Using WAR as a placeholder. Over the past three years:
Player A 75 2B, 9 3B, 74 HR, (158 xbh), 244 runs, 234 RBIs
Player B 123 2B, 39 3B, 45 HR, (197 xbh), 243 runs, 199 RBIs
Everyone will say that Tuckers, but I can make a pretty good case that it's close.