Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account
  • Red Sox News & Analysis

    Tyler Mahle Should Be Banging Down Red Sox's Door For A Chance To Pitch In Fenway Park

    Tyler Mahle's profile fits surprisingly well in Fenway Park, and he could be the perfect replacement for Sonny Gray.

    Yirsandy Rodríguez
    Image courtesy of Brett Davis-Imagn Images

    Red Sox Video

    Right-hander Tyler Mahle is one of the pitchers who, while not among the most coveted arms in free agency, makes a lot of sense to help fill out the Boston Red Sox's rotation.

    Mahle, 31, has bounced all the way back from Tommy John surgery that he underwent in May 2023 and was signed in early 2026 by the San Francisco Giants to a one-year, $10 million contract. They expected to get the most out of his arm after he showed a good recovery in 2025, when he went 6-4 with a 2.18 ERA and recorded 1.9 fWAR in 86⅔ innings over 16 starts with the Texas Rangers. Though, it's worth noting that right shoulder fatigue forced him to miss more than three months of the season.

    Regardless, to analyze Mahle’s 2026 season, it would be fair to divide it into two halves:

    In his 18 starts with the Giants: 8.46 K/9, 3.52 BB/9, 13.6% HR/FB, 5.13 ERA, 4.10 xFIP.

    In his nine starts with the Braves: 7.95 K/9, 1.49 BB/9, 10.9% HR/FB, 1.99 ERA, 3.41 xFIP.

    image.png

    Undoubtedly, the improvement in his ERA was significant, owed primarily to Mahle’s better control—he improved from the 52nd to the 92nd percentile in BB% after arriving in Atlanta. That resulted in a big jump in his xFIP, which finished well below his career mark of 4.02. His whiff rate also rose significantly, from the 30th to the 60th percentile.

    However, as you may have noticed, the home run rate remained almost in the same range and, of course, I know that raises concern, since it has been one of the marked trends in Mahle’s career. He was much better in that regard in 2025, but anyone who gives up a lot of long balls is usually a suspect fit for Fenway Park.

    I do think it's worth stopping to look at the home runs allowed by Mahle. After allowing 20 home runs this year, he has now allowed at least that many in four of the ten seasons of his career. This year, 43.4% of the 69 runs Mahle allowed came via the long ball, though it is fair to point out that most of the problems have appeared again against left-handed hitters. That is not a novel problem for the Red Sox, though.

    image.png

    What's really interesting about Mahle's case is that most of the home runs he's allowed to lefties (24 of 59, or 40.7%), have come in two-strike counts. Although he allowed his lowest OPS with two strikes against left-handed hitters since 2021 this year, I obviously needed to dig a little deeper.

    image.jpeg

    First things first: since Mahle has allowed 40 of his 59 home runs against lefties on his fastballs, I concentrated all this information in this pair of charts. On the left are all the home runs allowed by Mahle in all counts against left-handed hitters between 2018 and 2019, his worst stretch of consecutive years, and on the right are those from this season. The change is evident and you can notice how this year his main problems were concentrated on pitches that stayed right down the middle. In the past, when hitters recorded a higher home run rate with two strikes, they also took greater advantage of pitches around all the outer corners of the zone and the upper inside third.

    Of course, you might be thinking the same thing I am. Power-hitting lefties love to pull fastballs, which doesn't always equal home runs in Fenway. In fact, if we overlay the 20 home runs allowed by Mahle in 2026 on to every stadium in baseball, Fenway holds half of them in play. That's the best possible result of any ballpark in Major League Baseball.

    image.png

    In that sense, Mahle does not seem like such an unreasonable option for the Red Sox, especially now that they will need to cover Sonny Gray’s absence with more than one arm that can join in to strengthen the rotation. Paying up for his late-season surge with the Braves isn't ideal, but if he's looking for a short-term deal to further reestablish his value, he might benefit greatly from pitching in Boston.


    Want to play the role of Red Sox general manager? Check out our free-to-use "You're The GM" offseason tool and build your own Red Sox roster!

    Build Your 2027 Roster

    Follow Talk Sox For Boston Red Sox News & Analysis

    Recent Red Sox Articles

    Recent Red Sox Videos


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.



    Create an account or sign in to comment

    You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

    Create an account

    Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

    Register a new account

    Sign in

    Already have an account? Sign in here.

    Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...