The Definitive Case For the Red Sox to Trade Jarren Duran

[Alex Mayes]

I know, I know. We’ve been here before. I’ve discussed trading Jarren Duran here on Talk Sox more than maybe any other topic. There’s sound reasoning behind it, though. Ever since 2024, there has been reason after reason to offload Duran. Now, we sit in the 2026 season mired in mediocrity and not even within sniffing distance of a playoff spot in a weak American League. So now, dear friends, the time has come to make the definitive case for finally trading Jarren Duran away from the Boston Red Sox. 

In short, Jarren Duran has been awful this season. I recently talked about his struggles during the month of June but it’s no secret that the entirety of 2026 has been abysmal for Duran. He’s slashing .214/.270/.398 with 12 home runs, 37 RBIs, and 11 stolen bases. To go along with that awful slash line, he’s striking out 29.4% of the time and is only posting a 79 wRC+, hence his meager 0.7 fWAR. The power is nice, but it's hardly been impactful in an otherwise struggling lineup. He’s tinkered more with his batting stance and leg kick this season than he ever has in the past and it’s messed with his timing so much that he's striking out more than ever.

The stolen bases also look good, but Duran also isn’t getting any younger. He’s 29 right now and turns 30 in September. Speed is the first tool to deteriorate as a player ages, and although there hasn't been a massive decline in his sprint speed, it’s been a downward trend for the last two years. Eventually, he'll age out of elite territory in that regard, too.

But you all know what I think of him by this point. Leave it to the man himself to succinctly sum up his season in a recent postgame conversation: "Absolutely terrible. I’m gonna be honest with you, I’ve felt terrible. Playing like s*** at the plate. But just got to figure it the f*** out, you know?"

And he’s right, he does need to figure it out. There’s no question about that, but he doesn’t need to figure it out in Boston past this trade deadline. The outfield is still jammed, even though Roman Anthony’s injury has allowed Duran ample playing time in left field. When Anthony returns, will Duran go back to primarily playing at designated hitter? The results there have been less than stellar this season. You could argue that Anthony should spend the majority of his starts at DH, but the team didn’t guarantee him a nine-figure sum to just take swings. He needs to be in the outfield on a daily basis. Duran is going to be squeezed back out of his every-day playing time because you’re not going to bench Gold Glovers Ceddanne Rafaela or Wilyer Abreu. Once the entire outfield is healthy again, and that should come right around the trade deadline, Duran is once again the odd man out.

If we move away from the actual baseball side of things though, Duran likely just needs a change of scenery to unlock what’s next for him. Boston is a difficult market to perform in and he has struggled with it from time to time throughout his career. He’s used derogatory language and made lewd gestures towards fans, refused to speak to the media in the wake of Alex Cora’s dismissal, and has eschewed a leadership role within the clubhouse. While leadership isn’t for everyone, Duran is now one of the longest tenured players in the organization and there’s a certain expectation that comes along with that in professional sports. He may not ever be a true leader of men, but since the roster is currently constructed with such a focus toward younger players, that’s a role he has to step into more as he gets older. 

Obviously, the elephant in the room is that every other team can see his terrible numbers as well. What the Red Sox are likely hoping for is that there is a team that is willing to take a chance on him turning things around once he leaves Boston. It’s a gamble worth making, but the return for him is going to be lower than it would have been during the offseason or at the trade deadline last year when the Padres were offering both Dylan Cease and Ethan Salas in return. 

I'll end with this: Jarren Duran is a good baseball player. I've always believed that, and none of his struggles over the years have ever convinced me otherwise. At the same time, it's clear to me that he's overextended his welcome in Boston. A breakup can be painful, but also healing. It's best to rip that band-aid off now and deal with the fallout later.

View full article

[JoeBrady]

In short, Jarren Duran has been awful this season.

That's about as shallow an analysis as possible.  Even the one-minute version is that Duran had a bad start.  He has been outstanding since the start of May.

IRT to the two poor, poor fans that suggested that Duran should've killed himself in his attempted suicide, had Duran charged into the stands and beaten the guy into a hospital stay, I'd have laughed at the guy.

[mvp 78]

31 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

In short, Jarren Duran has been awful this season.

That's about as shallow an analysis as possible.  Even the one-minute version is that Duran had a bad start.  He has been outstanding since the start of May.

IRT to the two poor, poor fans that suggested that Duran should've killed himself in his attempted suicide, had Duran charged into the stands and beaten the guy into a hospital stay, I'd have laughed at the guy.

779 OPS since May 1. It's fine. I wouldn't say "outstanding" if we're really trying to highlight a moment in time. 

His last 2b was 5/19. The HR's are nice, but they are skewing the overall OPS. The good part of Duran's game is behind him. If he's just a power hitter now, I think he has a lot less value. 

[Alex Mayes]

34 minutes ago, JoeBrady said:

He has been outstanding since the start of May.

His June numbers would beg to differ with that assessment. 

[JoeBrady]

20 minutes ago, Alex Mayes said:

His June numbers would beg to differ with that assessment. 

Fair point.  But his weekly numbers are quite strong.  FWIW, I have no problem trading him.  I just happen to think he is still a very good player.  That said, if a team like Philly was putting Painter on the table, I'd be glad to involve Duran.

[Alex Mayes]

1 hour ago, JoeBrady said:

Fair point.  But his weekly numbers are quite strong.  FWIW, I have no problem trading him.  I just happen to think he is still a very good player.  That said, if a team like Philly was putting Painter on the table, I'd be glad to involve Duran.

I appreciate the comments! I’ve always said, even though some people don’t believe me, that I like Duran and understand why he wasn’t moved up to this point. I disagree with the reasons, but I get it. 
 

I think we’re going to get some teams that get pretty desperate for outfield help after Jo Adell is moved. That’s when whoever is actually running the deadline for the Sox needs to capitalize and ship Duran out as likely part of a package deal for pieces that can impact the team in a more positive way. 

[mvp 78]

Duran for prospects? 

[drewski6]

I disagree that Roman needs to play the OF.  But I have been fine with trading Duran since he dropped that ball.  Well, aside from when he hit a HR off sale in WBC (or spring I forget).  Then I put him back on my do not trade.  But at this point, gotta be open to really any move.

Prospects are fine as a temporary value storage.  A team that would be acquiring him is probably buying and therefore not looking to move any ML talent.  Problem is that with more prospects comes more earmarked positions, and thts gotten us in a bit of trouble.

So Id err towards flipping those prospects eventually.

[notin]

3 hours ago, JoeBrady said:

In short, Jarren Duran has been awful this season.

That's about as shallow an analysis as possible.  Even the one-minute version is that Duran had a bad start.  He has been outstanding since the start of May.

IRT to the two poor, poor fans that suggested that Duran should've killed himself in his attempted suicide, had Duran charged into the stands and beaten the guy into a hospital stay, I'd have laughed at the guy.

Hitting .239 with a .779 OPS since the start of May, with a sub-.300 OBP.

Im not ready to call that outstanding..

[Alex Mayes]

37 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

Duran for prospects? 

This would have been my plan last season, especially with Salas on the table. This year though, I don't know if he's worth any prospects close enough to the majors to make a difference. If they package him with either Chapman or Gray though, you're likely getting something substantial in return, and hopefully a blue chipper in there. 

[Alex Mayes]

16 minutes ago, drewski6 said:

I disagree that Roman needs to play the OF.  But I have been fine with trading Duran since he dropped that ball.  Well, aside from when he hit a HR off sale in WBC (or spring I forget).  Then I put him back on my do not trade.  But at this point, gotta be open to really any move.

Prospects are fine as a temporary value storage.  A team that would be acquiring him is probably buying and therefore not looking to move any ML talent.  Problem is that with more prospects comes more earmarked positions, and thts gotten us in a bit of trouble.

So Id err towards flipping those prospects eventually.

I actually think Roman would thrive at first base and that's his path to being a star in this league.

That homer off Sale in spring training was amazing and gave me a lot of hope, then he crashed back down to earth hard. 

I just don't trust Craig to be the one to flip really any prospects at this point, haha.

[notin]

1 minute ago, Alex Mayes said:

This would have been my plan last season, especially with Salas on the table. This year though, I don't know if he's worth any prospects close enough to the majors to make a difference. If they package him with either Chapman or Gray though, you're likely getting something substantial in return, and hopefully a blue chipper in there. 

Salas was a hard pass for me.  Not impressed by catchers having back problems by age 19.

San Diego has shown interest in the past, and Ramon Laureano’s season-ending injury opens the door again.  They’ve likely reviewed his contract situation already - a big first step in any trade already bypassed.  But they’ve depleted their farm severely through trades and promotions the last few seasons.

And beyond Salas, does San Diego have much to offer? Kash Mayfield? He is a flippable A-baller.

The only other possibility I can think of is Cleveland, who has a pretty solid farm, including a RHP named Khal Stephen, who might be the best Dothraki prospect ever.

[mvp 78]

2 minutes ago, notin said:

The only other possibility I can think of is Cleveland, who has a pretty solid farm, including a RHP named Khal Stephen, who might be the best Dothraki prospect ever.

6'4" and went to an SEC school. The only unchecked box is that he's right handed. 

[notin]

3 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

6'4" and went to an SEC school. The only unchecked box is that he's right handed. 

Craig can always flip him for a LHP later…

[drewski6]

24 minutes ago, Alex Mayes said:

I actually think Roman would thrive at first base and that's his path to being a star in this league.

That homer off Sale in spring training was amazing and gave me a lot of hope, then he crashed back down to earth hard. 

I just don't trust Craig to be the one to flip really any prospects at this point, haha.

3 good points

[notin]

4 hours ago, mvp 78 said:

779 OPS since May 1. It's fine. I wouldn't say "outstanding" if we're really trying to highlight a moment in time. 

His last 2b was 5/19. The HR's are nice, but they are skewing the overall OPS. The good part of Duran's game is behind him. If he's just a power hitter now, I think he has a lot less value. 

No doubles for a month is odd for a guy who used to get a double every time the left fielder needed to take four steps to field his single…

[mvp 78]

1 minute ago, notin said:

No doubles for a month is odd for a guy who used to get a double every time the left fielder needed to take four steps to field his single…

His speed is down a little bit, but he's still 93rd percentile. 

[mvp 78]

I think Duran's issue is that he's trying to hit everything over the wall. 

[vegasbob]

43 minutes ago, notin said:

No doubles for a month is odd for a guy who used to get a double every time the left fielder needed to take four steps to field his single…

Problem is Duran is pull happy not slashing to left side , impressed by his titanic HR power