Why does it matter? Calls for him to be DFA'd were not unjustified. He's still having a crap season, 13 million for a 5.42 ERA and a 4-11 record in his starts. Luckily we're salvaging a little from him lately, but who knows how long it will last or when he will get injured again.
Ross, of course, didn't squeeze out Salty until the last 3 games of the WS.
Gomes only did one thing in the entire postseason, and it didn't happen until Game 4 of the WS, but it was enough to justify the extra AB's Farrell gave him.
$13.5 mil should get you a 2 WAR player. Clay is a 0 WAR player this year. He really shouldn't be handed $13.5 mil for his 2016 performance. Exercising his option would really be betting upside.
My guess is that the voters do look at WAR for position players now, but they probably ignore WAR for pitchers. Based on fWAR for example, Price is ahead of Porcello.
McCann has certainly been a semi-bust. It'll be interesting to see if Cashman can get anything for him.
I just think that free agency in general has been a shitshow since the salaries went into the stratosphere. The Yankees have certainly been burned by that reality big time, and the Sox have joined them and quite frankly outdone them with the $167 million for nothing on Panda and Castillo.
Well, that's one way to look at it.
I can just imagine what the talk would be right now if another team traded for Pomeranz (which most certainly would have happened) and we did nothing to improve our rotation, which everyone agreed needed to be improved.