Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
1 minute ago, moonslav59 said:

When do players ever get the blame?

This is like students in my school that can never do anything wrong, because their parents say they are angels at home.

Shifting blame is now embedded in our culture- from the top orange dog all the way down to pre-K.

Blaming breslow is blaming the players.  What you are saying is the equivalent of dont blame the shopper, blame the groceries in the bag.

Posted
6 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

Blaming breslow is blaming the players.  What you are saying is the equivalent of dont blame the shopper, blame the groceries in the bag.

I use context to assign blame, but usually I distribute the blame among several people.

IMO, Brez deserves lower blame than players failing to meet expectations or getting hurt. (I don't blame players for getting HBP or throwing too hard because his coaches tell him to.)

The totality of Brez's choices are a clear and very good score. I've never seen a GM make more changes in 3 years, especially the last 2. He changed the focus on pitching from top to bottom. He's made some bad moves and was saved by not making a few others due to situations beyond his control, like JH saying he cant give no-trade clauses and the MN GM stiffing him at the deadline, and the AZ GM asking way too much for KMarte.

I wished he'd gotten a bigger bat last year, too. I'd have sacrificed Suarez and IKF to do it, but IMO, Bregman was a mistake, so I'm glad we didnt get him- botched negotiations or whatever.

I'm happy with the team we have. I think we still need one major move to get to the top, but when Brez took over, we were 10 major moves and 20 role player moves away. No exxaggeration. We needed 30 upgrades on the 40 and the farm sucked.

Posted
3 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

I use context to assign blame, but usually I distribute the blame among several people.

IMO, Brez deserves lower blame than players failing to meet expectations or getting hurt. (I don't blame players for getting HBP or throwing too hard because his coaches tell him to.)

The totality of Brez's choices are a clear and very good score. I've never seen a GM make more changes in 3 years, especially the last 2. He changed the focus on pitching from top to bottom. He's made some bad moves and was saved by not making a few others due to situations beyond his control, like JH saying he cant give no-trade clauses and the MN GM stiffing him at the deadline, and the AZ GM asking way too much for KMarte.

I wished he'd gotten a bigger bat last year, too. I'd have sacrificed Suarez and IKF to do it, but IMO, Bregman was a mistake, so I'm glad we didnt get him- botched negotiations or whatever.

I'm happy with the team we have. I think we still need one major move to get to the top, but when Brez took over, we were 10 major moves and 20 role player moves away. No exxaggeration. We needed 30 upgrades on the 40 and the farm sucked.

How many chances does Bres get to get past the first round of the playoffs? Hes 0-4 , entering year 5.

Is it infinite? Is it a results oriented business to everyone but him?

Posted
14 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

How many chances does Bres get to get past the first round of the playoffs? Hes 0-4 , entering year 5.

Is it infinite? Is it a results oriented business to everyone but him?

1. He's oh for 3 and started with a highly flawed roster and hardly any winter spending money for his first year (2024.) The Devers extension emptied JH's wallet. The Sale trade was a disaster, and despite my feeling that Sale was toast, ultimately, Brez was supposed to know he'd burst out. That's the nature of being a GM. I get it. (We don't win with Sale, either.)

2. The budget was significantly upgraded for 2025 and 2026. Almost every player he paid moderately for exceeded expectations. I don't the GM if the changes he made worked but the rest of the team declined or got hurt.

3. In no way do I put more than 10% of the blame on Brez for 2026. Personally, I'm glad he "botched the Bregman deal," but we don't even know if he ever could have gotten him anyway, due to the no trade clause demand. Yes, Bregman would have helped in 2026, but I'm still extremely thankful we did not get him. I wish we'd gotten Alonso, but I'm fine with how Contreras worked out as less than 2/3 the money and 2/3 the years. I'm thrilled with the results we got from Gray, Bennett and was fine with Durbin, Gasper, Guerrero, Jones, Miller, Rogers and others. No, I don't blame him for the vest getting hurt or sucking. No, I don't blame him for injuries to Crochet, Anthony, Mead, Oviedo and no returns from Houck & Crawford. I'm happy he built up decent depth to cover the Mayer implosion and Story injury. I don't blame him for being okay with Narvaez, because I'd be a hypocrite to do so. I thought we had a good team- better than 2025. My one beef was no elite hitter, but then Willson became one, so I don't blame Brez for finding one without me thinking he was one. Same with Gray, whoi many here said wasnt even a decent #3 starter. When is the last time a major signing did well? Price? JD? Well, Suarez met expectations.

I'm not setting a year limit on Brez. If his players he added do well, that's all I ask of a GM. Now, it's up to the players, the manager, the medic staff and luck. I might assign more than 10%, if we don't advance again, but I'll let you know next winter.

If I had to assign blame percentages for why we can't advance, I might go with...

66% JH & the budget committee

15% Players underperforming what I felt they coulda/shoulda done

10% Brez

5% bad luck

4% medical staff

I'm open to pushback on these hastily formulated numbers.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...