Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
15 minutes ago, notin said:

The Sox aren’t signing Suzuki.  Even if they try to.  He didn’t relocate from Japan to sit on the bench…

We are also not going to bench Anthony or Bauers by signing Suzuki.

There will be no Arozarena either.

No BLowe.

The only way we get a big bat is by trading for one, and that is a long shot.

If we do anything more major it'll be for a pitcher.

Posted
21 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

We are also not going to bench Anthony or Bauers by signing Suzuki.

There will be no Arozarena either.

No BLowe.

The only way we get a big bat is by trading for one, and that is a long shot.

If we do anything more major it'll be for a pitcher.

Most likely.  And despite the lack of a $30mill player, it’s not a bad lineup.

Now I suppose SS could be in play if the Sox did something like DFA Story and trade Arias (or whoever, but probably Arias) for Otto Lopez, which would serve the secondary purpose of giving the Sox a decent leadoff hitter.

Then address the rotation and replace Gray.  Possibly with Gray…

Posted
1 hour ago, notin said:

The Sox aren’t signing Suzuki.  Even if they try to.  He didn’t relocate from Japan to sit on the bench…

This pertains to Bauers

Posted
11 hours ago, drewski6 said:

I like you settling for top 3 a lot more than I like you settling for top 10.

I just look for improvements.  It doesn't matter how i get them.  I still want Skubal.

Posted
11 hours ago, notin said:

Fans have been proposing trades for decades with no idea what teams want AND without any ideas on value.  How is that better?

I'm guessing that 99% of every proposed trade in history, has been proven incorrect.

Posted
10 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

He has some flex in this way.

He has some flex, but there are no worthy targets out there, outside of Skubal and RPs.  Or the unlikely trade for DLC.

Posted
10 hours ago, notin said:

It’s always funny when people frequently respond to some issues with “I don’t care what other teams do”, but then rely on it as a sole argument other times.

 

It's poor logic to not consider what others do.  I don't HAVE TO listen to the opinions of others, but if my opinion is out-number 29-1, then i am going to be real careful to check my work.

Posted
3 hours ago, notin said:

Most likely.  And despite the lack of a $30mill player, it’s not a bad lineup.

Now I suppose SS could be in play if the Sox did something like DFA Story and trade Arias (or whoever, but probably Arias) for Otto Lopez, which would serve the secondary purpose of giving the Sox a decent leadoff hitter.

Then address the rotation and replace Gray.  Possibly with Gray…

Gray signed with the Twins.

I'm thinking Arias for Lopez is an overpay. I'd prefer Abrams, despite the bad defense. He's 26 and has power.

I do like the Lopez OBP and elad-off skills. It's pretty close. BTV says we can get Lopez & Alcantara for Arias, but I seriously doubt MIA does that, even if we add Valera and Paez.

Dumping Story, Duran and Yoshida could free up $18-20M. I'd do it for whatever we can get. Maybe that allows us to sign a decent pitcher like Morejon or a SP'er if we can't get Alcantara and geta  RP'er with Lopez.

Imagine Abrams and Morejon with no Arias, Duran, Story and Yoshida. We'd still have Gonzales, Primera & Godbout.

1. L Anthony LF

2. R Mead 2B

3. L Abrams SS

4. R Contreras 1B

5. R Bauers DH

6. L Abreu RF

7. S Rutschman C

8. R Durbin 3B

9. R Rafaela CF

Bench: Fortes, Sogard, Gasper and Jones/White

+ Morejon or a SP'er like Nick Martinez

_______________________

If we get Alcantara & Lopez + Morejon...

1. R Lopez SS

2. L Anthony LF

3. R Bauers DH

4. R Contreras 1B

5. L Abreu RF

6. R Mead 2B

7. S Rutschman C

8. R Durbin 3B

9. R Rafaela RF

+ Alcantara & Morejon

_______________________

I know, I know, I'm too wide-eyed. It aint happening. I get it.

 

Posted
1 hour ago, moonslav59 said:

Gray signed with the Twins.

I'm thinking Arias for Lopez is an overpay. I'd prefer Abrams, despite the bad defense. He's 26 and has power.

I do like the Lopez OBP and elad-off skills. It's pretty close. BTV says we can get Lopez & Alcantara for Arias, but I seriously doubt MIA does that, even if we add Valera and Paez.

Dumping Story, Duran and Yoshida could free up $18-20M. I'd do it for whatever we can get. Maybe that allows us to sign a decent pitcher like Morejon or a SP'er if we can't get Alcantara and geta  RP'er with Lopez.

Imagine Abrams and Morejon with no Arias, Duran, Story and Yoshida. We'd still have Gonzales, Primera & Godbout.

1. L Anthony LF

2. R Mead 2B

3. L Abrams SS

4. R Contreras 1B

5. R Bauers DH

6. L Abreu RF

7. S Rutschman C

8. R Durbin 3B

9. R Rafaela CF

Bench: Fortes, Sogard, Gasper and Jones/White

+ Morejon or a SP'er like Nick Martinez

_______________________

If we get Alcantara & Lopez + Morejon...

1. R Lopez SS

2. L Anthony LF

3. R Bauers DH

4. R Contreras 1B

5. L Abreu RF

6. R Mead 2B

7. S Rutschman C

8. R Durbin 3B

9. R Rafaela RF

+ Alcantara & Morejon

_______________________

I know, I know, I'm too wide-eyed. It aint happening. I get it.

 

I like Alcantara he could be great. But on Otto Lopez it's worth mentioning ‘24 & ‘25 he had a .690/.672 OPS obviously like Mead and Bauers you’re betting his 2026 780 OPS is more the new norm vs aberration. But it has some risk. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 hours ago, UtahSox said:

I like Alcantara he could be great. But on Otto Lopez it's worth mentioning ‘24 & ‘25 he had a .690/.672 OPS obviously like Mead and Bauers you’re betting his 2026 780 OPS is more the new norm vs aberration. But it has some risk. 

More like Mead than Bauers.  Its easier to believe in the breakouts of 25 year olds than 30 year olds…

Posted
7 hours ago, UtahSox said:

I like Alcantara he could be great. But on Otto Lopez it's worth mentioning ‘24 & ‘25 he had a .690/.672 OPS obviously like Mead and Bauers you’re betting his 2026 780 OPS is more the new norm vs aberration. But it has some risk. 

Yes, there is risk, but he was 24-26 years old when he hit .687 combined.

I cut younger guys some slack. Bauers worries me more, but I have confidence he will be fine, too.

Lopez is a better defender than Abrams, and adding Sandy makes it worth the gamble.

Posted
9 hours ago, UtahSox said:

I like Alcantara he could be great. But on Otto Lopez it's worth mentioning ‘24 & ‘25 he had a .690/.672 OPS obviously like Mead and Bauers you’re betting his 2026 780 OPS is more the new norm vs aberration. But it has some risk. 

There is really nothing to indicate that Lopez is any better than Arias.  Lopez projects to 12 HRs and a .277, with a great glove.  While I always like a great glove at SS, this is a really similar profile to Arias.

Posted
2 hours ago, notin said:

More like Mead than Bauers.  Its easier to believe in the breakouts of 25 year olds than 30 year olds…

True, but the biggest improvement in Otto was his .335 BABIP, but with no improvement in his EV.  If Otto reverts back to .300, his OPS reverts back to .716.

Posted
17 hours ago, notin said:

Two bench players listed as DH?

Abreu for Kirby seems like a fair trade, although Seattle might be hesitant to further dismantle their rotation.

I will point out that “Suzuki plus Kirby > Abreu plus rental pitcher” is a marketed statement.  I mean, why do the Sox pay for a 5-6 year deal for an OF but settle for a rental pitcher in Plan B?

And Kirby has been fairly mediocre the last two years.  Pretty durable, which is good because he only has two years left.

I don’t think the Sox could do better than Kirby, especially if they save the $120-150mill and not get Seiya Suzuki…

Seattle PBO Jerry Dipoto reportedly said there is "zero chance" the Mariners will trade another starter.

https://www.mlbtraderumors.com/2026/11/mariners-rumors-zero-chance-trade-another-starter-dipoto.html

The Mariners may pursue Seiya Suzuki, Steven Kwan and/or even Taylor Walls to bolster a defense that this year sabotaged an otherwise talented pitching staff.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

True, but the biggest improvement in Otto was his .335 BABIP, but with no improvement in his EV.  If Otto reverts back to .300, his OPS reverts back to .716.

I saw and thought “well let’s see how much his line drive rate increased.  Bigger factor in BABIP than EV.”

Nope.  His LD% actually decreased.  A jump in BABIP with no increase in LD% plus no change in EV? Huge red flag.

Lopez officially looks riskier to me now than before.  That’s why I like digging deeper…

Posted
1 hour ago, moonslav59 said:

adding Sandy makes it worth the gamble.

I don't see much more than an injury-prone #3.  The K9 of 6.4 last is unsustainable.  That ranked #126 out of 141 with at least 100 IPs.  And imho, having led the league in IPs last year, with his injury history, is worrisome.

Posted
2 minutes ago, notin said:

Lopez officially looks riskier to me now than before.  That’s why I like digging deeper…

I think that sometimes it is better to keep things simpler.  Without his name, if I said we could acquire a good glove at SS with 12 HRs and a .275, and all it would cost us is the #2 prospect in BB, people would be aghast.

Posted
18 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

I really don't think the6y will force teams to dump contracts to meet the cap. There will be a grace period.

How they count deffered money could affect some teams way more than others.

Agreed, I thought about this after. Prob what they would do is something like LAD cannot sign free agents until they are under, but you cant force them to get under.  Borrowed from NBA.

Posted
5 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Agreed, I thought about this after. Prob what they would do is something like LAD cannot sign free agents until they are under, but you cant force them to get under.  Borrowed from NBA.

I don't think that part will be an issue.  Neither the players nor the owners have a reason to not make this as smooth as possible for everyone.

Posted
15 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Agreed, I thought about this after. Prob what they would do is something like LAD cannot sign free agents until they are under, but you cant force them to get under.  Borrowed from NBA.

I wonder if they will have clauses that allow you to have exceptions to keep your own players.

Posted
1 hour ago, JoeBrady said:

I think that sometimes it is better to keep things simpler.  Without his name, if I said we could acquire a good glove at SS with 12 HRs and a .275, and all it would cost us is the #2 prospect in BB, people would be aghast.

These type of trades happen all the time, and the people who would be aghast dont understand windows.

After an extremely frustrating 7 years, its time to stop weight 5 years out equal to next year, and pay a little premium for right now.

Arias will be 21 next year and does not have his man strength. Lopez is in his prime today.  We need to see the humans. They are individuals, not their stat lines.

You can always talk yourself out of moving your chips in.  But if you do this too often, you get stuck in third place.

For next year - Arias projects as a #9 hitter, something we already have 2 of. Lopez does not.  Im not saying I would for sure make the trade or anything like that.  But my point is they should be viewed as individuals, not interchangeable uniform filler-outers.

ALl players are individuals, but you seem to consistently commoditize them.  And I think many do, and I think its a mistake.  

Posted
Just now, moonslav59 said:

I wonder if they will have clauses that allow you to have exceptions to keep your own players.

if they follow nba, they will, but thats not a hard cap.

Posted
2 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

if they follow nba, they will, but thats not a hard cap.

I am not sure they start with a hard cap, and this could be an exception that gets the players to go along with the idea.

I'm thinking the start with a soft cap and force a floor on low spenders. That's something that helps players.

I'm not sure a cap is the answer, but I hope they can agree on something that's fair for the players, especially the lower paid ones.

Posted
10 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

These type of trades happen all the time, and the people who would be aghast dont understand windows.

After an extremely frustrating 7 years, its time to stop weight 5 years out equal to next year, and pay a little premium for right now.

Arias will be 21 next year and does not have his man strength. Lopez is in his prime today.  We need to see the humans. They are individuals, not their stat lines.

You can always talk yourself out of moving your chips in.  But if you do this too often, you get stuck in third place.

For next year - Arias projects as a #9 hitter, something we already have 2 of. Lopez does not.  Im not saying I would for sure make the trade or anything like that.  But my point is they should be viewed as individuals, not interchangeable uniform filler-outers.

ALl players are individuals, but you seem to consistently commoditize them.  And I think many do, and I think its a mistake.  

Well said. I will add that part of the deciding factor is 6 years of Arias vs 3 of Lopez. Even if it takes 2 years for Arias to become as good as Lopez (big if) he might give 4 years to 3. Another factor is pay.

I know the Sox shouldn't have to worry about pay or years of service, since they should be able to replace Lopez after 3 years, but that's not the reality of the Sox.

If the new CBA has a cap, having a few players like Arias allows a team to spend more on other areas.

That being said, I'm all for trading Arias plus for DLC / Arias for Abrams/ Arias for Lopez plus.

Posted
9 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

Well said. I will add that part of the deciding factor is 6 years of Arias vs 3 of Lopez. Even if it takes 2 years for Arias to become as good as Lopez (big if) he might give 4 years to 3. Another factor is pay.

I know the Sox shouldn't have to worry about pay or years of service, since they should be able to replace Lopez after 3 years, but that's not the reality of the Sox.

If the new CBA has a cap, having a few players like Arias allows a team to spend more on other areas.

That being said, I'm all for trading Arias plus for DLC / Arias for Abrams/ Arias for Lopez plus.

EDLC is the guy I want desperately. Get him, build roster around him. As popular as Tolle is I’d trade Tolle + Arias + J Gonzalez + Godbout for EDLC. Then go out and figure out pitching. 


I think I’d rather trade Duran + Mead for Marte and hold off on Abrams since he projects as a 2b anyway. 

Posted
1 hour ago, UtahSox said:

EDLC is the guy I want desperately. Get him, build roster around him.

I agree on DLC, but no way I give Tolle.

I like Lopez but agree with BTV: Arias is worth more, and we should get more than Lopez for him. If MIA can add a decent RP'er or Alcantara with us adding Paez or Valera, okay.

I also like Abrams, who is the same age as DLC. He's not a good defensive SS, but he's 10 times the bat as Story & Arias.

Posted
1 hour ago, UtahSox said:

I think I’d rather trade Duran + Mead for Marte and hold off on Abrams since he projects as a 2b anyway. 

Mead is and will be better than KMarte.

I don't mind giving up Duran, but not Mead.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...