Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted

I saw some predictions that say Ryan Jeffers could be signed by the Sox (which I’d personally love) being prepared for Adley to get hurt yet again and be a FA after 2027. Maybe a 2-4 year deal @16-18m per? Put Wong in a trade, or in AAA if he has an option left... We’ll have a legit healthy productive stopgap for the short(ish) term. He was continuing is breakout offensively from 25 last year before he fouled a ball off his hand and missed 45 games. I think he’d be great in Fenway. I’d almost just move on from Adley except Breslow got fleeced for our top two RHSP prospects so he HAS to keep him. Maybe if we move on from some arb guys, Yoshida and Duran to free up some cash. After 2027 the payroll goes way down and his contract will be fine.

 

Posted

I've liked Jeffers for a long time. He's not great on defense, but his bat is good enough to DH and then catch one in every 4-5 days. 

With Bauers, the DH slot is filled and overflowing.

If we trade Contreras, so Bauers can play 1B, maybe we could sign Jeffers.

Posted
50 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

I've liked Jeffers for a long time. He's not great on defense, but his bat is good enough to DH and then catch one in every 4-5 days. 

With Bauers, the DH slot is filled and overflowing.

If we trade Contreras, so Bauers can play 1B, maybe we could sign Jeffers.

Nah, Bauers is the Main DH. I’m not doing the rotating DH. I want a guy who’s gonna play 120+ games there. We can use him elsewhere if needed.

contreras at 1b

Jeffers can play FT at catcher and be plenty fine with Adley as backup. I didn’t like the trade and I’m not impressed with AR. He’ll be hurt again, I’d bet on it.

Posted
1 minute ago, southpaw777 said:

Nah, Bauers is the Main DH. I’m not doing the rotating DH. I want a guy who’s gonna play 120+ games there. We can use him elsewhere if needed.

contreras at 1b

Jeffers can play FT at catcher and be plenty fine with Adley as backup. I didn’t like the trade and I’m not impressed with AR. He’ll be hurt again, I’d bet on it.

I don't think we trade our best batter, Willson. We may DH Contreras more than you think, as a way to extend his playing time and PAs.

We did not trade for AR to be the back-up, and we value catcher defense highly.

We may like Jeffers, but as long as Contreras and AR are on the roster, Jeffers will not be.

Word is the Yanks really wanted AR. Maybe we trade him to the Yanks.

Posted
Just now, moonslav59 said:

I don't think we trade our best batter, Willson. We may DH Contreras more than you think, as a way to extend his playing time and PAs.

We did not trade for AR to be the back-up, and we value catcher defense highly.

We may like Jeffers, but as long as Contreras and AR are on the roster, Jeffers will not be.

Word is the Yanks really wanted AR. Maybe we trade him to the Yanks.

I’m not trading anyone here. Bauers is the main dude at DH and WC can use it as well. There’s plenty of extra days available. If WC needs more days, then so be it. Bauers spends a little more time at 1b.
Adley is gone in a year. We need a main guy for the next few years. AR isn’t that guy.  He can play backup. Maybe move him at the deadline. It was a dumbass trade. Now they can eat it. Maybe even move him this offseason if anyone will bite. 

Posted
4 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

I’m not trading anyone here. Bauers is the main dude at DH and WC can use it as well. There’s plenty of extra days available. If WC needs more days, then so be it. Bauers spends a little more time at 1b.
Adley is gone in a year. We need a main guy for the next few years. AR isn’t that guy.  He can play backup. Maybe move him at the deadline. It was a dumbass trade. Now they can eat it. Maybe even move him this offseason if anyone will bite. 

The Sox did not trade that package for a back-up catcher.

Let's distinguish between what we want and what will never happen.

There are not enough PAs at C, 1B and DH for these 4 players: Contreras, Bauers, Jeffers and AR.

If Bauers can get 200-300+ PAs in LF maybe we can make it work, but then again, we ain't benching Anthony, Rafaela or Abreu. Bauers could maybe get 100-150 when they are rested but not 250+.

Posted
28 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

The Sox did not trade that package for a back-up catcher.

Let's distinguish between what we want and what will never happen.

There are not enough PAs at C, 1B and DH for these 4 players: Contreras, Bauers, Jeffers and AR.

If Bauers can get 200-300+ PAs in LF maybe we can make it work, but then again, we ain't benching Anthony, Rafaela or Abreu. Bauers could maybe get 100-150 when they are rested but not 250+.

So you think I need a lesson on what I want and what the Red Sox will or will not do? 
dude, this is MY GM plan, not theirs.

Just like Breslow did with Devers,  Adley wasn’t my deal and he’s now, at best, splitting time with Jeffers, who’s the better catcher, on my team for 2027.

theres plenty of AbS splitting time at C and maybe a few DH/LF/1B ABs available. most likely AR is getting hurt again. He’s only here for a year on my team. 
of course the Sox won’t do this, although they’d be wise to do so… I’m just playing GM and was never a fan of the Adley trade. If they sign him long term they’re even dumber than I think now. He’s a one year guy and should be treated as such

Old-Timey Member
Posted
2 hours ago, southpaw777 said:

I saw some predictions that say Ryan Jeffers could be signed by the Sox (which I’d personally love) being prepared for Adley to get hurt yet again and be a FA after 2027. Maybe a 2-4 year deal @16-18m per? Put Wong in a trade, or in AAA if he has an option left... We’ll have a legit healthy productive stopgap for the short(ish) term. He was continuing is breakout offensively from 25 last year before he fouled a ball off his hand and missed 45 games. I think he’d be great in Fenway. I’d almost just move on from Adley except Breslow got fleeced for our top two RHSP prospects so he HAS to keep him. Maybe if we move on from some arb guys, Yoshida and Duran to free up some cash. After 2027 the payroll goes way down and his contract will be fine.

 

Sure, Adley could get hurt again.  But Ryan Jeffers hasn’t exactly proven himself to be the solution to catcher durability, given that he’s only topped 100 games twice in his career…

Posted
1 hour ago, notin said:

Sure, Adley could get hurt again.  But Ryan Jeffers hasn’t exactly proven himself to be the solution to catcher durability, given that he’s only topped 100 games twice in his career…

Meh, concussion and hamate break, which was fully healed last year. He doesn’t get the nagging bs like a hammy or an oblique or a calf strain. Adley been a mess for three straight years and last year after the trade was all but a waste. I’d have more confidence in Jeffers moving forward the next few years.

Posted

So may injuries to all players now.  Seems way more than the 80's and 90's.  Might be just a distorted view, might be drugs then, might be pushing human body to its limits.  Anthony is about at my limit.  If he can't stay healthy this next season, I think he loses his place on this team.

Posted
2 hours ago, southpaw777 said:

So you think I need a lesson on what I want and what the Red Sox will or will not do? 
dude, this is MY GM plan, not theirs.

Just like Breslow did with Devers,  Adley wasn’t my deal and he’s now, at best, splitting time with Jeffers, who’s the better catcher, on my team for 2027.

theres plenty of AbS splitting time at C and maybe a few DH/LF/1B ABs available. most likely AR is getting hurt again. He’s only here for a year on my team. 
of course the Sox won’t do this, although they’d be wise to do so… I’m just playing GM and was never a fan of the Adley trade. If they sign him long term they’re even dumber than I think now. He’s a one year guy and should be treated as such

Fair enough.

I make plenty of suggestions I know will never happen.

Posted
16 hours ago, moonslav59 said:

Fair enough.

I make plenty of suggestions I know will never happen.

Yeah, that’s all this is. 
I was doing the play GM game thingy they got on here and was pretty much in that mode all day. 
it was more of a “Here’s what I’d do” kind of day for me. Just having some fun my dude…

Posted
On 11/15/2026 at 11:58 AM, moonslav59 said:

Let's distinguish between what we want and what will never happen.

We're not getting Jeffers or Suzuki.

Posted
On 11/15/2026 at 12:40 PM, notin said:

Sure, Adley could get hurt again.  But Ryan Jeffers hasn’t exactly proven himself to be the solution to catcher durability, given that he’s only topped 100 games twice in his career…

I don't think anyone signs fulltime players to be backups, in case of injury.  There is only so many $$$ to go around, and every team has holes.  If Rutschman plays 115 games, then you get 47 from Jeffers.  So that's about 1.1 WAR.  Or you go with Wong and maybe 0.3 WAR, but save $17M that you spend on something that you really need.

Posted
On 11/15/2026 at 10:15 AM, southpaw777 said:

I saw some predictions that say Ryan Jeffers could be signed by the Sox (which I’d personally love) being prepared for Adley to get hurt yet again and be a FA after 2027. Maybe a 2-4 year deal @16-18m per? Put Wong in a trade, or in AAA if he has an option left... We’ll have a legit healthy productive stopgap for the short(ish) term. He was continuing is breakout offensively from 25 last year before he fouled a ball off his hand and missed 45 games. I think he’d be great in Fenway. I’d almost just move on from Adley except Breslow got fleeced for our top two RHSP prospects so he HAS to keep him. Maybe if we move on from some arb guys, Yoshida and Duran to free up some cash. After 2027 the payroll goes way down and his contract will be fine.

 

Over the last several years Jaffers has spent more days on the Il than Rutchman has. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Hugh2 said:

Over the last several years Jaffers has spent more days on the Il than Rutchman has. 

Wonge has only been on the IL once in the same timeframe. 

Posted
1 hour ago, mvp 78 said:

Wonge has only been on the IL once in the same timeframe. 

Unless you’re referring to the Incompetent List.

But I at least see you bought his Jersey at Red’s Shope

Posted
15 hours ago, notin said:

Unless you’re referring to the Incompetent List.

But I at least see you bought his Jersey at Red’s Shope

It was next to the Jaffers and Rutchman jerseys. 

Posted
17 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

Wonge has only been on the IL once in the same timeframe. 

I've been on the Il NONCE, but I'm pretty sure you guys don't want to see me behind the plate. 

I think Adley is our guy guys......I am interested in swapping Wong out for someone.  One name I'd be interested in is Jimmy Crooks, he'd be an excellent backup this year and he might even be a great starting candidate if Adley moves on or his injury history ensues. 

I wonder what it would take for the Cardinals to part with him?

Posted
6 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

I've been on the Il NONCE, but I'm pretty sure you guys don't want to see me behind the plate. 

I think Adley is our guy guys......I am interested in swapping Wong out for someone.  One name I'd be interested in is Jimmy Crooks, he'd be an excellent backup this year and he might even be a great starting candidate if Adley moves on or his injury history ensues. 

I wonder what it would take for the Cardinals to part with him?

I was pretty good until I hit my mid 40's, then the IL stints started pulling up. 

Why Jimmy Crooks? Not a name I remember seeing. 

Posted
11 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

I was pretty good until I hit my mid 40's, then the IL stints started pulling up. 

Why Jimmy Crooks? Not a name I remember seeing. 

I've literally just been looking up names, im sure theres plenty of other options or candidates out there.  I thought I remember once reading up the Cardinals having a log jam of catchers so I looked there first. 

I thought I read somewhere that San Diego might be open to moving one of Freddy Fermin or Luis Campusano as well.  I might be fine with the offense if they can upgrade back up catcher, and go heavy on a starter to replace Gray

Posted
21 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

We're not getting Jeffers or Suzuki.

Yup.

And no Arozarena, Sato, BLowe or any big bat FA.

We may sign a pitcher or trade for a bat (SS?)

We may move on from  Wong and add a cheap back-up catcher.

Posted
On 11/17/2026 at 1:48 PM, Hugh2 said:

Over the last several years Jaffers has spent more days on the Il than Rutchman has. 

Two broken bones for Jeffers that took most of his IL time. . Unlike  a lot of nagging ones that caused most of the time on the IL for Adley. those kind of injuries are a constant with him.

https://sportsforecaster.com/mlb/p/724146/Adley_Rutschman/transactions

doesnt matter anyway since he took the QO.

Posted
3 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

Two broken bones for Jeffers that took most of his IL time. . Unlike  a lot of nagging ones that caused most of the time on the IL for Adley. those kind of injuries are a constant with him.

https://sportsforecaster.com/mlb/p/724146/Adley_Rutschman/transactions

doesnt matter anyway since he took the QO.

I mean we can reinvent the wheel all day long, he has still spent more time on the IL than Adley, that's an objective truth. You're right, he took the Q.O. so it's a mute point. 

I mean, 1-2 more injuries but smaller more insignificant injuries could also be spun too "well those weren't series, it was just a series of misfortune, he's never been seriously hurt so he is more likely to be fine moving forward"

I

Posted
Just now, Hugh2 said:

I mean we can reinvent the wheel all day long, he has still spent more time on the IL than Adley, that's an objective truth. 

I’m not arguing numbers, but going forward I’ll take my chances on the guy who got a couple broken bones than a guy who has a bunch of nagging injuries that are a constant with him

Posted
Just now, southpaw777 said:

I’m not arguing numbers, but going forward I’ll take my chances on the guy who got a couple broken bones than a guy who has a bunch of nagging injuries that are a constant with him

Maybe, but as I added, I could also say that the smaller injuries could more likely be just fluky where is a broken bone could be more serious, long lasting, or representative of a bigger problem. 

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...