I guarantee if you start a poll "Want JBJ back next year?" the no votes will be much higher than the yes votes.
You're picking on one or two posters who brought him up as a way to make the defense better next year.
The Moving Finger Writes, and Having Writ
Moves On. Not All Your Piety or Wit
Can Lure it Back To Cancel Half a Line
Nor All Your Tears Wash Out a Word of It.
-Omar Khayyam
You missed one small detail, Max. Cora pinch-hit Shaw for Plawecki, and Shaw drew a walk which enabled Verdugo's 2-run single.
Generally speaking, Cora is a fine in-game manager who usually knows what he's doing with each move.
a) It's arbitrary that there are 3 divisions per league.
2018, the Yankees won 100. So it's going to be 2 in 4 years. Small sample, but half the time is often.
And I disagree with your last sentence. The Dodgers are a much better team than the Braves. The Braves are only winning their division because of the randomness that goes with these arbitrary divisions. So it's perfectly fair to give the Dodgers the same chance as the Braves.
Like I say, the previous system with one Wild Card team was fairer. The "but now you gotta win the division!" argument is DOA. I don't like the Dodgers, but they're obviously having a vastly better season than Atlanta.
No way it's "fair" that the team with 17 more wins gets the play-in game. That's just stupid luck.
The new system does boost fan interest, I get that. But it's less fair than the previous system.
But because the divisions are of much different quality, you get this:
Atlanta 85 wins
Dodgers 102 wins
Dodgers, with 17 more wins (!!!), are the ones who have to play in the Wild Card game (unless they catch the Giants).
Obviously not fair.