Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 213
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Popular Days

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Judge away...but I am going to wait to see about six starts. In his last 8 starts last year, from Aug 1 on, his ERA was 3.14. He has pitched twice this year, both vs Toronto, probably the best offense in the league, and had one bad outing and one good one.
He has never been anyone's #2. Last year, he pitched like a #6. He can fill a very useful role as a #4 who eats innings, spells the bullpen and puts up a few wins along the way. If everything breaks right for him and he pitches like a #3, I will genuflect, bless myself and give thanks. He is not a #2. He just doesn't have that kind of stuff, never has and that will not change in his 7th full major league season.
Posted
I watched a lot of Young in 2014 for the Mets and in 360 + ABs, he was pathetic. He didn't do well against LHP and he was completely inept against RHP. Give him until the end of the month and then go in a different direction.
Posted
He has never been anyone's #2. Last year, he pitched like a #6. He can fill a very useful role as a #4 who eats innings, spells the bullpen and puts up a few wins along the way. If everything breaks right for him and he pitches like a #3, I will genuflect, bless myself and give thanks. He is not a #2. He just doesn't have that kind of stuff, never has and that will not change in his 7th full major league season.

 

In 2014 he had an ERA of 3.43 with an ERA+ of 113 in 204IP. Thats #2 stuff. He can do that again. Will he? Who knows.

Posted
I watched a lot of Young in 2014 for the Mets and in 360 + ABs, he was pathetic. He didn't do well against LHP and he was completely inept against RHP. Give him until the end of the month and then go in a different direction.

 

I hate the signing, the team already have a platoon OF in Castillo.

Posted (edited)
In 2014 he had an ERA of 3.43 with an ERA+ of 113 in 204IP. Thats #2 stuff. He can do that again. Will he? Who knows.
Stats are not stuff. He doesn't have the stuff i.e. the arsenal of a #2. He's a #4, Mrs. Porcello.

 

Edit: Plus that was only 1 year out of 6 full seasons, andhe was the #4 starter on that staff.

Edited by a700hitter
Posted
Stats are not stuff. He doesn't have the stuff i.e. the arsenal of a #2. He's a #4, Mrs. Porcello.

 

What is "#2 arsenal?" Because Lackey's been pitching like a #2 for the last four seasons with diminished stuff. Porcello's problem isn't stuff, like his 2014 can attest to, it's whatever they changed with his approach. He's a sinker guy looking for K's.

Posted
Who was the Talksox poster who talked about going over to the Cubs in the offseason? Are they still posting here?

 

SCM33, he barely posts anymore.

Posted (edited)
What is "#2 arsenal?" Because Lackey's been pitching like a #2 for the last four seasons with diminished stuff. Porcello's problem isn't stuff, like his 2014 can attest to, it's whatever they changed with his approach. He's a sinker guy looking for K's.
Jamie Moyer was not my idea of a #2 either, but that is just me. Porcello is just never going to be a #2 imo. His bread and butter i.e. his sinker deserted him before he could establish any consistent top of rotation results with his sinker. He had one good season. It looks like an outlier.

 

Other than his sinker, the rest of his arsenal is meh ,and he can't get #2 results with it.

Edited by a700hitter
Posted
Stats are not stuff. He doesn't have the stuff i.e. the arsenal of a #2. He's a #4, Mrs. Porcello.

 

Edit: Plus that was only 1 year out of 6 full seasons, andhe was the #4 starter on that staff.

 

So let me understand: those statistics are meaningless in comparison to your opinion. Is that correct? Statistics are meaningless in evaluating performance. If thats not true, what stats would be consistent with a #2 SP? You said he "was never" a #2 SP. His performance in 2014 disagrees with you.....statistically. Do you have to throw the ball at 95+ to be a #2? What about Greg Maddux?

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...