I think there is hope for any of our bats to turn it around. Gut of the top infield FAs, which contract would you want:
Bichette -0.3 bWAR .581 OPS
Bregman 0.6 with a .736
Alonso 0.4 with a .685
Suarez -0.1 with a .663
These guys wouldn't move the needle compared to how poorly our own guys have done.
My point being is that it is not the outsiders who have made the negative difference. If Narvaez, Story, Duran and Anthony were hitting like they should, no one would even notice Durbin. The same with Crochet and Bello.
If SF could take it back, I'm fairly sure they would. Devers is notoriously streaky, but in his last 19 games, he has an awful, awful 28/2 K/W with 1 HR. 2nd worse fWAR right now, out of 182 qualified.
I told a lot of folks not to give up on Hammy. He is a high-end utility. Compare Hammy and Ceddanne on a per AB basis in 2024-25, and they are very similar players. Ceddanne with the better glove and Hammy with the great speed.
Having Bregman instead of Suarez adds 0.2 bWAR.
I doubt Mayer + Bello gets you Marte. And Marte's 0.4 doesn't make a huge difference.
Arias had 46 weak AA ABs before this season. There is no way we were going to replace Story with a guy barely out of A+.
H&H are okay backup guys, but haven't done anything special with Mil.
The .596 OPS isn't as MVP-ish as it seems. But he did a good job for us, so no reason to not expect a certain level of play. He had a 3.2 bWAR/162 games over the past two years.
I love Wood's swing, but he has huge swing-and-miss issues. He spent the last three months of 2025 hitting almost nothing. I wouldn't buy high based on a 17-game hot streak.
I was just thinking about that. Most teams don't have a L/L platoon, bit given the numbers, I think I can make a case for Duran taking every AB v righties and Yoshida taking every AB against lefties. Part of the issue is that e currently have no righties but Ceddanne that have hit lefties.
The numbers are too small to bother with, but 4 of our top 5 OPS against lefties, are lefty hitters. That makes any platoon problematic.
On the bright side, we aren't being subject to long-term torture. These are pretty quick affairs. And we aren't suffering the pain of a 5-4 loss in the 9th inning.