My initial reaction was pretty close to this. The cons, initially, were 1. 20m off the "40m budget" and 2. we gave a chip for a 1 yr pitcher at 36 yrs old
But in a world where borderline #4 starters are getting (and sometimes rejecting) the QO, it really shows that you just have to pay a significant AAV premium for a short term contract, especially a 1 yr contract. No way we could have gotten Sonny as a FA for a 1 yr deal less than the QO. So there was value in the trade, and looking into Clarke, his top 2 secondaries are horizontal movement pitches, which generally means great vs lefty not as much vs righty (reliever risk), and his fastball plays down (per soxprospects). I can live with it, and with all the pitches we have on 40 man, I dont think Fitts was surviving the crunch anyways.
So its a good deal. Gray with his still elite peripherals (no way to cast #1 in K/BB as anything but elite), is prob still a solid #2 , albeit just a 1 yr fill-in. But he'll fill in well I suspect.
And we arent going to hard stop at 20m from here (40m total), I dont think this takes us out of the running for one of the four FA (Bregman, Bichettte, ALonso, Schwarber). Doesnt mean we'll for sure get one, and I am worried about "out of nowhere" teams coming in and grabbing a few of these guys (e.g. the Giants, or a small market team with new owners who want to change their perception). But I dont think the 20m for Gray really impacts the likelihoood here.
So I like the move. Full stop. Whereas initially I was an "I like the move, but... That "but" is no longer there for me