Jump to content
Talk Sox
  • Create Account

Recommended Posts

Posted
Just now, FredLynn said:

He’s not going after anyone of significance. I hope Bauers works out but he has sucked for most of his career. 

And as usual a CHEAPER option.

Posted
7 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Several reasons, I'm sure.

I'm not suggesting them as predictions, but that's something to complex for you to grasp.

I never thought, or said you were suggesting the trades as a prediction, so I guess it wasn’t too complex, but how about trying something new for a change,and suggest a logical trade that the other team would accept?🤔

Posted
8 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I never thought, or said you were suggesting the trades as a prediction, so I guess it wasn’t too complex, but how about trying something new for a change,and suggest a logical trade that the other team would accept?🤔

Most of the trades I suggest on BTV are rated more highly for the other team and the BTV value the other team gets is higher. In no way does this suggest they would say yes, but people who rate my suggestions think the other team says yes more than the Sox do. That doesn't mean much to me, but for someone who values what others think as highly as you do, maybe you should take note.

On the suggestions vs prediction comment, you have said numerous times the two words make no difference, so it was appropriate to bring up how the idea is too complex for your feeble mind to understand.

Sometimes I make trade suggestions just for fun- knowing one or both sides would surely say no. Maybe the idea that someone can have fun doing that is hard for you to comprehend, but it seems like more fun than  spending your time mocking people for having fun or trying to make actually suggestions instead of just bashing every trade and idea of a trade without hardly any exceptions.

Why not give us a realistic trade suggestion?

Posted
19 minutes ago, Old Red said:

And as usual a CHEAPER option.

Its the same pattern year with few exceptions after year: identify area of need, fill it with a reclamation project or the cheapest option that might work, make excuses. Its getting old.

Posted
Just now, FredLynn said:

Its the same pattern year with few exceptions after year: identify area of need, fill it with a reclamation project or the cheapest option that might work, make excuses. Its getting old.

I fully understand your position. One point of note might be that if the winter budget was set at $60M/4, it's hard to hold Brez fully or even mostly responsible.

Posted
1 minute ago, FredLynn said:

Its the same pattern year with few exceptions after year: identify area of need, fill it with a reclamation project or the cheapest option that might work, make excuses. Its getting old.

I heard Bauers being discussed yesterday, and the comment was that someone like Bauers you buy on the cheap as a reclamation project, and not someone you give $58M to hoping he can do the same for you as he did in Milwaukee.

Posted
7 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Most of the trades I suggest on BTV are rated more highly for the other team and the BTV value the other team gets is higher. In no way does this suggest they would say yes, but people who rate my suggestions think the other team says yes more than the Sox do. That doesn't mean much to me, but for someone who values what others think as highly as you do, maybe you should take note.

On the suggestions vs prediction comment, you have said numerous times the two words make no difference, so it was appropriate to bring up how the idea is too complex for your feeble mind to understand.

Sometimes I make trade suggestions just for fun- knowing one or both sides would surely say no. Maybe the idea that someone can have fun doing that is hard for you to comprehend, but it seems like more fun than  spending your time mocking people for having fun or trying to make actually suggestions instead of just bashing every trade and idea of a trade without hardly any exceptions.

Why not give us a realistic trade suggestion?

As I said BTV just does values, and nothing else, so being rated more highly doesn’t really amount to any value of use, and way below wants, needs, and acceptance. I didn’t say there was no difference between suggestion, or predictions. I said one can be just as wrong as the other, so thanks for remembering. Wouldn’t it be more fun to actually see a trade suggestion happen?🤔🤔

Posted
15 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

I fully understand your position. One point of note might be that if the winter budget was set at $60M/4, it's hard to hold Brez fully or even mostly responsible.

Then I think that Breslow should be honest with the fans and tell it like it is: "the owners don't want to spend the money to obtain top talent so we will do the best we can with the budget they have given us". That could get him fired but at least its honest. I mostly blame Henry for lying about prioritizing winning and for being cheap-but Breslow shoulders some of the blame.

Posted
4 minutes ago, FredLynn said:

Then I think that Breslow should be honest with the fans and tell it like it is: "the owners don't want to spend the money to obtain top talent so we will do the best we can with the budget they have given us". That could get him fired but at least its honest. I mostly blame Henry for lying about prioritizing winning and for being cheap-but Breslow shoulders some of the blame.

Do you think the odds are that Brez has a much higher winter budget and chooses not to spend it?

I'm not sure any company wants managers to rat out their bosses. I think we can safely assume Brez is spending close to what is allowed, or if he wants to spend more than is allowed, he need permission first.

Do you honestly think he's not spending what is allowed? If yes, why do you think that?

Posted
2 hours ago, Old Red said:

Lots of guys have had hype, but how many were there talk of being the face of the franchise, and an MVP candidate in his first full year. Lynn burst on the scene, but he wasn’t to be the face of the franchise like little A was. Nobody had more pressure on them as Yaz did at age 21, because he was replacing Ted. little A was as I read  a perfect storm between the talent evaluators , the Boston press, and the Red Sox themselves who hyped, and placed the expectations on little A.

Nomar and Mo were set to be the face of the franchise. 

Posted
2 hours ago, notin said:

The Brewers extended Pratt for 8 years $51mill prior to his MLB debut.  There is absolutely no reason whatsoever for them to even consider trading him, especially to clear the path for 19 year old Jesus Made.  If the Brewers get to the point of trading Pratt or Made, they are more likely to move Made.  (But most likely to push him to 3b.)

Neto somehow put together some defensive analytics that looked good last year, and he is a prior target for Breslow.

Lopez is just good at everything.  I actually would not be surprised if the Sox dealt Arias for him at all, BTV values be damned…

Neto's defense looked like it always has.

'25: 13 DRS, -8 OAA, -4 FRV

'26: 9 DRS, -8 OAA, -4 FRV

He needs to be moved off SS as he has no range. 

Posted
21 minutes ago, Old Red said:

As I said BTV just does values, and nothing else, so being rated more highly doesn’t really amount to any value of use, and way below wants, needs, and acceptance. I didn’t say there was no difference between suggestion, or predictions. I said one can be just as wrong as the other, so thanks for remembering. Wouldn’t it be more fun to actually see a trade suggestion happen?🤔🤔

We all know and agree BTV only assigns their value and nothing else. They don't know other team's needs or how they value their own players or those they seek.

It only serves a purpose of getting close to what is considered by this site to be near equal value. Nothing else.

Yes, you did say "There is no difference between a suggestion and prediction," and you have also said "You can be just as wrong as the other." I assume that means the suggestion can be wrong because it make no sense to one or both teams and wrong as a prediction, because it doesnt happen, but if it was never meant to a be a prediction, it can't ever be wrong as one, so again, you show you just cant comprehend anything with a slight bit of complexity to it. The worst part is this isnt complex at all.

I'm suggesting a trade. You can disagree, but it doesnt mean it's "wrong." It can never be wrong as a prediction, because it wasnt one.

Would it be fun if one came true? I guess so.

Posted
37 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I heard Bauers being discussed yesterday, and the comment was that someone like Bauers you buy on the cheap as a reclamation project, and not someone you give $58M to hoping he can do the same for you as he did in Milwaukee.

Bauers isn't a reclamation project AFTER the season he just had. He's a reclamation project before '26. 

Posted
Just now, mvp 78 said:

Bauers isn't a reclamation project AFTER the season he just had. He's a reclamation project before '26. 

Any word longer than 4 letters is incomprehensible to Red.

Posted
1 minute ago, mvp 78 said:

Bauers isn't a reclamation project AFTER the season he just had. He's a reclamation project before '26. 

I’m just reporting what’s being discussed elsewhere.

Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

Their first year? MVP candidate?

Roman wasn't considered an MVP candidate until he balled out at the MLB level in '25. 

Nomar was ROY and received MVP votes in his first season. 

Posted
2 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Roman was not either, except form some drunk fan you sat next to one day long ago.

Roman was an MVP candidate prior to the season per Vegas books. I don't know if we were really talking about it on here TBH. Not sure it was a big talking point anywhere. 

Posted
2 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Roman was not either, except form some drunk fan you sat next to one day long ago.

As I said yesterday I’m not getting in the litter box with you, so you can stay in yourself.👋

Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

I’m just reporting what’s being discussed elsewhere.

Oh sure. I'm just reporting that you're wrong. He can't be a reclamation project if he's already been successful in '26. That's how the English language works. 

Posted
Just now, mvp 78 said:

Roman was an MVP candidate prior to the season per Vegas books. I don't know if we were really talking about it on here TBH. Not sure it was a big talking point anywhere. 

How many other venues to you venture too?

Posted
2 minutes ago, Old Red said:

I’m just reporting what’s being discussed elsewhere.

But you agree or why would you post it? Or, you'd say "This is not my opinion, but people are saying it..."

Posted
Just now, Old Red said:

How many other venues to you venture too?

Who cares?

If nobody said it here why bring it up like your scolding some of us for having too high hopes for a promising prospect?

I doubt anyone in their right mind expected Roman to win the MVP year one or two. If you heard it, the guy was likely drunk.

Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

How many other venues to you venture too?

I'm omnipresent. If you're at a bar, I'm the jukebox. If there's no jukebox, I'm the miller lite. 

Posted
1 minute ago, mvp 78 said:

Oh sure. I'm just reporting that you're wrong. He can't be a reclamation project if he's already been successful in '26. That's how the English language works. 

Some still see him that way though, and that’s how it works too.

Posted
2 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

But you agree or why would you post it? Or, you'd say "This is not my opinion, but people are saying it..."

I’ve said from when they signed Bauers to me it was just meh, and I still feel the same today, but thanks for asking.

Posted
19 minutes ago, moonslav59 said:

Do you think the odds are that Brez has a much higher winter budget and chooses not to spend it?

I'm not sure any company wants managers to rat out their bosses. I think we can safely assume Brez is spending close to what is allowed, or if he wants to spend more than is allowed, he need permission first.

Do you honestly think he's not spending what is allowed? If yes, why do you think that?

I think he is spending what the Henry the Cheap told him is available. I want him to be honest though-clearly state that he spent what he was allowed to spend and that he understands that Bauers had exactly one very good season and that before that he was a bum.

Posted
3 minutes ago, mvp 78 said:

I'm omnipresent. If you're at a bar, I'm the jukebox. If there's no jukebox, I'm the miller lite. 

There is so many different things, and different views discussed outside of on here. I guess I’m just different that I like to hear ALL the different opinions, and subjects being discussed than just limiting myself to just on here.

Posted
1 minute ago, Old Red said:

I’ve said from when they signed Bauers to me it was just meh, and I still feel the same today, but thanks for asking.

You dont ever answer the question asked. It exposes your lack of comprehension once again.

You've called Mead & Bauers journeymen, which at least makes some sense, but why post a senseless comment someone else made?

BTW, was your hero Renfroe a journeyman before we added him?

(I expect you to once again answer some other question.)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund
The Talk Sox Caretaker Fund

You all care about this site. The next step is caring for it. We’re asking you to caretake this site so it can remain the premier Red Sox community on the internet.

×
×
  • Create New...