder so screwed up that even being a relief pitcher is suspect and by what measure or standard does one determine when a guy crosses the line between reliever and starter?

 

I don't think the Sox are going to get satisfaction out of this.

 

Is there any part of MLB that is not entirely and completely f***ed up other than the fans desire to see them play.

Kids what 21 right already had TJ ? And he’s getting traded for Mookie .I would say we where told medicals clear with minor scar tissue but in reality that impinge we are all being told about is a shoulder issue like a tear .No way in Hell can Mr Brusdar be anything more than filler on a trade of this magnitude.

Posted (edited)
Alright guys we don't need 10 threads about Mookie Betts. I'll leave this one and the curse of Mookie Betts thread up, but please stop making new ones regarding the same deal

 

 

Ok but good discussion today

Edited by Swiharts Ghost
Community Moderator
Posted
Alright guys we don't need 10 threads about Mookie Betts. I'll leave this one and the curse of Mookie Betts thread up, but please stop making new ones regarding the same deal

 

That's what I've been saying!!!

Posted
The Deal has been held up due to concerns about Brusdal's health. I'm guessing we are now holding out for a sweetner to the deal. Either a better pitching prospect who is still healthy, or an add on. Like we eat less of Price's contract in order to accept damaged goods. But if the guy is damaged goods, I'd want to swap the prospect.
Posted

So there is some goo-gah coming out of MLB Network that both are true. The Sox valued Gatorade as a starter in the deal and the Twins valued him as a relief pitcher.

 

That is a train wreck waiting to happen.

 

If true that each team had its own perspective on the player in the deal how can that be and by what standard is a pitcher deemed a starter or a relief pitcher? What happens if Gatorade ever starts again if the Sox get added compensation in the deal? Seems to me that Gatorade has to be cut entirely out of the deal and another player added as this is leading to an impossible situation.

 

Bloom or Bust!

Posted
So there is some goo-gah coming out of MLB Network that both are true. The Sox valued Gatorade as a starter in the deal and the Twins valued him as a relief pitcher.

 

That is a train wreck waiting to happen.

 

If true that each team had its own perspective on the player in the deal how can that be and by what standard is a pitcher deemed a starter or a relief pitcher? What happens if Gatorade ever starts again if the Sox get added compensation in the deal? Seems to me that Gatorade has to be cut entirely out of the deal and another player added as this is leading to an impossible situation.

 

Bloom or Bust!

The Twins should know more about the guy than the Red Sox. If the Twins think he is a reliever, I am skeptical of the Red Sox reported interest in him as a starter.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...