I really like Duval, I think he fits this roster perfectly.
It’s perfectly conceivable his 2024 is better and much more productive than his 2023.
Despite that last statement, I’d be very weary of him staying healthy all year in a starters role.
I think Hader would be a good replacement. Better defense and just as good production vs. LHP. Duval is fine defensively and might cost less in years and money. I’m fine with either.
The only solid starter I see is Verdugo. Everyone else is either too young, still unproven, or has platoon concerns.
It’s perfectly conceivable that Duran/Abreu/Rafaela/Refsnyder or some combination of those can become at least 1 viable defender, maybe you get two from that group with clean health and if platoons are used right.
Fact remains however that outfield depth is very thin. In a perfect world a power hitting outfield bat who can RF emerges.
But in a year where it makes so much more sense to buy pitching we may end up rolling with a youth movement in the outfield
Still I see the Sox signing a bat in the OF, Duval back on a 1 year makes the most sense.