If it comes down to the Cubs, BTV gives fair trades as
1. Witherspoon for Hoerner
2. Tolle for Shaw
Of those two, and both are tough calls, I do Tolle for Shaw. Shaw has much more control and much more power. Both are excellent defensive players.
Witherspoon might have the higher ceiling, but he’s also much further away. But with the Sox current pitching depth, I’m in no rush on Witherspoon..