Yes, I think basically each time they expanded the playoffs they increased the crapshoot factor. It only makes sense. Teams that would have been on the sidelines in past years now have a shot if they get on a roll at the right time.
No repeat winner since 2000. That seems to support the crapshoot theory...
When it comes to the crapshoot theory, opinions shouldn't even enter into it, really. We've got a ton of data to work with.
I don't think it's a total crapshoot. But there have been a lot of crapshoot results, or crapshoot years like 2023.
One thing that is undeniable is that there have been some major crap shoot results in the playoffs.
Arizona (-15 regular season run differential) knocking out the Dodgers (+207 regular season run differential) in 2023 and making it to the WS was one of the all time crap shoot results. And I realize that had a lot to do with the Dodgers pitching being decimated. But that's actually the point - that's exactly why it can be a crap shoot.
The 85-86 win projection looks very reasonable. Obviously we'd like to think we're better than that, but the games keep suggesting otherwise.
OTOH we're only 1.5 games worse than the best record in the AL.
It's an indisputable fact that velocity and spin have increased a lot and everyone agrees it's put a lot more stress on pitcher's arms.
And pitchers aren't getting all these surgeries just for fun.
Nolan Ryan is not a good source because he was a freak of nature. That's a compliment.
Looking at run scoring over the years is fair and would require a deeper dive.
The problem is they throw a lot harder and put a lot more spin on the ball.
Fitts reportedly added a couple MPH to his fastball since last year - but now he's injured.
Unfortunately I have to concede Splintered's point on this one. The Sox record has to be discounted for a relatively soft schedule, including all 7 of our 2025 games against the White Sox.
Which doesn't mean the Sox aren't capable of playing better than they have so far.