Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
3 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

Anyone who has paid attention to Arias for a long while doesn't believe Arias's bat will be his calling card. He's not going to have an 800 OPS. He's like a 725 OPS at best. He flashed some power this year after having ZERO power in previous seasons. He's a contact guy that may run into a few HR, but he's not going to hit more than 15 HR or so. I'd expect a good BB rate, a good K rate and a decent average going gap to gap like Xander used to (just less power). 

Red overheard some fans pumping up Arias and it bugs the hell out of him. 

Sox fans have long learned not to pin our hopes on top prospects. Of course, when we had 3, it was hard to not believe 1 or 2 of them would do well at some point in their careers, which could still be years away or never.

Maybe someday Arias flicks a switch on offense and does better than you suggest, but most Sox fans are not expecting great (or every good) offense from him year one, two and even three. He may never have a good O year.

Posted

We've seen a lot of MLB top prospects go on to do very nice things- sometimes out of the gate/ sometimes a year or two later. Some have taken steps back and even big steps.

It's hard to know ahead of time who will go on to do great things, and we've seen first hand how someone like Bennett surprises us while more hyped guys like Anthony, KC & Mayer have yet to impress.

Was Tolle over or under-hyped? My question is, why does it even matter?

Community Moderator
Posted
11 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Was Tolle over or under-hyped? My question is, why does it even matter?

I think we were properly "excited" for his debut. We were also properly restrained on his expectations before 2026.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

Red Sox (jumped the line, bid against themselves): Bauers 4/58

White Sox (patient, shrewd and economical businessmen): Dustin May 3/52

they can have him. he has never impressed me even a little.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

Red Sox (jumped the line, bid against themselves): Bauers 4/58

White Sox (patient, shrewd and economical businessmen): Dustin May 3/52

I'm not convinced about this. You really think no other team in baseball was going to offer him a contract?

 

Community Moderator
Posted
8 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I'm not convinced about this. You really think no other team in baseball was going to offer him a contract?

🚬😮‍💨

Old-Timey Member
Posted
4 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

Anyone who has paid attention to Arias for a long while doesn't believe Arias's bat will be his calling card. He's not going to have an 800 OPS. He's like a 725 OPS at best. He flashed some power this year after having ZERO power in previous seasons. He's a contact guy that may run into a few HR, but he's not going to hit more than 15 HR or so. I'd expect a good BB rate, a good K rate and a decent average going gap to gap like Xander used to (just less power). 

I mean, 25 HR's is still 25 HR's.  I dont 100% disagree with your assesment, and I certianly don't think he's going to have 30 HR power at the MLB level but someone not being a power hitter at 18, 19 years old and then all of a sudden growing into a little bit more power isn't exactly unheard of or even surprising. 

Remember, they're trying to project these guys out, but these are real human beings.  They don't know, nor do you or I how a human being is going to develop. 

I don't think it's fair to definitively say he's not going to develop more power after showing more power.  Unlikely? more fair until he shows it again. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, mvp 78 said:

🚬😮‍💨

I don't know what that means.  Are you implying I'm on drugs?

Posted
On 11/16/2026 at 9:22 AM, norbit said:

Jake Bauers

2025 xwOBA.  .356
2026 xwOBA.  .371

Jake Bauers career numbers: 

OPS: .717

OPS+: 96 (below average)

Maybe he has figured it out, finally, but maybe Henry just doesn't want to spend the money to get an established star player with a good track record to bolster the lineup, as always.

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, FredLynn said:

Jake Bauers career numbers: 

OPS: .717

OPS+: 96 (below average)

Maybe he has figured it out, finally, but maybe Henry just doesn't want to spend the money to get an established star player with a good track record to bolster the lineup, as always.

 

In John Henry's defense........who is really available that is an established star player with a good track record who can bolster this lineup?

Posted
4 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

In John Henry's defense........who is really available that is an established star player with a good track record who can bolster this lineup?

Seiya Suzuki. Not established, but he is projected to have an OPS of .814 next year and he hits RH, which is a plus.

Posted
On 11/14/2026 at 8:29 AM, moonslav59 said:

It's one thing to take a chance on Mead- a guy with just a half season of really good hitting, but he just turned 26.

Yes, we gave up Early, and the draft picks and Int'l money lost on Bauers may not turn out better than Early, but he just turned 31 and costs almost $15M a year up to his age 34 season.

Maybe this guy is something special, but it just seems like all these players we've added have a high degree of "dice roll" to them. I've suggested what their upside might look like, and it's something to be optimistic about, but what I haven't talked much about is how almost all of our players have too high degree of a chance ar failure or decline. Even if we put the chances at decline or steep decline at just 15-25% for most of them, it's make it not all that unlikely we end up with too many doing poorly all at once. (Some of these guys might have chances of decline more like 33-50%... maybe most of them do.)

Would it shock anyone if....

Rafaela ends his nonstop trend of improvement by having a bad year, highlighted by a god-awful August-September slump?

Abreu never has that "bust out season" and actually has a bad one?

Contreras finally sees his age catch up with him in a sudden and steep matter?

Anthony's promise turns into what we saw from KC and Mayer?

Mead and Bauers turn out to be flash-in-the-pans?

AR saw his best days a few years back and never comes close, again?

And these are our best and most hopeful 7 bats going into 2027.

Now, take a gander at Gasper, Romy, Jones, Wong, Sogard, Seigler, Monasterio and even somewhat promising players like Durbin and Arias.

I left out Duran, Story and Yoshida because their recent records speak for themselves.

 

 

Elite bats. Keep saying it. Guys who post you pay a premium for. Alonso, Devers types
 I don’t think all 6 of the things you said happen, and you missed the 7th which is major injury like Mead/ Anthony again…. I’d put the over/under on is at least 2.5 of those things will happen. Which ones I have no idea. 

Posted
2 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

We've seen a lot of MLB top prospects go on to do very nice things- sometimes out of the gate/ sometimes a year or two later. Some have taken steps back and even big steps.

It's hard to know ahead of time who will go on to do great things, and we've seen first hand how someone like Bennett surprises us while more hyped guys like Anthony, KC & Mayer have yet to impress.

Was Tolle over or under-hyped? My question is, why does it even matter?

Over-hyped, or under-hyped don’t matter at all, but expectations are a whole different matter. Tolle wasn’t part of the big master plan 2-3 years ago, but Mayer, little A, Teel, and KC certainly was along with Casas, and RAF Man. Also Raffy would have been in the middle of the lineup as well. How has that all turned out? It’s a lot better to be surprised by someone then to count on someone as much as little A was this past year, and especially when it doesn’t work out as expected, and Mayer to a lesser degree.

Posted
6 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

In John Henry's defense........who is really available that is an established star player with a good track record who can bolster this lineup?

Devers and or Alonso. Over the last 18 months. 

Posted
1 minute ago, UtahSox said:

Devers and or Alonso. Over the last 18 months. 

Alonso, yes. Devers screwed himself by being a ME ME ME kind of guy. We don't need any of those.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, FredLynn said:

Seiya Suzuki. 

I mean, if people don't believe that Bauers year is real, then why should they believe that Suzuki's was? he had a year twice as good as any and at 32 what are the odds he's not on the decline.

Why is it Bauers can't be as good as his career year but Suzuki is? I suppose to be fair, Seiya's baseline is much better but still.  Is that any better than what Roman Anthony/Ceddanne Rafaela/Wilyer Abreu are going to give you? if healthy all three of those guys might be better than Suzuki so who are you taking out of the lineup and off the field in that group?

Old-Timey Member
Posted
3 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Over-hyped, or under-hyped don’t matter at all, but expectations are a whole different matter. Tolle wasn’t part of the big master plan 2-3 years ago, but Mayer, little A, Teel, and KC certainly was along with Casas, and RAF Man. Also Raffy would have been in the middle of the lineup as well. How has that all turned out? It’s a lot better to be surprised by someone then to count on someone as much as little A was this past year, and especially when it doesn’t work out as expected, and Mayer to a lesser degree.

It's not like Payton Tolle came out of left field. They drafted him in the second round of the MLB draft and gave him 2 million dollars.  The highest bonus they had given to a pitcher in over a decade. 

He also was a college player and not a highschooler and made it thru the minors to the majors in one single season.  He wasn't hyped because.......there wasn't time to hype him, by the time people knew who he was he was in the majors doing it. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 minutes ago, UtahSox said:

Devers and or Alonso. Over the last 18 months. 

I apologize but I thought it was obvious we are talking about this years free agency class. 

Posted
6 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I mean, if people don't believe that Bauers year is real, then why should they believe that Suzuki's was? he had a year twice as good as any and at 32 what are the odds he's not on the decline.

Why is it Bauers can't be as good as his career year but Suzuki is? I suppose to be fair, Seiya's baseline is much better but still.  Is that any better than what Roman Anthony/Ceddanne Rafaela/Wilyer Abreu are going to give you? if healthy all three of those guys might be better than Suzuki so who are you taking out of the lineup and off the field in that group?

One major advantage is that Suzuki is RH. We need a RHH with power to add to Contreras, who I do not see replicating his career year last year.

Suzuki is the DH most days instead of the guy they got.

Posted
On 11/15/2026 at 12:51 PM, notin said:

I think he can all those supplementary pieces without dealing Schwarber.

Not even sure they need an INF.  Maybe CF/RF help makes more sense.  Theyre actually a good landing spot for Duran (whom Dombrowski drafted).  

In the IF, they have Stott, Turner and Miller.  But Turner has a very bad glove and Miller is both an injury and performance risk.  They currently have $39M to spend.  I'm expecting them to sign Suzuki, who will eat up most of that $39M.

Posted
5 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

It was very risky for JH to put all of his eggs into "the Big Three." I don't think "prospect people" thought that was a great idea. They needed to be surrounded by players that were ready to compete and veterans that were strong voices in the clubhouse. The Sox didn't do that. 

Correct.  Although I would caveat that not all prospect people go into one category.  Some are unreasonable.

Reasonable prospect people, including Hugh2 (but not Hugh1) - love prospects. They love to follow em.  They root for em.  But they know that its probably smart to surround them with established talent.  Regarding the era that was wait for the big 3 (Bloom years) - I think the reasonable prospect people like Hugh might have thought wait for them to bust out and then spend, so it all lines up....So maybe they were like dont spend (yet), wait until RA, Mayer, Teel, KC give you that baseline of affordable homegrown THEN spend.

This is more reasonbable than : All homegrown cheapies at every position!  Woohooo ownership profits!!

Posted
5 hours ago, Hugh2 said:

I remember Soxprospects making this exact point last offseason, and I also remember Lou Merloni saying the same thing on a section10 pod.  I think I was making this point last year myself. 

There seem to be some that just want an all prospect team, they want to develop and never want to splurge on big name free agents.  But having those big names to couple with young talent is important in so many different ways.  

I promise you that 2 minuntes ago whne I said you think this way because you are a reasonable prospect guy and not an unreasonable prospect guy - I swear it was before I saw this post.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

One major advantage is that Suzuki is RH. We need a RHH with power to add to Contreras, who I do not see replicating his career year last year.

Suzuki is the DH most days instead of the guy they got.

Bauers and Suzuki literally both hit the same number of home runs last year, and Bauers did it in less at bats. And they're both RHH

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, drewski6 said:

I promise you that 2 minuntes ago whne I said you think this way because you are a reasonable prospect guy and not an unreasonable prospect guy - I swear it was before I saw this post.

I believe you

Posted
2 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

Red overheard some fans pumping up Arias and it bugs the hell out of him. 

Sox fans have long learned not to pin our hopes on top prospects. Of course, when we had 3, it was hard to not believe 1 or 2 of them would do well at some point in their careers, which could still be years away or never.

Maybe someday Arias flicks a switch on offense and does better than you suggest, but most Sox fans are not expecting great (or every good) offense from him year one, two and even three. He may never have a good O year.

The pricetag of IKF was 6m.  The price of a 4th OF who isnt going to play everyday, and is going to struggle at LF defensively, but has some pop is worth 10m.

Factor in the cost of replacement when deciding who really is a top asset.

If Arias was projected to be bad offensively, hed be IKF at best.  And we could always go get another IKF for cheap.  IF you think hes going to be average with the bat, that changes things somewhat.

Posted

Im not sure how low we are expecting on offense.  BUt you can usually find a good defensive SS with no hitting on the cheap. Like a Yu Chang or an IKF.  If this is Arias upside then we need to trade him before everybody knows this.

But....There is a huge differnece between a great defensive SS who can hit at an average MLB clip and a great defensive SS who cant hit at all.

But I feel like we already have too many average bat, elite glove guys.  Like Durbin.

Posted
On 11/15/2026 at 7:01 PM, moonslav59 said:

No way does PHI take a deal where they dont even save any money.

Unlikely, plus Schwarber is popular with the fans.  But the payroll hit is mostly only one year.  I'd say everything revolves around one's assessment of how Schwarber will age at age 34-35-36-37.  From 2023-2026, for players aged 34-37, only one player has exceeded 7.2 bWAR.  Even for those that disregard WAR, those numbers are awful.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Im not sure how low we are expecting on offense.  BUt you can usually find a good defensive SS with no hitting on the cheap. Like a Yu Chang or an IKF.  If this is Arias upside then we need to trade him before everybody knows this.

But....There is a huge differnece between a great defensive SS who can hit at an average MLB clip and a great defensive SS who cant hit at all.

But I feel like we already have too many average bat, elite glove guys.  Like Durbin.

I mean, take out Durbins slow start and he was much more than an average bat. 

Can he get off to a quicker start? or perhaps he will always be a streaky guy who grades out to average??? Yes. But for an extended period of time last year he certainly looked better than average. 

Posted
26 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Over-hyped, or under-hyped don’t matter at all, but expectations are a whole different matter. Tolle wasn’t part of the big master plan 2-3 years ago, but Mayer, little A, Teel, and KC certainly was along with Casas, and RAF Man. Also Raffy would have been in the middle of the lineup as well. How has that all turned out? It’s a lot better to be surprised by someone then to count on someone as much as little A was this past year, and especially when it doesn’t work out as expected, and Mayer to a lesser degree.

And the fault of that is at least 80%  Breslow.

Posted
8 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

Unlikely, plus Schwarber is popular with the fans.  But the payroll hit is mostly only one year.  I'd say everything revolves around one's assessment of how Schwarber will age at age 34-35-36-37.  From 2023-2026, for players aged 34-37, only one player has exceeded 7.2 bWAR.  Even for those that disregard WAR, those numbers are awful.

Flintstone Schwarber is pretty there to do one thing, and that is to hit homers. 230+ the past five years, and whatever RBI he can get, because of the homers. He strikes out a ton, and draws a bunch of walks. That’s what he gets paid for, and that’s what he does, and those numbers are PDG, so yes disregard WAR altogether.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...