I've mentioned this before, but part of the issue with these discussions is that some RS fans (and I am being generous with 'some') have no idea what the stats are. Hamilton's 2024 stats, extrapolated to 600 ABs, are 16 HRs, 66 SBs, with a great glove. 50% of the RS fans probably don't know that.
But that said, this is the opportunity for them to come in and admit they were wrong.