Ohtani
Judge
Harper
Corey Seager
Yamamoto
Gerrit Cole
Manny Machado
Biggest contracts ever, how many of those look horrible right now?
Also, you forget, Soto is 25, he's just not a guy who's going to put up insane numbers but he's at the beginning of his prime. Also, he's marketable, you make money just from his name.
Sox should be all in on Soto, don't talk yourselves out of it, don't overthink. He's Juan freaking Soto.