Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
2 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

I think he is spending what the Henry the Cheap told him is available. I want him to be honest though-clearly state that he spent what he was allowed to spend and that he understands that Bauers had exactly one very good season and that before that he was a bum.

He spent a lot of money last winter, and it's fair game to say he shoulda signed Alonso instead of Suarez and IKF. 

If this is all Brez spends this winter, I might be inclined to think he did pretty well, unless Sato signs for $15M AAV.

Posted
24 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Some still see him that way though, and that’s how it works too.

Some people also drive the wrong way in a roundabout. It's not really how rotaries work though! 

Posted
20 minutes ago, Old Red said:

There is so many different things, and different views discussed outside of on here. I guess I’m just different that I like to hear ALL the different opinions, and subjects being discussed than just limiting myself to just on here.

Interesting as it seems you don't like to hear or value all opinions on here. 

Posted
27 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Some still see him that way though, and that’s how it works too.

But it’s not how the definition of “reclamation” works…

Posted
18 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

He spent a lot of money last winter, and it's fair game to say he shoulda signed Alonso instead of Suarez and IKF. 

If this is all Brez spends this winter, I might be inclined to think he did pretty well, unless Sato signs for $15M AAV.

If this is the only move he makes, D offseason. 

Posted

Another factor to consider is this:

Assume Brez has already spent to the budget max for the winter, he could decide to trade Duran and add $11M to future spending. He could trade KC and others to save AVV budget space and future spending, but I'm not sure how much that would add to this winter's budget. He could trade Contreras and play  Bauers at 1B, but then we have one of our best bats needing replacement.

Trading Yoshida might save $3-5M. Trading Story might save $4-7M. Houck? Almost $5M. 

Combine some of these guys and maybe he can add one more moderate or big cost player.

He could trade for a lower cost big bang addition by trading away top prospects.

He has some flex in this way.

Posted
25 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

I think he is spending what the Henry the Cheap told him is available. I want him to be honest though-clearly state that he spent what he was allowed to spend and that he understands that Bauers had exactly one very good season and that before that he was a bum.

Do you have any ideal how unrealistic this is? 
 

“hey everyone here’s the new guy, we hired because we’re cheap and HE’S A BUM!!!!!”

Posted
20 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

He spent a lot of money last winter, and it's fair game to say he shoulda signed Alonso instead of Suarez and IKF. 

If this is all Brez spends this winter, I might be inclined to think he did pretty well, unless Sato signs for $15M AAV.

No it’s not.

How much better would the Sox be with Alonso over Contreras? I know some folks insist they could have had both, but that only works if they offload either Duran or Anthony.  And I really cannot call failing to dump Duran - one of the best players in MLB from 2024 through 2025 - for nothing just to get Alonso in there.

Maybe it makes 2028 better, as Alonso would still be here and Contreras is likely gone.  Is that the goal?

Posted
1 hour ago, FredLynn said:

He’s not going after anyone of significance. I hope Bauers works out but he has sucked for most of his career. 

Who should he be going after in free agency?

Posted
3 minutes ago, notin said:

But it’s not how the definition of “reclamation” works…

Word meanings dont matter.

Klube and Richards were "reclamation." Paxton and Sandoval, too.

Hendriks and to a lesser extent Wacha and Hill, also.

I guess with the Mea dinjury, someone could say there is a reclamation aspect to his signing, but there are much better words to choose.

Why choose some poorly-words chosen comments to regurgitate?

Posted
2 hours ago, Old Red said:

I think most of the trade suggestions on here aren’t plausible, because most of the time they are just trying to unload players they don’t want on the Red Sox anymore onto other teams, and that’s why they never happen. If you were a fan of the team on the other side of the trade you wouldn’t except it either.if it’s aimed at me, or not meh.

Yes, some are like that and those points can be debated, but some trade ideals are pretty good.  I personally believe It makes for better conversation that if someone is going to poo poo someone else’s trade ideals they should offer up their own.

Posted
3 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Do you have any ideal how unrealistic this is? 
 

“hey everyone here’s the new guy, we hired because we’re cheap and HE’S A BUM!!!!!”

Of for the new hire to say, "Hey guys, don't blame me for our ownership being cheap bums. I'm spending all they give me, and I beg them for more, but they always say no."

Posted
4 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Interesting as it seems you don't like to hear or value all opinions on here. 

I would say that works both ways. It’s like when I mentioned old time stats, and all kinds of bells, and whistles go off. I didn’t say there listen to Milliken talk about expected woBA yesterday though. I will say that the opinions on here are usually way out there compared to other venues, and there is nothing wrong with knowing that.

Posted
2 minutes ago, notin said:

No it’s not.

How much better would the Sox be with Alonso over Contreras? I know some folks insist they could have had both, but that only works if they offload either Duran or Anthony.  And I really cannot call failing to dump Duran - one of the best players in MLB from 2024 through 2025 - for nothing just to get Alonso in there.

Maybe it makes 2028 better, as Alonso would still be here and Contreras is likely gone.  Is that the goal?

I think Brez did more than fine with the budget he spent last winter. It might be the best actual winter spending vs next year results in the history of Red Sox winter spending.

My point was, he did have a big winter spending budget, last year, and there were other choices on how he could have spent it. IMO, I'd rather have Contreras than Alonso, because the cost was lower and length too. That allows us to spend more on someone else.

It's fair for people to say he could have done something different. Could he have dumped Yoshida, not signed Suarez and IKF and signed Alonso to DH?

Could he have signed Bregman over Suarez and IKF? That might be a better result, but word was JH would not allow a no-trade, so that was likely not an option anyway.

Posted
1 hour ago, FredLynn said:

Then I think that Breslow should be honest with the fans and tell it like it is: "the owners don't want to spend the money to obtain top talent so we will do the best we can with the budget they have given us". That could get him fired but at least its honest. I mostly blame Henry for lying about prioritizing winning and for being cheap-but Breslow shoulders some of the blame.

Because he chose Bauers over Arozarena?

I don’t know what they liked about Bauers.  I’m not a Bauer’s fan either.  But two undiputBle facts are 1) they probably have some stats or metrics that made him their primary target in a very weak class and 2) they paid Whats they paid because they needed an offer that made rejecting the QO a decision Bauers felt confident with.

And if Arozarena and/or Suzuki get 6 yrs $130mill, this deal looks better overall…

Posted
4 minutes ago, notin said:

No it’s not.

How much better would the Sox be with Alonso over Contreras? I know some folks insist they could have had both, but that only works if they offload either Duran or Anthony.  And I really cannot call failing to dump Duran - one of the best players in MLB from 2024 through 2025 - for nothing just to get Alonso in there.

Maybe it makes 2028 better, as Alonso would still be here and Contreras is likely gone.  Is that the goal?

You guys are so hung up on the Con Man. If you asked every GM in MLB who they would rather have between the Con Man, or Alonso if they needed a middle of the order run producing bat how many do you. Think would take the Con Man?

Posted
5 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Yes, some are like that and those points can be debated, but some trade ideals are pretty good.  I personally believe It makes for better conversation that if someone is going to poo poo someone else’s trade ideals they should offer up their own.

That's how I see it. It's easy to come back later and say, "I told you that was a bad trade," but not have stated their ideas to compare it to.

 

Posted
7 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Yes, some are like that and those points can be debated, but some trade ideals are pretty good.  I personally believe It makes for better conversation that if someone is going to poo poo someone else’s trade ideals they should offer up their own.

I don’t have any desire, or the need to play fantasy trades, and think it’s fun to make unrealistic ones. I made suggestions last offseason on who to sign though.

Posted
3 minutes ago, notin said:

Because he chose Bauers over Arozarena?

I don’t know what they liked about Bauers.  I’m not a Bauer’s fan either.  But two undiputBle facts are 1) they probably have some stats or metrics that made him their primary target in a very weak class and 2) they paid Whats they paid because they needed an offer that made rejecting the QO a decision Bauers felt confident with.

And if Arozarena and/or Suzuki get 6 yrs $130mill, this deal looks better overall…

Suzuki would have been better imo. Of course he likely would cost more. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

You guys are so hung up on the Con Man. If you asked every GM in MLB who they would rather have between the Con Man, or Alonso if they needed a middle of the order run producing bat how many do you. Think would take the Con Man?

Breslow did.

I keep asking how much better are the Sox with Alonso instead?  I’d say 1-2 wins better.  I could be convinced of 3 maybe.  That still leaves the Sox as second wild card, going to NY, giving up 18 runs in two games and season ending the same way…

Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

You guys are so hung up on the Con Man. If you asked every GM in MLB who they would rather have between the Con Man, or Alonso if they needed a middle of the order run producing bat how many do you. Think would take the Con Man?

1. Many GM couldn't afford Alonso. (Some couldn't afford Contreras either.) So, they wouldn't "rather have" someone they cant pay.

2. The Contreras deal ends earlier and STL paid off some of it. That allows for spending after Contreras leaves that wouldn't be there when Alonso is still being paid and is likely in decline.

Many GM would take Contreras over Alonso, and not just in hindsight. YES!

If you can't see that, go talk to your circle jerk clown friends and see what they say.

Posted
Just now, FredLynn said:

Suzuki would have been better imo. Of course he likely would cost more. 

I agree Suzuki might and should be better.  But how much better? And is it worth what I can promise you will be a much larger contract?

Posted
2 hours ago, notin said:

The Brewers extended Pratt for 8 years $51mill prior to his MLB debut.  There is absolutely no reason whatsoever for them to even consider trading him, especially to clear the path for 19 year old Jesus Made.  If the Brewers get to the point of trading Pratt or Made, they are more likely to move Made.  (But most likely to push him to 3b.)

Neto somehow put together some defensive analytics that looked good last year, and he is a prior target for Breslow.

Lopez is just good at everything.  I actually would not be surprised if the Sox dealt Arias for him at all, BTV values be damned…

If you do research they have a hotshot 3b prospect as well. Looks like he is a year behind last name is Pena.

Posted
15 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Do you have any ideal how unrealistic this is? 
 

“hey everyone here’s the new guy, we hired because we’re cheap and HE’S A BUM!!!!!”

Something like that would have been honest

Posted
14 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Another factor to consider is this:

Assume Brez has already spent to the budget max for the winter, he could decide to trade Duran and add $11M to future spending. He could trade KC and others to save AVV budget space and future spending, but I'm not sure how much that would add to this winter's budget. He could trade Contreras and play  Bauers at 1B, but then we have one of our best bats needing replacement.

Trading Yoshida might save $3-5M. Trading Story might save $4-7M. Houck? Almost $5M. 

Combine some of these guys and maybe he can add one more moderate or big cost player.

He could trade for a lower cost big bang addition by trading away top prospects.

He has some flex in this way.

Winter budget may also completely change depending on the CBA negotiations. We don't know where the Lux Tax tiers end up. There could be additional $ to spend? 

I heard that they were following Bauers back to the middle of the season. They reached out with a good offer and got a FA early. It's a good process, even if YOU don't like the player. 

Is there more money to spend? Probably, but who knows?

Posted
Just now, FredLynn said:

Suzuki> Bauers. Better still, both. Get rid of Masa and Duran. 

No Duran and Masa might add $15M to the budget, then maybe we could have afforded Suzuki over Bauers for the short term budget outlook, but it's the later years that scares the beJesus out of JH & Co..

Posted
3 minutes ago, notin said:

Breslow did.

I keep asking how much better are the Sox with Alonso instead?  I’d say 1-2 wins better.  I could be convinced of 3 maybe.  That still leaves the Sox as second wild card, going to NY, giving up 18 runs in two games and season ending the same way…

That’s subjectivity if I’ve ever seen it. You have no idea no one does.
 

 Many on here said a year ago said “the back end of Alonso contract was gonna be terrible”. And that “he was declining already.”All he did was play everyday, play his best 1b of his career and absolutely rake in a lineup without a lot of protection. Objectively no one knows how it would have looked in Boston. 

Posted
1 minute ago, notin said:

I agree Suzuki might and should be better.  But how much better? And is it worth what I can promise you will be a much larger contract?

I'm not a Bauers fan, either (yet.) He has some serious upside, if he can just repeat 2026 or Sept 2025-2026. It seems some here value the "what have you done for me lately" philosophy, but seem to be down on Mead & Bauers.

Roman, Yoshida, Story, AR and Duran are written off dues to recency numbers, and I admit, I've written all but AR & Roman off, too, but it's based off more than just 2026 numbers.

Duran has been erratic his whole career, and has declined 2 years in a row.

Story has two half seasons of success in 5 years with the Sox.

Yoshida at his finest is barely a good DH. He's past prime, and his very best is probably behind him.

If we traded Duran and Yoshida and sign Suzuki, where would he or Anthony play? I guess with no Bauers, DH would be open, but DH might be the best place for Mead.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...