October 2024 prospect voting closed!

[Brock Beauchamp]

Thanks for voting (again), this round will be combined with the previous round and we will begin to build out the prospects section of the site.

Ranked Prospects

• Roman Anthony
• Kristian Campbell
• Marcelo Mayer
• Kyle Teel
• Braden Montgomery
• Franklin Arias
• Luis Perales
• Yoeilin Cespedes
• Richard Fitts
• Miguel Bleis
• Chase Meidroth
• Jhostynxon Garcia
• David Sandlin
• Mikey Romero
• Johanfran Garcia
• Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
• Payton Tolle
• Hunter Dobbins
• Juan Valera
• Yordanny Monegro

[Nick John]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Marcelo Mayer
3. Kristian Campbell
4. Kyle Teel
5. Braden Montgomery
6. Franklin Arias
7. Luis Perales
8. Chase Meidroth
9. Miguel Bleis
10. Yoeilin Cespedes
11. David Sandlin
12. Richard Fitts
13. Jhostynxon Garcia
14. Payton Tolle
15. Mikey Romero
16. Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
17. Hunter Dobbins
18. Johanfran Garcia
19. Wikelman Gonzalez
20. Yordanny Monegro

[moonslav59]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Kristian Campbell
3. Marcelo Mayer
4. Kyle Teel
5. Braden Montgomery
6. Franklin Arias
7. Luis Perales
8. Yoeilin Cespedes
9. Jhostynxon Garcia
10. Richard Fitts
11. Miguel Bleis
12. David Sandlin
13. Chase Meidroth
14. Mikey Romero
15. Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
16. Johanfran Garcia
17. Hunter Dobbins
18. Yordanny Monegro
19. Juan Valera
20. Payton Tolle

[mvp 78]

1. Roman Anthony
   Number 1 prospect in baseball.
2. Kristian Campbell
   I had him ranked #2 last time and many places named him MiLB player of the year. I'm leaving him here.
3. Marcelo Mayer
   Same ranking as last time. Still concerned about health.
4. Kyle Teel
   Same ranking as last time. Could be on Opening Day roster in 2025.
5. Braden Montgomery
   Many believe he could be a fast riser next year in the top 100 and that he has a very high ceiling. I haven't seen him so can't comment. Same ranking as last time.
6. Luis Perales
   Same ranking as last time. Should be back next August.
7. Franklin Arias
   Same ranking as last time. Just didn't hit in A ball when he got there. FCL scouts were impressed, but A ball scouts were not.
8. Miguel Bleis
   Same ranking. Needs to perform on the field. Could fall next year IMO.
9. Yoeilin Cespedes
   Same ranking. Unsure of future position. If his frame maxed out, how much more can he develop as a player?
10. Richard Fitts
    My first changed ranking. Fitts handled himself really well in BOS. Seems MLB capable. Will he be a starter in BOS?
11. Chase Meidroth
    He struggled at the end of the year due to injury and was limited to DH appearances. Seem to have an MLB skillset at least as a part time player.
12. Mikey Romero
    Can adequately field 2B/SS. Improved power projection. Only questions seems to be injury history. Otherwise, I have an up arrow on him.
13. Jhostynxon Garcia
    Hit a big wall at AA and wasn't quite able to push through. Next season will be a big test. I had him at 11 last time around.
14. Johanfran Garcia
    No change from last ranking.
15. David Sandlin
    No change from last ranking. The most electric stuff of the remaining pitchers listed.
16. Yordanny Monegro
    No change from last time. If he develops a better FB (2 seamer?), he'd climb a lot higher in most rankings. The worry is that he's going to struggle as he faces more advanced hitters.
17. Payton Tolle
    Another guy we haven't seen yet. Could end up being the best pitcher in the system.
18. Hunter Dobbins
    I had him at 20 last time, but he pitched well after being promoted to AAA. Is a depth option for 2025.
19. Juan Valera
    Same ranking as last time. He has a long way to go. May end up being a reliever as he hasn't figured out a 3rd pitch.
20. Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
    His velo has ticked up, but the FB is Calvin Schiraldi straight. Probably a guy who goes back and forth between the pen and the rotation like Alfredo Aceves.

[Larry Cook]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Marcelo Mayer
3. Kristian Campbell
4. Kyle Teel
5. Chase Meidroth
6. Braden Montgomery
7. Yoeilin Cespedes
8. Franklin Arias
9. Jhostynxon Garcia
10. Johanfran Garcia
11. Luis Perales
12. Juan Valera
13. Richard Fitts
14. Hunter Dobbins
15. Mikey Romero
16. Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
17. Connelly Early
18. Yordanny Monegro
19. Jedixson Paez
20. Miguel Bleis

[Maddie Landis]

1. Roman Anthony
   Anthony's bat speed is faster than most major league hitters. He's a smart hitter and it's a disservice to him if he's kept in the minors at the start of the next season.
2. David Sandlin
3. Kyle Teel
4. Richard Fitts
   Fitts needs to strikeout batters more but has a good base to build on. Worst case scenario: Story goes down with another injury and Fitts and Priester's high GB% are negatively affected by a shoddy defense.
5. Kristian Campbell
6. Franklin Arias
7. Yoeilin Cespedes
8. Miguel Bleis
9. Luis Perales
10. Marcelo Mayer
    Mayer has the ceiling of Bogey but his parade of injuries led to him being pushed down the list. Who's to say that these injuries will magically cease to exist in the majors?
11. Braden Montgomery
12. Wikelman Gonzalez
13. Mikey Romero
14. Allan Castro
15. Jhostynxon Garcia
16. Payton Tolle
17. Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
18. Chase Meidroth
19. Nazzan Zanetello
20. Conrad Cason

[Hugh2]

1. Roman Anthony
2. Kristian Campbell
3. Marcelo Mayer
4. Kyle Teel
5. Braden Montgomery
6. Luis Perales
7. Franklin Arias
8. Miguel Bleis
9. Yoeilin Cespedes
10. David Sandlin
11. Jhostynxon Garcia
12. Chase Meidroth
13. Richard Fitts
14. Mikey Romero
15. Payton Tolle
16. Elmer Rodriguez-Cruz
17. Johanfran Garcia
18. Conrad Cason
19. Juan Valera
20. Hunter Dobbins