Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
33 minutes ago, Old Red said:

Actually I thought the 2025 winter getting Cro Man, Breggie, and Chapman were a better haul.

That was close, and all exceeded expecations.

Most of this year's did too. It was the returning players that slipped. (That's on Brez.)

Old-Timey Member
Posted
15 hours ago, Old Red said:

Anger/upset? That’s quite an exaggeration for just saying Gray got a nice little $10M parting gift from the Red Sox.

Well, Boston and St. Louis.  That crazy mutual option with. $10mill buyout was more than sufficient leverage to get the Cardinals to pay half the fare…

Posted

Perhaps 3 of Brez's best moves were ones he didn't make (or "botched.") Too bad he didn't botch the Sale trade!!! LOL.

Breggie signing

Joe Ryan trade

KMarte trade

Look how many adds he made where the player did better than expectations:

Crochet (His durability was a concern, and for good reason) 2nd in CYA

Gray (18-5 2.72 and 5th in CYA)

Bregman (Hit .795 in his previous 5 seasons combined)

Contreras- career year (.901)

Chapman (Most of us felt he'd be a decent set-up man and we still needed a closer)

Bennett- nobody saw that one coming

Suarez- maybe matched expectation and not exceeds

Durbin- GG and great second half- maybe barely exceeded.

Seagler- .727 is not bad for a 4th stringer.

Romy, Gasper, Guerrero, J Jones, J Rogers, Olds, Miller, Monasterio, Toro, N Lowe, Wilson, Slaten, O'Neill, D Smith, Weissert, Criswell, Booser, Priester...

That's like 10 x what Bloom got and in less time!

He's had some failures, like Grissom for Sale, Sandoval and Hendriks. The Gio deal got some late redemption, but was not great.

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 hour ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

A year ago Breslow made some good moves to offset two really bad moves:

1. Losing the club's one proven power hitter -- yes, losing because the whole debacle smacked of miscommunication and/or conspiracy that exposes an incompetent administration;

2. Losing a Silver Slugger Gold Glover third baseman who wanted to spend the rest of his career in Boston where he was already a well-respected leader.

Ultimately, all those good moves by Brez did was put the Red Sox in exactly the same position they were the year before: playoff losers in the Bronx.

And for that, he got an extension.

I think there is a major omission in this summary between 2025 and 2026.  
 

Yes the Sox reached status quo by replacing a Gold Glove Silver Slugger solely with a Gold Glove.  But the 2025 team also had a 6 WAR Cy Young runner up that missed all but a handful of games in 2026.

If Crochet stays healthy, does it maybe affect the Sox being “in the same position”?  Wasn’t Crochet a big part of the reason we thought we had a window in the first place?

Posted
1 hour ago, moonslav59 said:
2 hours ago, Old Red said:

 You didn’t want Breggie, but Brez did, and he Botched the negotiations from day 1 spelled out quite nicely by AJ, and didn’t end up with another bat to go with the con Man.

How many times are you going to repeat the one point we both agree on and act like I disagree?

Wait!  I thought that Moon wanted Bregman and Red did not want him?

Posted
40 minutes ago, notin said:

If Crochet stays healthy, does it maybe affect the Sox being “in the same position”?

I don't normal engage in too many 'what-ifs', but if Crochet & Anthony were healthy, and either Duran or Story play like they did in 2025, then we'd have won 100.

Posted
3 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

I don't normal engage in too many 'what-ifs', but if Crochet & Anthony were healthy, and either Duran or Story play like they did in 2025, then we'd have won 100.

To me, those who dream "What If Anthony is good for one entire MLB season" is very similar to those who warn "What If Bauers has only been good for one entire MLB season."

Except only one of those scenarios has ever come true so far.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 hour ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

To me, those who dream "What If Anthony is good for one entire MLB season" is very similar to those who warn "What If Bauers has only been good for one entire MLB season."

Except only one of those scenarios has ever come true so far.

I have far more faith in an Anthony breakout than a Bauers repeat performance.

There are some questioning why the Sox didn’t invest in Sonny Gray for roughly the same total contract value as Bauers (although half the years, so half the AAV). A fair question.

Which of the two is more likely to repeat?

1. Bauers, at age 31 with only one good year to his name?

2. Or Gray at age 37 coming off a successful year despite a career low fastball velocity?

Both are gambles.  Bauers might be the bigger, but that’s why he cost about half as much to bet on….

 

Posted
6 minutes ago, notin said:

I have far more faith in an Anthony breakout than a Bauers repeat performance.

There are some questioning why the Sox didn’t invest in Sonny Gray for roughly the same total contract value as Bauers (although half the years, so half the AAV). A fair question.

Which of the two is more likely to repeat?

1. Bauers, at age 31 with only one good year to his name?

2. Or Gray at age 37 coming off a successful year despite a career low fastball velocity?

Both are gambles.  Bauers might be the bigger, but that’s why he cost about half as much to bet on….

 

Costing half as much is at least 50% of why Brez took a shot. The other half is probably he felt comfortable with his rotation depth and his specialty of building pitching staffs.

And he better feel uncomfortable -- like the rest of Red Sox Nation -- with his batting order the past two postseasons... whether Roman Anthony is at the top (UGH) or not.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
2 hours ago, notin said:

Well, Boston and St. Louis.  That crazy mutual option with. $10mill buyout was more than sufficient leverage to get the Cardinals to pay half the fare…

Other Red Sox with buyouts

KC $4 million

Bello $1 million

Contreras $7.5 million

Whitlock $500k

Rafaela $4 million

Story $5 million

Saurez $10 million

 

Not everyone, but a lot of people have buyouts in their contract.  On average, roughly half of all guys in mlb who have a contract and not under team control have some kind of option in it. 

Lets not even get started on deferred money

 

Posted
2 hours ago, notin said:

I think there is a major omission in this summary between 2025 and 2026.  
 

Yes the Sox reached status quo by replacing a Gold Glove Silver Slugger solely with a Gold Glove.  But the 2025 team also had a 6 WAR Cy Young runner up that missed all but a handful of games in 2026.

If Crochet stays healthy, does it maybe affect the Sox being “in the same position”?  Wasn’t Crochet a big part of the reason we thought we had a window in the first place?

The returning injured players has always been this big hope for the Sox, in recent years, and it hardly ever works out well.

This season seems different in two ways:

1. The quality of returning players is way better: Crochet, Anthony, Houck, Crawford, Oviedo, Guerrero, Slaten, Gasper and a few others.

2. None of these guys are expected to start the year on the IL, except maybe Gasper. Most were playing/pitching at the end of 2026, unlike past seasons where we knew Houck, Sandoval & Crawford would be out a while. Before that it was Hendriks and others. Before that Giolito and others.

Couple these returns with newbies Bauers & Fortes and first full seasons from Mead, AR, Miller and others, it will be like we have a new team without adding more players this winter.

I hope we keep adding, and knowing Brez's history, I doubt he is done for the winter.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 hour ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

To me, those who dream "What If Anthony is good for one entire MLB season" is very similar to those who warn "What If Bauers has only been good for one entire MLB season."

Except only one of those scenarios has ever come true so far.

To be fair, Bauers has also been on earth for almost a decade longer. 

Bauers put up a 3.6 FWar last year in 144 games.  Ironically Roman has only played in 144 games so far and has put up a 3.3 FWar.  So the 22 year old youngster has been almost just as good as Bauers has been at his best. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Just now, Hugh2 said:

To be fair, Bauers has also been on earth for almost a decade longer. 

Bauers put up a 3.6 FWar last year in 144 games.  Ironically Roman has only played in 144 games so far and has put up a 3.3 FWar.  So the 22 year old youngster has been almost just as good as Bauers has been at his best. 

Expecting Roman Anthony to be better than Bauers if healthy is an insanely reasonable expectation. 

Posted
3 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

To be fair, Bauers has also been on earth for almost a decade longer. 

Bauers put up a 3.6 FWar last year in 144 games.  Ironically Roman has only played in 144 games so far and has put up a 3.3 FWar.  So the 22 year old youngster has been almost just as good as Bauers has been at his best. 

Bauers wasn't bad in 2025, and had a strong September. (1.078 after Sept 1st.)

Old-Timey Member
Posted
16 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Bauers wasn't bad in 2025, and had a strong September. (1.078 after Sept 1st.)

Which 31 year old has the brighter future?

Bauers, who bounced around as a middling bench bat for several seasons?

Mickey Gasper, who spent his life stuck in MiLB but then exploded with one of the best months we’ve seen in a long time?

Bauers is 5 days older.

Posted

Since 9/3/25, yes some cherry-picking, and with 500+ PAs:

TOP OPS (We have 2 in the top 7, but just don't call them "elite.")

1.033 Yordan

.921 Ohtani

.913 PCR

.911 Willson

.908 Soto

.901 Rice

.892 Bauers

.886 Alonso

Others...

12. Schwarber .855

13 DLC .852

14 Harper .851

17 Suzuki & Devers .844

24 Arozarena .828

43. Abrams .803

52 Paredes .794

68. Lopez .768

75. Abreu .760

78 Neto .758

82 Rafaela .748

85 KMarte .744

 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
31 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Other Red Sox with buyouts

KC $4 million

Bello $1 million

Contreras $7.5 million

Whitlock $500k

Rafaela $4 million

Story $5 million

Saurez $10 million

 

Not everyone, but a lot of people have buyouts in their contract.  On average, roughly half of all guys in mlb who have a contract and not under team control have some kind of option in it. 

Lets not even get started on deferred money

 

But a $10mill option on a mutual buyout is actually crazy.  On that list, only Suarez has a buy out that high.  It is a similar case, being mutual with a $35mill guaranteed salary hanging in the balance.  Mutual options are almost never exercised.  In these cases, it’s all but a guaranteed payday for the player.  
 

Boston knew Sonny was getting $40mill this season, and that was almost definitely a factor in St.Louis kicking in $20mill.

Posted
2 minutes ago, notin said:

Which 31 year old has the brighter future?

Bauers, who bounced around as a middling bench bat for several seasons?

Mickey Gasper, who spent his life stuck in MiLB but then exploded with one of the best months we’ve seen in a long time?

Bauers is 5 days older.

I'm not a Gasper believer. His .269 OPS vs LHPs (not a typo. Not his BA.) tilts to Bauers. It's nice Gasper hits pitchers (RHPs) who start 70% of all games, but even that .902 split v RHPs could be a serious outlier. That sample size is 197 PAs vs Bauers. much larger one.

Gasper hit .501 v RHPs in 2025.

Maybe I'm more homer than I want to think I am, but I'm liking Bauers chances more and more each day.

I'm higher on Mead.

Posted
Just now, notin said:

But a $10mill option on a mutual buyout is actually crazy.  On that list, only Suarez has a buy out that high.  It is a similar case, being mutual with a $35mill guaranteed salary hanging in the balance.  Mutual options are almost never exercised.  In these cases, it’s all but a guaranteed payday for the player.  
 

Boston knew Sonny was getting $40mill this season, and that was almost definitely a factor in St.Louis kicking in $20mill.

The $10M buyout is "crazy" but so was his $8M salary for 2026.

Posted
47 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

To be fair, Bauers has also been on earth for almost a decade longer. 

Bauers put up a 3.6 FWar last year in 144 games.  Ironically Roman has only played in 144 games so far and has put up a 3.3 FWar.  So the 22 year old youngster has been almost just as good as Bauers has been at his best. 

No argument. Nor should there be that almost everyone who makes the majors has been used to being the best player at every level from teeball through the minor leagues.

When they do arrive, they're all more used to being counted on to be The Guy than they are failing to be The Guy.

Bauers has been around the big leagues long enough to make adjustments and overcome failure. Red Sox fans should be encouraged by that, and that he can now share his experiences with younger teammates in Boston... and hopefully, take some pressure off a few in the line-up.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
38 minutes ago, notin said:

But a $10mill option on a mutual buyout is actually crazy.  On that list, only Suarez has a buy out that high.  It is a similar case, being mutual with a $35mill guaranteed salary hanging in the balance.  Mutual options are almost never exercised.  In these cases, it’s all but a guaranteed payday for the player.  
 

Boston knew Sonny was getting $40mill this season, and that was almost definitely a factor in St.Louis kicking in $20mill.

The opt-out was actually $5 million, it increased to $10 if he was traded. 

Posted
14 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

Name one winter in Red Sox history where the GM got more production from his additions than last winter, yet a few posters here, and apparently way more that the feeble-minded Red overhears in venues none of us are privy to, think Brez blew it.

You guys crack me up.

.901 Contreras

18-5 2.72 Gray (numbers traditionalists like Red should respect)

3.22 Suarez

3.65 Bennett

GG and .710 Durbin

.823 Gasper

.727 Seagler

3.15 Guerrero

1.91 Gamboa

His few misses were IKF (.633 w good D,) Monasterio (.665,) Watson- a Rule 5 stab in the dark and Coulombe (.629 OPS Against)

Wah wah wah... we missed out on an overpaid Breggie and Alonso who would have cost about as much as all of the above combined. Wah wah wah.....

 

First place = victory parade, second place = set of steak knives, third place = youre fired.

Posted
4 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

Perhaps 3 of Brez's best moves were ones he didn't make (or "botched.") Too bad he didn't botch the Sale trade!!! LOL.

Breggie signing

Joe Ryan trade

KMarte trade

Look how many adds he made where the player did better than expectations:

Crochet (His durability was a concern, and for good reason) 2nd in CYA

Gray (18-5 2.72 and 5th in CYA)

Bregman (Hit .795 in his previous 5 seasons combined)

Contreras- career year (.901)

Chapman (Most of us felt he'd be a decent set-up man and we still needed a closer)

Bennett- nobody saw that one coming

Suarez- maybe matched expectation and not exceeds

Durbin- GG and great second half- maybe barely exceeded.

Seagler- .727 is not bad for a 4th stringer.

Romy, Gasper, Guerrero, J Jones, J Rogers, Olds, Miller, Monasterio, Toro, N Lowe, Wilson, Slaten, O'Neill, D Smith, Weissert, Criswell, Booser, Priester...

That's like 10 x what Bloom got and in less time!

He's had some failures, like Grissom for Sale, Sandoval and Hendriks. The Gio deal got some late redemption, but was not great.

 

Breslow will be judged by the results of the boston red sox, not by the trades he didnt make.

So far, so bad.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
50 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

The opt-out was actually $5 million, it increased to $10 if he was traded. 

All the more reason St. Louis helped pay for it…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
31 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Breslow will be judged by the results of the boston red sox, not by the trades he didnt make.

So far, so bad.

He seems to get judged by the free agents he didn’t sign…

Posted
5 minutes ago, notin said:

He seems to get judged by the free agents he didn’t sign…

Under Breslow we have finished 3.5/5 on average and thats over a 4 year sample, and we have made it past the first round of the playoff series 0 times.

Thats a guy who should be on the hot seat, full stop.

Posted
29 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Breslow will be judged by the results of the boston red sox, not by the trades he didnt make.

So far, so bad.

So he should have overhauled the team by even more than he did?

It's his fault some of the contracts given to him are sunken?

I get the part about he should have been a crystal ball and known the exact moment Duran was going to collapse, and ultimately that is on the GM... same with knowing, expecting and providing allstar back-up for injured player- all on a tightly restricted budget.

IMO, the roster is light years better than it was when he took over. The wins and losses haven't always reflected that improvement, and yes, he is partially to blame. I do blame JH & Co and the actual players who fail to meet expectations, as well.

Last 2 years of Bloom: 78 wins & 78 wins.

Brez: 81>89>87

I hoped it would be better. I expected 2026 to be better and I applauded his summer moves to try and get us better, but Mead got hurt day one, AR did worse, and Miller fell apart the last 2 weeks of the season/playoffs. I guess he can be blamed for that. He coulda got Hicks not AR. He could have willed Mead to not get HBP. He could have sent Miller to a shrink with 3 weeks to go in the season. He could have stopped the Crochet injury, and on and on...

Should he have traded Anthony, last winter?

 

Posted
1 minute ago, drewski6 said:

Under Breslow we have finished 3.5/5 on average and thats over a 4 year sample, and we have made it past the first round of the playoff series 0 times.

Thats a guy who should be on the hot seat, full stop.

When do players ever get the blame?

This is like students in my school that can never do anything wrong, because their parents say they are angels at home.

Shifting blame is now embedded in our culture- from the top orange dog all the way down to pre-K.

Posted
1 minute ago, moonslav59 said:

So he should have overhauled the team by even more than he did?

It's his fault some of the contracts given to him are sunken?

I get the part about he should have been a crystal ball and known the exact moment Duran was going to collapse, and ultimately that is on the GM... same with knowing, expecting and providing allstar back-up for injured player- all on a tightly restricted budget.

IMO, the roster is light years better than it was when he took over. The wins and losses haven't always reflected that improvement, and yes, he is partially to blame. I do blame JH & Co and the actual players who fail to meet expectations, as well.

Last 2 years of Bloom: 78 wins & 78 wins.

Brez: 81>89>87

I hoped it would be better. I expected 2026 to be better and I applauded his summer moves to try and get us better, but Mead got hurt day one, AR did worse, and Miller fell apart the last 2 weeks of the season/playoffs. I guess he can be blamed for that. He coulda got Hicks not AR. He could have willed Mead to not get HBP. He could have sent Miller to a shrink with 3 weeks to go in the season. He could have stopped the Crochet injury, and on and on...

Should he have traded Anthony, last winter?

 

Entering year 5 with 3 third place finishes and one fifth place finish under his belt.  0 playoff series wins. Never came in first or second.

When does he run out of excuses?

Posted

I thought Gray wanted to pitch closer to home or was it being in a situation where he has a chance to win. Signing with Minnesota is neither. I don't think the Sox had a chance to sign him.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...