TedYazPapiMookie

It's amazing how many articles get written trying to bury specific players but not others. This journalist is notorious for it. Let's document the people he dislikes and the ones he likes. Is he paid to write the articles by the marketing group or does his mindset simply align with the front office marketing folks? You be the judge. 1. Duran has been lambasted by this author on many occasions. If he has a rough patch, the first author to attach Duran is always this one. 2 Campbell in 2025 was coming off a 2024 season that proved to be more productive offensively and defensively than both Anthony and Mayer two of his favorites. The second Campbell fell from his .400 average in mid-April or his .300 average at the end of April he was proclaimed not worthy and author did everything possible to highlight that opinion. Eventually AAA was the result. Should Cora and the coaches have invested more time helping him make adjustments? Absolutely. But Campbell wasn't on the front office elite prospects list despite the industry declaring him Minor League Player of the Year in 2024. He needed to fail to make the chosen ones the true elite prospects. Campbell after being dropped back to AAA was never promoted again and has pretty much been dismissed from the future of the Red Sox organization. 3 Houck like Duran is a Dombrowski guy and has been dismissed despite being the most promising pitcher in the organization before Early came along. Every hiccup he had was magnified and every achievement by him was reduced by this writer. Houck deserved better based on his performances beginning in 2020 when he put up a 0.50 ERA, or his 3.52 in 2021 or even his 2022 performance that ended with a 3.15 ERA. Not enough was written pointing out all those accomplishments compared to the over-rated Bello. Here are just a few of the unjustly glorified players by the author. 1 Marcelo Mayer the 4th pick of the 2021 draft who has been a bust so far based on his numbers compared to other 4th picks in the draft. His fielding percentage in the minors at SS was a miserable .953 yet he's often called an excellent defender by this writer. That's simply not true based on the numbers. His hitting the last two seasons for the Red Sox has been a dismal .228 in 2025 (five points higher than Campbell who spent the second half of 2025 in AAA) and an even worse .203 in 2026. Has he been called out for underperforming like Campbell was called out in 2025? Nope. Mayer should be in AAA learning how to field and hit but the front office and specific writers are encouraged to spin his awful statistics. 2 Wilyer Abreu is a platoon hitter that hit .219 after April last year but never was sent down to AAA either. This author often spins the truth and suggests he's better than Duran. The numbers don't indicate it and during his 5 months of sub-par hitting was it ever pointed out? Nope. The focus simply got redirected to his defense which is very questionable despite the bogus GG awards based on right field dimensions in Fenway Park. He has more errors that both Rafaela and Duran in CF yet still gets playing time. The best defensive set-up based on actual performance is Duran in CF (2 errors in 606 total chances) and Rafaela in RF (because the total area covered is more than CF and he's so much faster than Abreu). 3 Brayan Bello got the big extension despite Houck being the far superior pitcher at the time. He's another front office and specific writer favorite. His five-year performance is 4.52 ERA (7.71 in 2026) and a horrendous 1.379 WHIP (1.929!! in 2026). Despite these bad numbers he always has gotten more accolades than Tanner Houck who in just over 5 seasons has a 3.97 ERA and 1.238 WHIP and no long- term contract. Trevor Story was the last victim of being highlighted for low performance by this author and of course Duran was today's!! Let's wait and see when Mayer's .203 will be pointed out, or Anthony's .225 average, or Narvaez's .245, or Contreras' .250, or Oviedo's 9.82 ERA, or Crochet's 7.88 ERA, or Bello's 6.75 ERA, or Weissert's 4.66 ERA that led to our first two losses when Cora picked the wrong reliever two days in a row. Maybe there should be an article on the consistency of poor play across the team not focusing just on guys the writer doesn't support well. This truly is a team effort with no one single player to blame. There is, however, ONE SINGLE MANAGER TO BLAME AND FIRE!!! Smart front offices recognize a need for a shake-up and do it. Others are lethargic and political and avoid doing the obvious. Breslow needs to get a pair and go to Ownership to let him pick the next manager. He needs a guy with a background of winning not cheating. He needs a professional who understands both pitching and fielding unlike our current manager. He needs to find someone who doesn't play favorites and cares about winning all games in each series. He needs to find a guy who cares more about winning than being the most popular guy in the dugout. He needs a guy who doesn't fly by the seat of his pants and base decisions on his gut alone when history shows something opposite. Rather than pointing at players you don't like, maybe it's time to point out all the ENORMOUS faults of the manager and suggest he be removed rather than individual players.

Red Sox teams under Cora are not successful. Cora is there because of the ownership. The root cause of the problems isn't Breslow it's the Ownership and Cora. Breslow is no Dombrowski but he's also no Bloom. He's a league average GM working under a weak ownership team and with the worst manager in baseball. That's a lot of problems to fix for Boston to be great again. Clearly when Dombrowski worked for these same owners he was successful, so a GM upgrade is needed but Cora has absolutely no managerial skills he simply speaks two languages. That's not enough to win unless you have a monster roster like in 2018. Breslow can NOT produce that stellar roster, so a better manager is desperately needed and an upgrade at GM is desperately needed. We have lost enough years now that ownership should have motivation to hire the right people to win again but that's yet to be seen.

Joe, absolutely because it's not what really happened BUT Mayer was much higher ranked and trades like that one often includes prospects based on their ranking. The one thing to me that gives me confidence in what I am saying is that Quero was nearly as highly rated at catcher as Teel. Who in their right mind chooses TWO catchers by trading for the second young catcher? Mayer was a SS but could play (allegedly) at 2B, SS or 3B. I often commented that Meidroth had a better minor league performance than Mayer, but he was NOT rated anywhere near Mayer. So, the iffy part of what I said in my mind is the chances they might have pulled Montgomery because he was highly rated too. The two gold chippers in the deal from Boston were Teel and Montgomery but if they bumped up the value from Teel to Mayer from a ranking perspective they would have had to lessen the value elsewhere in the deal. Since neither Meidroth or Gonzalez had much ratings value then the downgrade should have been Montgomery OR they simply pull Meidroth or Gonzalez from the deal. That's why the Montgomery part to me is the "unknown" part of what I wrote. Clearly, Baseball America and the MLB Pipeline loved Mayer much more than both Teel or Montgomery and the White Sox had a great young catcher, it makes perfect sense that Breslow made the mistake of not seeing Mayer as the bust that he is and didn't include him in the trade. He also didn't see Teel as the next coming of Fisk or Varitek. Breslow was new at his job and has had as many bad evaluations as positive evaluations in his time as GM of Boston. I will always respect him for dumping Devers and his bloated salary and disrespect him for not seeing the problem with Sale wasn't Sale it was Cora. Sale has played for Ventura and Snitker and now Weiss for 10 years of his career and he's been awesome. He played 7 years in Boston but only ONE year not for Cora (excluding 2020) and Farrell handled him great and he finished 2nd in the CY YOUNG voting. He was a lock to win it in 2018 until Cora screwed with him and ruined his chances of winning (he finished 4th that year) and he ruined his career or at least derailed it for 7 years. I blame the Sale trade to ATL on Cora. Breslow should have recognized the BIGGEST issue in BOS other than Devers and that was/is Cora. It's three years later and Breslow has acquired lots of talent yet the team still can't win. The problem is Cora and that should be obvious to even the unintelligent baseball fan but Cora got rehired by these owners and they clearly owe him because he should NEVER have been rehired. They brought in Dombrowski and he turned the program around immediately and had 3 highly successful seasons. They brought in Cora and if not for DD he wouldn't have had the talent to win in 2018 and he did his best to screw it up but the players overcame his ineptness as a manager. The following year Cora's mistakes were more than any GM or set of players could off-set and the organization was destroyed and has proceeded downhill every since. FIRE CORA and FIX THE PROBLEM 8 years too late.

I think you are way too optimistic about Narvaez. He's a Yankee cast off who didn't perform for NY and came to Boston to replace Wong a Dodger cast off who never performed well in LA or in Boston except for ONE season. His career year got everyone believing in him while ignoring his past seasons of failure. His encore was miserable in 2025 just like his years prior to 2024. I explained at the start of last season when Narvaez was hot that it was an anomaly based on past performance and that like Wong his career year in 2025 would regress him into oblivion in 2026 just like Wong the year before. In the meantime, Breslow screwed up big-time by including Teel in the Crochet deal. Mayer was more famous and should have been the key to the deal, so Montgomery didn't have to be included. With higher value from Mayer the Red Sox could have lowered the remaining value slightly from Montgomery to someone like Arias. That would have kept the next Varitek in Boston and got rid of the next Jeter Downs (Mayer) to Chicago. Huge mistake by Breslow and Boston is going to pay for it until they find another great young catcher. ONE YEAR WONDERS like Wong and Narvaez don't solidify a franchise they simply mislead the fan base to expect growth out of sub-standard starters. You are welcome think tinkering with a swing will change the skill level of a player, but it won't. Talent dictates success and neither Wong nor Narvaez have close to the talent that Teel has. Mayer on the other hand is much closer in talent to Wong and Narvaez. There was a good reason LA dumped Jeter Downs, Wong and Verdugo in the Mookie deal. Bloom was an idiot (actually he still is!!) and there is a reason NY gave up on Narvaez. Breslow seems to either hit on a great deal or a terrible deal and very little in between. Good Crochet except for the Teel part, bad on Sale, good on Bregman, bad on Buehler, Sandoval and Giolito and hopefully good on Gray and Suarez. Losing Bregman remains a huge mistake and gaining Contreras seems like another mistake that coupled with the Bregman mistake makes the Red Sox corner infield their Achilles Heel.

Ryan, better read up on what metrics are and how they are fabricated (calculated). Data is generated when a player gets an assist, put out or error. Estimates are created when a party tries to determine if something like a run was saved. To do that you must first fabricate a set of rules for what makes for a run saved, then you have to apply it to a completely unique set of circumstances in a fair way. Who gets to decide if the determination is fair? An umpire? No. A sportswriter? No. A fan? Yes, in a way. A PERSON or set of PEOPLE who get hired to make judgements unbeknownst to the public so there is no opportunity to disagree with their decisions. You must simply trust their estimates are correct. That's why it's an estimate not a fact/stat. Facts/stats are base data. Estimates are derivative data. BIG DIFFERENCE in accuracy. Are there mistakes made in gathering facts thanks to biased or simply bad score keeping? Yes, but those mistakes are catalysts to even bigger mistakes in the downstream estimates. I think Arias is the heir apparent at shortstop until he proves he isn't. Mayer was supposed to be but his fielding percentage in the minors was miserable. Heck, it wasn't that much better than Devers!!! OUCH. Arias is only at AA and has done a much better job defensively than Mayer did BUT he can't hit MLB pitching at this point in time so let Story stick at SS until Arias is ready or trade for a legitimate MLB SS who is defensively better than Story and then move him to 2B where he will be the same guy that he is playing SS with the same skills. He'll need to transition his throwing motion to accommodate the position change and that may make him a worse 2B, even if the throw is shorter. Age really isn't as big of an impact to the elite players. Nolan Arenado is still a better 3B defensively than nearly all other 3Bs and he's ancient in the minds of many young people (35) but great hands don't typical fall off as fast as running speed, bat speed or pitch recognition. Story may keep getting worse. He has 4 errors, but he might not error again before April ends. Devers beginning in 2018 his first full season had 5 errors through April and finished with 24, 8 errors in 2019 and finished with 22, 3 errors in 2021 and finished with 22, 0 errors in 2022 and finished with 14, 1 error in 2023 and finished with 19, 1 error in 2024 and finished with 12 in a shortened season of 130 games. What does this show? Starting bad doesn't mean ending the season bad, starting good doesn't mean ending the season good. Story has played just 19 games and people are extrapolating his errors in a straight line, but they don't occur that way as I have shown with Devers. Devers has a .944 fielding % at 3B and Story has a .977 fielding % over 10 years, one more year than Devers. His history suggests he will regress to his mean, so I'll take a .977 fielding % any day!! When the weather warms up and Story starts hitting people won't focus on his defense. This is much ado about nothing. Players have bad stretches and come out of it. Aren't we all hoping that is what's happening to Anthony's offense? No need to pile on Story because someone wants Mayer to be the new SS. He's a below league average defender historically. I'm more worried about him getting hurt than making errors. We failed in 2025 when Bregman got hurt and Story is the new top dog that we need in the line-up. That doesn't bode well for the team except we have a much-improved pitching staff that is handcuffed by the manager.

Metrics are estimates NOT STATS. Some people incorrectly use the word stats to try to legitimize fake facts like metrics, but they are wrong, they are simply collective GUESSES at what happened during a baseball game(s). Are you familiar with the word "rationalization"? In 2025, Story at age 33 put up numbers that were comparable with his great years in Colorado. Is Boston now as hitting friendly as Colorado? Is his age really impacting his performance? Nothing you wrote suggests he needs to move. It was simply a rationalization to try to prove the point that Alex/Alan made. Sorry, it missed the mark. 2025 validates that Coors didn't make him great, he did and 2025 proved that he's not falling off, he was injured and it impacted his play when he first got to Boston. He's still the best player on the team and deserves the respect of real baseball fans, not modern-day mathletes.

So you don't consider that a petty comment?

Think of his contract. Think of his history. Think of how many players have rough patches and recover. We are witnessing the same thing in Crochet. Should we make him a reliever? No. Why? Because his history at being a starter is known and he's just going through a rough patch. Same is true for Story. The length of being great at something buys the person patience from the fans. Story has earned more patience than Crochet has earned. Fans should respect all he's done and give things time to shake out. It's mid-April for Pete's sake.

You continue to use insignificant segments to evaluate players. A guy is hot for a week, and you like him and he's practically a HOFER. A guy has a couple of weeks that contradict his entire fielding history, and you are all over the guy. It's not like Boston has a better defensive SS on the MLB roster. AAA has at least two and who knows below AAA. Face it, Mayer is a bust defensively and offensively and Story is the current player with the best pedigree on offense and defense. The data backs up both factual statements. You are full of generalizations because they are part of the metric generation that doesn't care about accuracy. You make enormous assumptions that are not true and they are said with such conviction you seem to think that validates them. It doesn't. It's just a loud wrong commentary that falls on the public's deaf ears.

Here is another helpful hint to you Alan about defensive metrics. The number of balls played (total chances) varies greatly by position. That's why fielding percentage adjusts for the difference by creating a success for the fielder. Abreu has 493 total chances and 13 errors over two full seasons and two partial seasons. He won GG in the two full seasons with a total of with 228 chances and 7 errors in 2024 and 227 chances and 5 errors in 2025. By comparison, Rafaela has played 2 partial and 2 full seasons as well. In 2024 he had 187 chances and made 3 errors and in 2025 he had 332 chances with 5 errors. So during his two full years Abreu made 12 errors and won two gold gloves and Rafaela made 8 errors and won one GG. Overall, In 2024 when Abreu got his first bogus GG he had a fielding percentage of .969 and LEAGUE AVERAGE was .986 nearly 20 points higher!!!! That's why I consider it bogus. In 2025, Abreu got his second bogus GG he had a fielding percentage of .978 and LEAGUE AVERAGE was .987 (9 points higher to be league average!!). In 2026 Mayer has made 2 errors in 52 chances for a .962 fielding percentage with League Average being .988 so he's just 26 points below league average. That sure sounds like he is consistently bad at fielding since it's very similar to his minor league numbers. His hype is beyond disgusting. The guy is at best a league average player and at worst a DFA waiting to happen. Good thing he's connected.

Your comment shows your ignorance for defensive statistics. You should do your homework on fielding percentage. He had 19 errors in a whopping 635 chances and a fielding percentage of .970. Mayer's fielding percentage at SS in the minors was .953 which stinks. In the majors, he's gotten an out on 1 of 2 chances for a fielding percentage of .500!!! WOW that's impressive.

Ryan, you and your tag team partner Alan are "INVENTING" crap about Story in hopes of helping Mayer. That's inappropriate as a writer. Stick to FACTS not your spin to hurt one player and help another. Story is a better defender than Mayer in his sleep!!! In the minors when Mayer played SS he had 928 total chances and made 44 errors for a fielding percentage of .953!!!!!!!!!!! Enough said. Story in the MLB has had 4031 total chances with 98 errors for a fielding percentage of .977 over the last 10 years. Last year it was .970 and in 2024 it was .989. Those are numbers that Mayer has never been close to based on a significant number of total chances. You must be one of those guys like Alan who takes an incredibly insignificant number of games or plays and extrapolates it to suggest something that is completely untrue both from a mathematical perspective and a hind-sight 20/20 perspective. Mayer should be in AAA based on both his hitting and fielding. Story has started slowly and always improves as the weather warms up. You story is totally bogus.

Since when do you care about defensive accuracy? You watch Abreu lead the team in errors and get gold gloves and praise him. I don't respect your knowledge of the game because of many things but when it comes to complaints it's always targeted with an agenda. You want the crap defender Mayer at SS which is crap. Today's Story is the follow-up to your lead-in. You are fooling nobody. You always have an agenda!!

This article is a hatchet job on Story. Why? The writer has always supported Mayer as the SS of the future and picking on Story puts thoughts in the head of the incompetent manager and front office about needing change. No change is needed. This is a rudderless ship with Cora at the wheel and the merry-go-round line-ups are just reinforcement of his incompetence. Current averages of the players don't actually reflect their skills. That often happens at the beginning of a season and to pick out ONLY ONE individual as this author did is irresponsible. Is Durbin's .127 average likely to be representative of Durbin? No. How about Duran's .167? No. Mayer's .188? Maybe. Narvaez's .195? Yes. Story's .208? NO but the author went after him anyway!! How about the great Roman Anthony's .246? Maybe because he's just a second-year player who may regress from his initial success like Devers did. On the upside, can Yoshida maintain his .286 average? i think so. Can Contreras maintain his .298 average? HIGHLY UNLIKELY since his career average is .258 and over the last several years it's hovered around .260. How about Rafaela and his .300 average? Maybe. He's in his 3rd full season at age 25 and could be coming into his own as a hitter, especially if he is finally returned to the top of the order where he performed in the minors and had great success. What about Abreu's .333 average? NO WAY. In his 2 full seasons in Boston, he's hit .253 and .247 against mostly right-handed pitchers BUT he's hit .316 and .296 in March/April meaning he drops back roughly 50 points after April until the end of the season. It's mid-April and I believe his April numbers once again will be his peak for the season. And I can't emphasize enough that it's mostly against right-handed pitchers limiting his value to the team significantly. BA vs LH pitchers in his career .218 vs .270 versus RH pitchers. His value is grossly over-stated by many fans, reporters and front office personnel based on ACTUAL performance to date. If you rank the players on this team offensively you have no great offensive players!!! If you rank the players for defensive skills, you have two outstanding players if they are played at their proper positions (Rafaela and Duran). On offense, here are the facts about each starter: 1 - Story (one good season out of four but the best pedigree on the team for his career) 2 - Anthony (had a good initial season that was cut short but has great potential but not lengthy success that is needed to be considered an elite hitter.) 3 - Rafaela (a non-favorite of Cora's punished since he arrived in Boston by forcing him to the bottom of the order despite his huge clutch factor) 4 - Duran (another non-favorite of Cora who has been an outstanding leadoff man who lost his job to the latest player on the fast track to fame forced by the organization. Anthony is no lead-off man, he's just the latest player being touted as a star since Devers is gone. Duran has been an all-star but the writer reflects many biased fans opinions about Duran. He should be the starting centerfielder and lead-off hitter but we have a horrible manager. 5 - Contreras (like Story he has a good pedigree at hitting FOR A CATCHER NOT A 1B!!! He's on a four-year decline and was a bad choice by Breslow. His attitude is a major question because it's hard to tell if he fires up teammates or embarrasses them with his temper and outbursts. Does he create fear in opposing pitchers? Nope) 6 - Abreu (streak hitter, streak fielder and best friend to Cora. Nobody gets more undeserved playing time than this platoon hitter who can't seem to hitter right-handed or left-handed pitchers consistently. He also makes the most errors in the outfield and somehow wins gold gloves which completely negates the validity of the gold glove award. This guy constantly swings for the fences, so he's seen as having power like Chris Davis of BAL or Jim Kingman in the old days with the Cubs. Not only does Abreu not have the clutch gene like Rafaela, but he also has the arrogance of Devers which makes him very unlikeable especially in light of the favoritism he gets from Cora. 7 - Mayer (an unproven 4th pick in the draft in 2021 that has continued to get huge support from the organization and Cora. His mediocre numbers in the minors suggested a league average shortstop on offense and defense and he's not proven anything beyond that in the MLB. He's an injury prone player who has had multiple wrist/hand injuries which significantly impacts the ability of the player to hit for power historically. I think Campbell would be far ahead of him if the CLUB and CORA actually gave him the same support that Mayer gets. Had Breslow sold the CWS on Mayer not Teel our organization would be far stronger today. Instead, we have no future C, 3B, SS, 2B or 1B. Casas should have been the future 1B, Campbell should have been the future SS or Bogaerts should have been the current SS, Bregman should have been the short-term 3B so a future 3B could be drafted The Crochet deal was GREAT BUT guys like Abreu and Mayer should have been used not Teel or Meidroth. 8 - Narvaez (A Yankee cast-off for good reason, this guy is an excellent back-up catcher but not a front-line catcher. Like Wong, he's a ONE YEAR WONDER. Each catcher had career years and then fell back to the previous level. His offense is negligible. He's acceptable when hot and miserable when cold and over below league average. 9 - Durbin (newest member doesn't have enough history to say much. Not impressive so far but he needs more at bats. Unfortunately, he's a HUGE step down from Bregman. Bregman should be the norm on a team that pretends to seek being a contender. This team is pretending to seek such lofty goals but realistically is a great pitching crap hitting team. 81 games jump out as an estimate of wins. This team is devastated by the loss of Bregman as opposed to loss of the more highly revered Devers who left without any impact. No quality 1B is killing the team. No quality 2B is killing the team. STORY is just fine overall despite starting slowly. No quality 3B is killing the team. NO Anthony in LF, Duran in CF and Rafaela in RF is killing the team. No batting Duran and Rafaela at the top of the order is killing the team. Most importantly, no quality MANAGER is killing the team. Pitching substitutions can be blamed for more than half the loses. That's on CORA. Overall, this article was a hit article on Story. One person's misguided opinion on the performance of the best hitter on the team now that Bregman is gone. Anthony slumping wasn't even mentioned. His 54 points lower batting average than Rafaela who bats 9th is one of the biggest reasons the Red Sox are failing miserably. Did the author mention Mayer is batting .188? That's lower than Campbell was batting when he was sent to AAA. Yoshida is batting .286 and should be the full time DH batting near the top of the order. Maybe if the order was Rafaela, Anthony, Story, Yoshida, Contreras, Abreu, Narvaez, Durbin and Duran the team might score more runs!!! Maybe if Abreu was traded Yoshida would get the permanent position he came to the US to play and the outfield would make far less errors than they have during the last two seasons!! There is no easy way to fix this team and there is no chance it will happen under Cora.

This article is so off base it's ridiculous. Abreu started the same way last season and hit .219 after April 30th. Hardly a performance to suggest a top player in baseball. HE IS A JOURNEYMAN WHO CAN'T HIT LEFT-HANDED PITCHERS. If Cora wasn't the manager, AND HE SHOULDN'T BE, Abreu would be just a bench guy who comes up when right-handed relievers are trying to finish up a game. He can't hit lefties, he's not clutch, he leads the outfield in errors despite winning bogus gold gloves, he is a bad base runner and because of his tight relationship with Cora he gets opportunities that aren't given to Rafaela who is a FAR, FAR better baseball player. This article is a massive hyperbole with NO FACTS to justify its existence. This writer is so clearly a misguided fan who doesn't have a clue about the game. Why not take ONE GOOD GAME and declare him a HOFER? It's just as ridiculous as this article. He's a bad journeyman player who can't hit lefties and can't field above league average yet wins GGs thanks to CORA. A good manager would have Rafaela the far superior defender guarding right field where the distance from the plate is 302 down the line and 380 in right-center field. Those dimensions translate using bogus outfield metrics into a massive bump in performance to anyone playing right field. Verdugo almost won a GG in right field the one year he was in Boston and then the guy with the most errors two years in a row wins the GG both years. It's a travesty and shows just how bogus the underlying concepts of metrics are. They are a joke. Next time, pick a guy who can perform all year not just in two-week spurts. It's this type of exaggeration that creates myths from players with little skill like Blake Swihart and Jeter Downs. You want to write about a budding star that has NOT been over hyped because he's a white guy in a Latin community of players, look to Connelly Early. He blows away Bello on skills but has yet to get close to the amount of love provided by Cora since he showed up in Boston. MERITOCRICY is such an important word in good baseball organizations. It doesn't exist in the Red Sox organization and that's why since Dombrowski left, this team has abjectly failed and will continue to fail until spots are once again earned not handed out based on relationships. For that to happen, CORA MUST GO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!