Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
7 hours ago, notin said:

I think the Sox are locked in (to a degree) at catcher (Rutschman), 1b (Contreras), 2b (Mead), 3b (Durbin), LF (Anthony), CF (Rafaela), RF (Abreu) and DH (Bauers).

SS is the last question.  Story? Arias? A player you can get for Arias? 

I don't think so.  If DLC is available, maybe.  But I calculated our OPS based on FG projections, using .658 for Story, and .680 for the bench using 10% of the PAs.  I come up with .748.  That would've been 3rd in MLB last year.

Posted
5 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Scarecrows don't work as well as plastic owls.

"Strawmen" only exits in people's minds, but to them, they are as real as night and day.

Some clowns don't even know what a strawman is.

 

is this a haiku? are you being poetic?

Posted
1 hour ago, Hugh2 said:

It's not like Payton Tolle came out of left field. They drafted him in the second round of the MLB draft and gave him 2 million dollars.  The highest bonus they had given to a pitcher in over a decade. 

He also was a college player and not a highschooler and made it thru the minors to the majors in one single season.  He wasn't hyped because.......there wasn't time to hype him, by the time people knew who he was he was in the majors doing it. 

Yes, but he didn’t make the club out of ST, and he had nowhere near the expectations on him going into last year as little A did. I’ve seen everyone come up since Yaz, and NO ONE has had the expectations placed on them that little A had last year, and when those expectations don’t happen then the results aren’t usually very good. A magic carpet ride saved them last year.

Posted
10 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Exactly.  Not everything is value, value, value.  Value is only one component.  The team that has the most WAR for every dollar spent is usually NOT the champs. 

The teams that do poorly with WAR/dollar spent do even worse.

Speaking of DD, and I mean no disrespect: I loved him as our GM, but some Philly BTVs:

-60 Schwarber (4 yrs left)

-56 T Turner (7 yrs)

-17 Realmuto (2)

-14 Nola (4)

-10 B Keller (1)

-4 Harper (5 and owed $118M)

-1 D Hill, B DLC, T Banks

(The Dodgers have 10 guys underwater, including Tucker at -100. The Padres have -144 Machao and -66 Bogey!)

 

 

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

Yes, but he didn’t make the club out of ST, and he had nowhere near the expectations on him going into last year as little A did. I’ve seen everyone come up since Yaz, and NO ONE has had the expectations placed on them that little A had last year, and when those expectations don’t happen then the results aren’t usually very good. A magic carpet ride saved them last year.

You're missing the point.  2025 was his first season pitching in Pro ball.  HE REACHED the Majors in 2025. 

One reason these guys get so hyped up is because there is time to hype them, the legend grows with anticipation.  That doesn't happen so much when a guy fly's thru a system. 

Mookie Betts never touched the top 50, he was going to be ranked #1 but he graduated.  That's what happens when you move fast, you don't get time to get hyped up. 

Posted
17 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

Therein lies the problem.  Some opinions are formed on what the poster believes, and not necessarily what's trending in baseball.  Objectively, BTV is probably right on their opinion of Schwarber being such a negative.  But folks that grew up with four stats on the back of their BB cards only see the HRs.

What’s trending in baseball isn’t trending for everyone. I don’t only see HR, but a HR, or an RBI, because of that HR instantly goes up on the scoreboard, and what hasn’t changed with the so called trends is that what goes up on the scoreboard counts the most. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

is this a haiku? are you being poetic?

I call them Faikus.

Speaking of poets, here's one of my faves on scarecrows...

 

 

Posted
4 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

You're missing the point.  2025 was his first season pitching in Pro ball.  HE REACHED the Majors in 2025. 

One reason these guys get so hyped up is because there is time to hype them, the legend grows with anticipation.  That doesn't happen so much when a guy fly's thru a system. 

Mookie Betts never touched the top 50, he was going to be ranked #1 but he graduated.  That's what happens when you move fast, you don't get time to get hyped up. 

And because he did get the time to be hyped, our expectations were not allowed to swell too much.

Somehow, it's the player's fault. They hype machine's fault, It's the fan's fault, but only on hyped players...

Posted
3 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

You're missing the point.  2025 was his first season pitching in Pro ball.  HE REACHED the Majors in 2025. 

One reason these guys get so hyped up is because there is time to hype them, the legend grows with anticipation.  That doesn't happen so much when a guy fly's thru a system. 

Mookie Betts never touched the top 50, he was going to be ranked #1 but he graduated.  That's what happens when you move fast, you don't get time to get hyped up. 

I’m not disagreeing with what you are saying at all, and every case is a case all to itself. Anthony is a special case all to himself also, and like I said I’ve seen them all come up since Yaz.

Posted
11 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

You're missing the point.  2025 was his first season pitching in Pro ball.  HE REACHED the Majors in 2025. 

One reason these guys get so hyped up is because there is time to hype them, the legend grows with anticipation.  That doesn't happen so much when a guy fly's thru a system. 

Mookie Betts never touched the top 50, he was going to be ranked #1 but he graduated.  That's what happens when you move fast, you don't get time to get hyped up. 

Bogey got some hype.

HRam was hyped, then traded.

I remember Evans and Rice were hyped a lot, and Lynn kinda stole the show- not that he wasn't hyped.

Clemens was super-hyped.

Nomar.

Remember when Espinoza was hailed as the next "Pedro?"

Posted
28 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

I don't think so.  If DLC is available, maybe.  But I calculated our OPS based on FG projections, using .658 for Story, and .680 for the bench using 10% of the PAs.  I come up with .748.  That would've been 3rd in MLB last year.

To me, SS is the only position we can upgrade by a lot on offense. That doesn't mean do it just for the sake of an argument, and I'd be okay with Arias at SS. I just think an elite bat added at SS gets us to top 3-4 favorites in MLB.

Posted
10 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

And because he did get the time to be hyped, our expectations were not allowed to swell too much.

Somehow, it's the player's fault. They hype machine's fault, It's the fan's fault, but only on hyped players...

Anthony's failure to explode into an MVP candidate in the batter's box weren't his fault nor the fans -- who were told for at least two years he was the guy.

The lack of superstardom also isn't the media's fault, either, because most were just delivering predictions based on the analysis of evaluators and/or coaches.

This is on the Red Sox braintrust -- who posters implored for over a year now to build a batting order with proven bats around a guy like Anthony, and don't leave him hanging without support in the lineup for savvy pitchers and gameplans to exploit.

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
6 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Bogey got some hype.

HRam was hyped, then traded.

I remember Evans and Rice were hyped a lot, and Lynn kinda stole the show- not that he wasn't hyped.

Clemens was super-hyped.

Nomar.

Remember when Espinoza was hailed as the next "Pedro?"

And all those guys were super young and spent many years in the system 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
2 hours ago, Hugh2 said:

Bauers and Suzuki literally both hit the same number of home runs last year, and Bauers did it in less at bats. And they're both RHH

The big difference is Bauers bats right/handed from the left side of the plate…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
46 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

You're missing the point.  2025 was his first season pitching in Pro ball.  HE REACHED the Majors in 2025. 

One reason these guys get so hyped up is because there is time to hype them, the legend grows with anticipation.  That doesn't happen so much when a guy fly's thru a system. 

Mookie Betts never touched the top 50, he was going to be ranked #1 but he graduated.  That's what happens when you move fast, you don't get time to get hyped up. 

The only year BA ranked Betts, they placed him behind The Immortal Garin Cecchini…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
30 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

 

Remember when Espinoza was hailed as the next "Pedro?"

He made the majors as a RHRP gor the Cubs, making him the Next Pedro Strop…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
26 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

And all those guys were super young and spent many years in the system 

Clemens pitched 18 games totaling 127 IP in the minors before his debut…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
4 minutes ago, notin said:

Clemens pitched 18 games totaling 127 IP in the minors before his debut…

I think Clemens is irrelevant

Posted
7 hours ago, southpaw777 said:

The guys at Sox prospects are pretty grounded. I like them. It’s the other media that overplays their talent…

I just go by BA, BP, and a little less by MLB.  And I quite candidly will acknowledge I have no shot at out-guessing people that get paid real money for this type of analysis.  If BA says that Arias is #2, then he is #2.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
25 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I think Clemens is irrelevant

He was on the list of Hyped Prospects that were saud to have spent “years in the system.”  He spent one.

Posted
5 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

Red Sox (jumped the line, bid against themselves): Bauers 4/58

White Sox (patient, shrewd and economical businessmen): Dustin May 3/52

Are we done with the idea that May was a bad acquisition yet?

Posted
2 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

Are we done with the idea that May was a bad acquisition yet?

I've been done with Dustin May since he sucked for the Red Sox when they acquired him.

I could care less how he does for anyone else.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
27 minutes ago, notin said:

He was on the list of Hyped Prospects that were saud to have spent “years in the system.”  He spent one.

Oh ok, Clemens was before my time.

i also think the times are different in how accurate prospect ranking are, how they’re ranked, how much attention they get, media. Social media etc etc.  

Old-Timey Member
Posted
34 minutes ago, notin said:

He was on the list of Hyped Prospects that were saud to have spent “years in the system.”  He spent one.

Clemens was also projected to be a mid rotation starter.  At least at some point, I’d say he more than lived up to that hype 

Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

He's like a 2.5-3 fWAR player. That's good for $24M AAV at most, but his contract is $30 AAV. Sometimes you have to eat your shorts to bring in players with a certain skillset. If Schwarber is your DH and he's surrounded by the right guys, you aren't complaining. 

You aren't complaining this year, but there are no 37 year old hitters.  Rojas was the leader at 0.8 fWAR.  And there are almost no 36 year old hitters, with Freeman being the leader with 1.7, and Springer #2 at 0.9.  Even at age 35, there are only 3 hitters with a fWAR more than 0.7.

Posted
3 hours ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

Anthony's failure to explode into an MVP candidate in the batter's box weren't his fault nor the fans -- who were told for at least two years he was the guy.

The lack of superstardom also isn't the media's fault, either, because most were just delivering predictions based on the analysis of evaluators and/or coaches.

This is on the Red Sox braintrust -- who posters implored for over a year now to build a batting order with proven bats around a guy like Anthony, and don't leave him hanging without support in the lineup for savvy pitchers and gameplans to exploit.

 

I disagree on the "left him hanging" comment. Anthony failed to meet even tepid expectations.

No doubt Brez & Co failed to add the elite bat many of us wanted, but Contreras ended up doing nearly as well as Bregman, Alonso & Schwarber. He did better than Bichette, KMarte and many other names we threw out there in hopes Brez would have signed or traded for.

I think Brez made  a decent stab at fixing the issue by trading for Mead & AR, but Mead got hurt and AR did worse than his first half.

I do think they counted on Anthony to be a big part of the line-up but not as necessarily the best hitter on the team.

IMO, I was expecting Abrue to bust out as he reached peak prime. Instead he kinda stayed flat, and that was actually better than almost all the other vets, except Rafaela. No doubt, putting a lot of faith in 2nd year man Narvaez, and already declining Duran, and 80 year old SS who cant field anymore and another 2nd year guy named Durbin missed the mark, but most of these guys getting hurt or underperforming is not the reason Anthony was hurt and played kinda poorly the rest or the time. They weren't the reason Mayer sucked, either. 

I know that's not what you are claiming, and Brez failed to replace the 2/3 Breggie + 1/2 Devers 2025 season's losses. Contreras took up some slack, but counting on Anthony to take up part of it, along with Abreu, Story, Duran, Yoshida, Rafaela, Durbin and Narvaez was not an absurd ask.

Had Mead stayed healthy and hit like he did with the Nats, I doubt we'd be saying a lot of what we're hearing now. I'm not disagreeing with a lot of what is being said. I think we are still short a big bat, despite all these additions.

Posted
3 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

I do think they counted on Anthony to be a big part of the line-up but not as necessarily the best hitter on the team.

I think we are still short a big bat, despite all these additions.

Your opinion is noted, but Roman Anthony is the only hitter on that role call of guys you listed that Breslow has paid. That says something.

I also pasted your last line, though, because it's what we've all been posting for over two years now.

Posted
2 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

Are we done with the idea that May was a bad acquisition yet?

I remember saying the same about Martin Perez and Springs, after they did very well the minute they left Boston.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
2 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

Are we done with the idea that May was a bad acquisition yet?

he sucked with the Dodgers, he sucked with the Red Sox, he sucked with the Cardinals, he sucked with the Brewers and he will suck with the White Sox. it's what he does.

Posted
1 minute ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

Your opinion is noted, but Roman Anthony is the only hitter on that role call of guys you listed that Breslow has paid. That says something.

I also pasted your last line, though, because it's what we've all been posting for over two years now.

It's the one central point that comes closest to a consensus or site members.

If we keep adding batters like Bauers, Mead, AR & Contreras, instead of a Schwarber or Alonso, maybe the talk will never stop.

I didn't mean to combative, but you kinda hit a nerve. IMO, Brez's strength has been that he has done a fine job building up a foundation to support the few elite players we we should add. He keeps improving on that framework of support, and he kinda hit gold with Contreras and Bregman, the year before. At the same time he built two pens in a  row that overperformed expectations and a rotation all but maybe 1-2 two team envy- all under an owner that puts the brakes on mega large and long deals and continually restricts winter spending budgets. He had to build most of this foundation from a farm he helped build up in just 3 short season.

To me, we are at the point where we are one, maybe two big adds away from being as good or nearly as good as anyone else, on paper. Looking at next season, and not because of any 2025 letdown by Anthony, how much is the FO or fans counting on Anthony to lead us to a ring in 2026?

IMO, he might be our 3rd, 4th or even 5th best projected bat value.

Mead, Bauers and Contreras are all higher.

Abreu and maybe AR could end up having a better season than Anthony without shocking anyone (and not because Anthony bats .775 in 2026.)

Hell, if Rafaela keeps improving, he may top Anthony's .803 career OPS. Oh, and Durbin hit .804 after game 60 of 2025. Some here might still have hopes Duran can hit over .800, and others want Gasper playing more in '26.

This club excels in support pieces. We need a  big bopper to compliment everyone else.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...