What the heck is wrong with being able to praise and criticize someone at the same time?
Like, is Dave really this golden goose golden boy who shits gold and could never.
There is a word for people who view others like that. No one is discrediting Dave, we're just being honest. He has a reputation, a well-deserved one, but it often puts him with gigs with organizations that are already built to win and he just adds the cherry on top. He's not some special god or has some secret recipe no one else has.
He's just got bigger balls than Bloom does, doesn't make him special.