What I'm saying is that if the Sox hadn't extended him, and he exceeds expectations, people would be criticizing the FO for not extending him.
No one knows how these things are going to work out. It's a risk worth taking, IMO. Also, IMO, it was a good deal. I think his defense alone pretty much makes it worth it. I agree that he needs to show a little more on offense. Honestly, I was rather surprised when I returned to this site and read the posts about Rafaela not being worth the contract.