Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Community Moderator
Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

I agree on following RAF Man’s path whom I’ve never had a problem with as some have, because  His bat wasn’t good enough.

Anyone who has paid attention to Arias for a long while doesn't believe Arias's bat will be his calling card. He's not going to have an 800 OPS. He's like a 725 OPS at best. He flashed some power this year after having ZERO power in previous seasons. He's a contact guy that may run into a few HR, but he's not going to hit more than 15 HR or so. I'd expect a good BB rate, a good K rate and a decent average going gap to gap like Xander used to (just less power). 

Posted
11 hours ago, Hitch said:

👨‍🍼

 

13 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I get what you’re saying, and I saw all the ones  I mentioned play at least twice in Portland, and I heard all the talk while they were there. All I’m saying is they all don’t live up to the hype no matter how muchYou want them to.

I get to see a bunch of games here in Portland too.
I remember the first game of 2026 for the Sox.. Will Fleming (should be fired, hes awful) was already carving out RAs bust for the HoF after hitting 3 little base hits. He’s saying crap like OMG RA is passing all expectations, he’s already proving to be a leader on this team! 
it was pathetic to listen to. I mean, I’m all for giving props when deserved, but this clown talked like Anthony was headed to the HOF, an all star and an MVP already.

it’s stuff like that that gives fans delusional reality’s when it comes to these prospects.

 The guys at Sox prospects are pretty grounded. I like them. It’s the other media that overplays their talent…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
10 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

It was very risky for JH to put all of his eggs into "the Big Three." I don't think "prospect people" thought that was a great idea. They needed to be surrounded by players that were ready to compete and veterans that were strong voices in the clubhouse. The Sox didn't do that. 

I remember Soxprospects making this exact point last offseason, and I also remember Lou Merloni saying the same thing on a section10 pod.  I think I was making this point last year myself. 

There seem to be some that just want an all prospect team, they want to develop and never want to splurge on big name free agents.  But having those big names to couple with young talent is important in so many different ways.  

Community Moderator
Posted
3 minutes ago, Old Red said:

You nailed it.

Honestly, you need to infuse cheaper prospects into the lineup on an ongoing basis with veterans on higher dollar contracts. They just thought the cheaper prospects would take the place of acquiring the veterans. You have to do both if you want to compete year in and year out. 

Community Moderator
Posted
Just now, Hugh2 said:

I remember Soxprospects making this exact point last offseason, and I also remember Lou Merloni saying the same thing on a section10 pod.  I think I was making this point last year myself. 

There seem to be some that just want an all prospect team, they want to develop and never want to splurge on big name free agents.  But having those big names to couple with young talent is important in so many different ways.  

Definitely not a unique idea.

Old-Timey Member
Posted
Just now, southpaw777 said:

 

I remember the first game of 2026 Will Fleming (should be fired, hes awful) was already carving out RAs bust for the HoF after hitting 3 little base hits. He’s saying crap like OMG RA is passing all expectations, he’s already proving to be a leader on this team! 
it was pathetic to listen to. I mean, I’m all for giving props when deserved, but this clown talked like Anthony was headed to the HOF, an all star and an MVP already.

it’s stuff like that that gives fans delusional reality’s when it comes to these prospects.

 The guys at Sox prospects are pretty grounded. I like them. It’s the other media that overplays their talent…

Soxprospects are often trying to get guys to pump the breaks on prospects. 

They were skeptical on Campbell, and they have their reservations on Arias as well.  They see Arias as more of a very high floor guy but not a superstar in the making. 

Posted
1 minute ago, Hugh2 said:

Soxprospects are often trying to get guys to pump the breaks on prospects. 

They were skeptical on Campbell, and they have their reservations on Arias as well.  They see Arias as more of a very high floor guy but not a superstar in the making. 

I appreciate them(Sox prospects)keeping fans grounded about the young players.

Posted
17 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

 

I get to see a bunch of games here in Portland too.
I remember the first game of 2026 for the Sox.. Will Fleming (should be fired, hes awful) was already carving out RAs bust for the HoF after hitting 3 little base hits. He’s saying crap like OMG RA is passing all expectations, he’s already proving to be a leader on this team! 
it was pathetic to listen to. I mean, I’m all for giving props when deserved, but this clown talked like Anthony was headed to the HOF, an all star and an MVP already.

it’s stuff like that that gives fans delusional reality’s when it comes to these prospects.

 The guys at Sox prospects are pretty grounded. I like them. It’s the other media that overplays their talent…

Yes Flemming is over the top, but he’s just a fan like everyone when you come right down to it, and yes some fans buy in.

Posted

People may be missing the point of looking forward to Arias.

Even if he's not a superstar, an above-average shortstop can be the key to a pitching-and-defense contender. Soft hands, good range and a strong, accurate arm don't go into slumps.

Every Red Sox fan can at least appreciate that, because we haven't seen one since when? Stephen Drew in the 2013 postseason?

Plus, if Arias only bats .270 with contact, that's still better than any Trevor Story we've seen for half a decade.

Posted
19 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Honestly, you need to infuse cheaper prospects into the lineup on an ongoing basis with veterans on higher dollar contracts. They just thought the cheaper prospects would take the place of acquiring the veterans. You have to do both if you want to compete year in and year out. 

I agree, and not all the prospects are going to turn out as expected, and especially all at once, which I think was expected.

Community Moderator
Posted
51 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

I appreciate them(Sox prospects)keeping fans grounded about the young players.

They aren't always grounded about players TBH. They do hype trains on guys from time to time. 

Community Moderator
Posted
35 minutes ago, 5GoldGlovesOF,75 said:

People may be missing the point of looking forward to Arias.

Even if he's not a superstar, an above-average shortstop can be the key to a pitching-and-defense contender. Soft hands, good range and a strong, accurate arm don't go into slumps.

Every Red Sox fan can at least appreciate that, because we haven't seen one since when? Stephen Drew in the 2013 postseason?

Plus, if Arias only bats .270 with contact, that's still better than any Trevor Story we've seen for half a decade.

I'm looking forward to that version of Arias. I don't think he's an AS SS, but he should provide stability at a position that hasn't had any for a few seasons. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
1 hour ago, Hugh2 said:

Soxprospects are often trying to get guys to pump the breaks on prospects. 

They were skeptical on Campbell, and they have their reservations on Arias as well.  They see Arias as more of a very high floor guy but not a superstar in the making. 

Soxprospects went from massive overhyping to eliminating all hype whatsoever, which was probably the best thing they ever did.  Remember back when they had MLB Equivalents for some players?  The most infamous example was when they labeled Lars Anderson’s MLB Equivalent as Justin Morneau.  I wonder if that’s why they stopped.  Lars never quite reached MVP level, apparently.

And the lack of hype is more realistic.  Teams now have Top 30, Top 40, even Top 50 prospect lists (notably Fangraphs).  Get real.  No minor league organization out there has 50 future major leaguers.  Maybe 10-12 for a good organization, and thats counting the players to go on to become utility infielders and back up catchers.  And certainly they don’t all come up at once…

Old-Timey Member
Posted
3 minutes ago, notin said:

Soxprospects went from massive overhyping to eliminating all hype whatsoever, which was probably the best thing they ever did.  Remember back when they had MLB Equivalents for some players?  The most infamous example was when they labeled Lars Anderson’s MLB Equivalent as Justin Morneau.  I wonder if that’s why they stopped.  Lars never quite reached MVP level, apparently.

And the lack of hype is more realistic.  Teams now have Top 30, Top 40, even Top 50 prospect lists (notably Fangraphs).  Get real.  No minor league organization out there has 50 future major leaguers.  Maybe 10-12 for a good organization, and thats counting the players to go on to become utility infielders and back up catchers.  And certainly they don’t all come up at once…

Yeah but even then I think people misunderstood the comps.  It was kind of more of a if everything breaks right here what he could look like. I think that's one reason why they got rid of comps, because people just took it as gospel "You said he was going to be the next Mo Vaughn"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

They were pumping the breaks on Duran 6 years ago, I remember when Lars Anderson was a highly tauted prospect they were not as high on him as the national media was. I remember listening to a much older podcast where they were talking about how overhyped he was in the national media. 

Posted
1 hour ago, Old Red said:

Yes Flemming is over the top, but he’s just a fan like everyone when you come right down to it, and yes some fans buy in.

He literally is just a fan. No formal training…and it shows. He’s too over the top for me. I like homerism on the radio but the dude needs to chill and act like he’s been there before…he makes us look bad. I think WMB gets a little perturbed with him at times too.  I mean,  I’d have fun talking to him like one of my buddies, just give me another voice on the radio. I can’t go from stiggy to this guy. Too much of a contrast.

Posted
48 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

They aren't always grounded about players TBH. They do hype trains on guys from time to time. 

For the most part they are. The podcasts are pretty tame when it comes to hype. There’s some, but it’s not like listeNing to Fleming on the radio where all our players are superstars.

Community Moderator
Posted
19 minutes ago, notin said:

No minor league organization out there has 50 future major leaguers.  Maybe 10-12 for a good organization, and thats counting the players to go on to become utility infielders and back up catchers.  

Right now, the Sox crappy org probably has 20 if you consider UTIL, RP... If you go back and look at the top 20 year and year out, there are a lot of MiLB guys that get a cup of coffee. 

Community Moderator
Posted
14 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

Yeah but even then I think people misunderstood the comps.  It was kind of more of a if everything breaks right here what he could look like. I think that's one reason why they got rid of comps, because people just took it as gospel "You said he was going to be the next Mo Vaughn"!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

They were pumping the breaks on Duran 6 years ago, I remember when Lars Anderson was a highly tauted prospect they were not as high on him as the national media was. I remember listening to a much older podcast where they were talking about how overhyped he was in the national media. 

They never really bought into Duran's profile because he didn't have any power and was a terrible fielder. There is just a certain profile that they tend to overvalue (toolsy guys that are far away). 

Community Moderator
Posted
12 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

For the most part they are. The podcasts are pretty tame when it comes to hype. There’s some, but it’s not like listeNing to Fleming on the radio where all our players are superstars.

Now that Ian Cundall writes for Baseball America, I bet the podcast becomes even more conservative when projecting out prospects. 

Posted
3 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Now that Ian Cundall writes for Baseball America, I bet the podcast becomes even more conservative when projecting out prospects. 

Good. There are very few real superstars that come out and are like Ohtani, Trout, Betts, etc.  out of the gate. 

conservative is always best. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
7 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

They never really bought into Duran's profile because he didn't have any power and was a terrible fielder. There is just a certain profile that they tend to overvalue (toolsy guys that are far away). 

I'm not sure they're "overvaluing" them so much, it's more like they're dreaming.  They're like a broken record with the line "there's a lot that can go wrong between low A and MLB"  That's kind of their job, to dream on guys.  At the end of the day, there's certain things you see as a scout that you just can't teach, and that doesn't mean a guy is going to be a superstar but it could be he will be if he makes it. 

You can teach 6'7" elite fast twitch muscle fibers hitting a ball over 400 feet as a 17 year old.  But that kid might not ever sniff the majors.  I think it's your job as a prospect evaluating site to dream on that kid. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
14 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Right now, the Sox crappy org probably has 20 if you consider UTIL, RP... If you go back and look at the top 20 year and year out, there are a lot of MiLB guys that get a cup of coffee. 

I’m not talking about the Raymond Burgos Pitch 15 IP And Then Sign With The Hiroshima Carp type guys.  I mean players who actually stick, but really were not necessarily prospects….

Old-Timey Member
Posted
11 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

They never really bought into Duran's profile because he didn't have any power and was a terrible fielder. There is just a certain profile that they tend to overvalue (toolsy guys that are far away). 

They thought he was going to be a decent MLBer, they did pump the breaks, but they were also the first ones to defend him when it looked awful when he first reached mlb. 

Old-Timey Member
Posted
50 minutes ago, southpaw777 said:

For the most part they are. The podcasts are pretty tame when it comes to hype. There’s some, but it’s not like listeNing to Fleming on the radio where all our players are superstars.

They certainly dream on guys, but they'll tell you all about their warts as well.  Guys like Fleming, like many fans listen to a podcast and just remember all the good stuff. 

Someone can say "this guy could be a 30 HR hitter who hits for average if he puts it all together, but he some issues that if he doesn't work out he's never going to come close to reaching that ceiling" and someone will hear that and say "HE'S THE NEXT JUDGE!!!!!" and then people get mad at the prospect gurus like it's their fault a guy doesn't succeed. 

Community Moderator
Posted
15 minutes ago, Hugh2 said:

They certainly dream on guys, but they'll tell you all about their warts as well.  Guys like Fleming, like many fans listen to a podcast and just remember all the good stuff. 

Someone can say "this guy could be a 30 HR hitter who hits for average if he puts it all together, but he some issues that if he doesn't work out he's never going to come close to reaching that ceiling" and someone will here that and say "HE'S THE NEXT JUDGE!!!!!" and then people get mad at the prospect gurus like it's their fault a guy doesn't succeed. 

Flemming doesn't even listen to a podcast most likely. He just sees a guy in a uniform and becomes a fan. He's a homer, but also is 100% behind anything the FO/ownership does. He's an annoying lapdog. 

Community Moderator
Posted
20 minutes ago, notin said:

I’m not talking about the Raymond Burgos Pitch 15 IP And Then Sign With The Hiroshima Carp type guys.  I mean players who actually stick, but really were not necessarily prospects….

Burgos is going to actually stick for a few years now, but I get your point. 

Posted
2 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

It was very risky for JH to put all of his eggs into "the Big Three." I don't think "prospect people" thought that was a great idea. They needed to be surrounded by players that were ready to compete and veterans that were strong voices in the clubhouse. The Sox didn't do that. 

It should also be noted that the vets he surrounded the kids with unerperformed, underwhelmed or spent too much time on the IL.

Story did okay in 2025, fueled moistly by his second half, but he sucked and missed most of 2026.

Abreu did okay but never really busted out.

Rafaela kept improving and was not an issue.

We added Bregman- the quintessential clubhouse guy, but he missed about a 1/3 of 2025 and bolted for '26. We replaced him with Contreras, who might not be viewed as a clubhouse leader, but he did well on the production end.

Yoshida was largely a non-show. 

On the pitching end, we added some very nice pitching but lost Crochet and several others.

While we got next to nothing from the BIG THREE, we did get something from Tolle, Bennett and Early before we traded him. To me, the major blow to the team was underperformances by the vets. Only Rafaela & Contreras came close to career years.

Community Moderator
Posted

Red Sox (jumped the line, bid against themselves): Bauers 4/58

White Sox (patient, shrewd and economical businessmen): Dustin May 3/52

Posted
6 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Red Sox (jumped the line, bid against themselves): Bauers 4/58

White Sox (patient, shrewd and economical businessmen): Dustin May 3/52

Why can't the Red Sox get guys like May?

Errr....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...