Anyone that thinks a 4.9 bWAR is 'screwing up' doesn't know enough about baseball to warrant a discussion. He's the 2nd best CF in BB over the past two seasons.
That's the whole thing. We can weigh in, but GMs are using the best scouts in the world. We don't know what they are looking at and what they value. And a falling #75 might be a #150, and a rising #150 might be more like a #75.
Again, baseball is a game of wild variance, and some fans just look at short-term results. 110 games into the season, and we are roughly exactly where we should be. And some guys will out-perform and some will under-perform.
If Rutschman was healthy, and I got 1.2 seasons from him, maybe, if I thought it wouldn't affect the staff. Of if he was hurt, but I got two seasons from him, sure.
That said, BA is only 1.5 back from the WC.
Soriano has been for about 3 months. Webb is almost certainly not available.
OTOH. your Gausman/Springer package almost seamlessly fits our team. Mayer would be an overpay, but I wouldn't hurl if they made that move. Maybe Mayer + some TO dinero if CBT is a concern.
Good, that's all I'm saying. No one knew what his Plan A was, and then they made assumptions based on, my guess, what the writer liked. And then blamed Breslow for not landing a player the writer liked. It's a nothing-burger, but we are now on the same page.