Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 630
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Posted
Really like both deals they pulled off today. Now time to sign Edwin and I think that'd push them over the Astros to be the favorites in the AL. I have to admit DD is building a very good team.
Posted
They had to do this. I said before that you've got 3 years of cheaper control over your core. Now was the time to go for it, and they did

 

His luxury cost is just $6.5M a year!!!!

 

We're still under the cap.

 

You can't pass on a chance to get an ace like this.

 

I just hope his arm holds out for 3 more years!

Posted
I have no idea how the Red Sox pulled this off without trading Eduardo Rodriguez - you'd think the ChiSox would want some major league help coming back. Moncada could be that help - but it is an open question - though he is an excellent prospect.
Posted
I was afraid they would have to include JBJ. Doing it for prospects only is pretty good.

 

Great trade as it stands; however, I have given up on JBJ and would have prefered he be in there rather than Mancada.

 

Other trade (Shaw) was just as good as this one, I think

Posted
Great trade as it stands; however, I have given up on JBJ and would have prefered he be in there rather than Mancada.

 

Other trade (Shaw) was just as good as this one, I think

 

I think if we subbed JBJ for Moncada, we may have had to give more.

Posted
We can really keep the innings down on the Starters, this is a long Starting Staff. Pomeranz can go to BP, lots of Options.
Posted

Since the CWS did not get ML players in return, are they beginning a full rebuild era?

 

If so, can we trade now JBJ, Pomeranz and Swihart for Quintana?

Posted (edited)
I was afraid they would have to include JBJ. Doing it for prospects only is pretty good.

 

I was just thinking to myself earlier that if we could do it for Moncada and some lesser pieces, I'd be pretty tempted, but every rumor or estimate seemed to include guys like Bradley, Rodriguez, etc., which would have felt like robbing Peter to pay Paul to me.

 

They are obviously putting a lot of eggs in the Sandoval (2017 3B), Devers (3B of the future), and Groome (last SP prospect of note) baskets, but man does our roster look stacked now.

Edited by Jack Flap
Posted
People really think we traded Espinoza for Pomeranz just so we could put him in the bullpen, though? Would not surprise me to see him or Buchholz shipped out now and possibly Wright to the bullpen in the swingman role he was intended to fill last year.
Posted

We could use ERod and another player to get back a couple more prospects to replenish the system. We have too many MLB starters now. And Four LHP...Buch could be salary relief now.

More moves to come

Posted

Our rotation is brimming now.

 

Price

Sale

Porcello

Buch

E-Rod

Pomeranz

Wright

 

I dont think any of the last 4 have surefire spots in the rotation. I imagine we trade at least one of them and let the remaining 3 battle it out for the final 2 spots with the odd man out going to the BP. I think of Buch, E-Rod, Pomeranz and Wright, E-Rod probably has the most value in a trade and could get us a pretty nice piece to fill out the roster.

Posted
This makes no sense to me. Are the WS betting that Moncada can learn to hit a curve ball in three years? Or are they just content to have a cheaper version of Castillo in their farm system?
Posted

HOLY CRAP!!!!!! I haven't posted in quite a long time but this certainly warranted it!!!!! This is a CRAZY good deal!!! I was as high on Moncada as others......loved his speed a TON and his power potential but he just seemed to have too many question marks in terms of consistency at the ML level at the plate and in the field. I actually hate to see Kopeck go because young fireballers like him are not a dime a dozen........but to get a REAL TOR starter......it's an absolute no brainer.

 

When I saw the deal originally I thought that one of Bogey, JBJ, Betts or Benni would have been included.......in which case I would have been sad...... But to keep that young core intact is absolutely CRAZY awesome!!!!!!

 

The amazing thing is......Price is our 3rd starter!!!! He's an ace on 3/4 of the clubs out there!! HAHA!!!!

 

Sale, Porcello, Price, Erod, Pom???? with Wright and Buch as 6th starters and spot starters??? Crazy good. In all honesty though, I actually would be shocked if they broke camp with Wright,Buch and Pom on the squad. I can see once of them being traded for some quality BP help or depth in the IF.

Posted
Best. Christmas, Gift. Ever. Wow - Can't believe they pulled this off without having to give up a starter and the Sale contract is so workable....DD is the man! (and the Sox are the faves in 2017)
Posted
This makes no sense to me. Are the WS betting that Moncada can learn to hit a curve ball in three years? Or are they just content to have a cheaper version of Castillo in their farm system?

 

Yes, they are. He's ranked the #1 prospect in baseball for a reason. If you don't get the #1 ranked prospect to headline a deal for an ACE who do you get? They also got a pitcher who has TOTRS potential as well. They also got a toolsy CF prospect and a lower level pitcher who throws in the high 90's and has touched 100 (I'm 99% of this unless I'm thinking of someone else)

 

It's a really good deal for both teams.

Posted
People really think we traded Espinoza for Pomeranz just so we could put him in the bullpen, though? Would not surprise me to see him or Buchholz shipped out now and possibly Wright to the bullpen in the swingman role he was intended to fill last year.

 

He's here - how he got here doesn't matter ... use him in the way that will help the most

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...