It’s a simple question.
If division titles are the sole measure, when do we acknowledge not all titles are created equal.
In Dombrowski’s first two years, the Sox won 93 games each time and won the division title. In those two years in the AL East, only one other team won 90 games. Last year, the Sox won 92 games - enough to win the East in 2016 and 2017. But they played in a division where four teams won 91 games, including one team winning 100. This year, the AL East figures to be just as tough if not tougher. Why doesn’t that get taken into account? It’s not like Bloom has any control with what other teams do. And he certainly couldn’t stop Toronto from developing a lineup full of legacy sluggers.
Epstein only won one title because he was up against Vintage Core Four in NY. Why does that tarnish his accomplishments according to you?