This is a wide-open internet forum with very diverse attitudes and opinions. I see no 'groupthink' thing whatsoever. You'll get clusters who agree with each other, of course, but that's only natural.
I think it's possible to have two separate arguments, one about the baseball business decision part and one about the "moral" part.
I was using the Mike Trout injury as evidence of the astronomical risks associated with any of these mega-contracts.