1. I do not agree that Moncada, Young, or Swihart should be the DH next year, but even if one of them were, that does not equate to standing pat if other areas of the team are improved.
2. That's fine that you did not suggest getting the best FA available. That was my point though. We can improve the team without signing an expensive big bat to replace Papi.
3. Papi cannot be replaced, even if we signed Encarnacion.
Would it be okay if perhaps the offense is still the best offense in the league next year but only outscores the rest of the league by 50 runs instead of 100?
Would it be okay if perhaps the offense is only the 2nd best offense in the league next year but our BP improved to #1?
4. As I said, I don't think the Sox will stand pat. Our definitions of "standing pat" seem to be different.