Old Red
-
Posts
16,101 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
4
Content Type
Profiles
Boston Red Sox Videos
2026 Boston Red Sox Top Prospects Ranking
Boston Red Sox Free Agent & Trade Rumors, Notes, & Tidbits
Guides & Resources
2025 Boston Red Sox Draft Pick Tracker
News
Forums
Blogs
Events
Store
Downloads
Gallery
Everything posted by Old Red
-
New to online forums? Boy you’re really at it today. It’s always more acceptable to make the postseason. Teams in any sport with the best record don’t always win in the postseason, but teams with the worst record sometimes do. It shouldn’t even be a debate that getting into the postseason is better than not getting in . Teams with better records in the postseason does not guarantee success.
-
I don’t think Bell agreed he was ignorant.
-
You really asked that question? How many fans out in RSN do you think would rather see the Red Sox make the playoffs, or not. I don’t think the vote would be even close with getting in being the winner. ACCEPTABLE to not getting in at all.
-
Ignorant? Wow!
-
Oh I think it should be done, but I’ll believe it when I see it, and I’d be shocked if it happens.
-
Entitled fan? That’s what I mean when I say the bar has been set so low now. If expecting the Red Sox to be in the postseason every year, or at least be in not only in contention, but real contention I’ll take being called an entitled fan along with many, many others who are out in RSN. If you’re not playing to win every year, and get into the postseason then don’t play at all IMO.
-
The bar has been dropped so low that a 82 win season will now look like a major improvement postseason berth, or not.
-
Well said. If the Red Sox don’t make the postseason for the third straight year it’s 100% unacceptable IMO no matter what’s going on down on the farm, and what might happen in 2026.
-
Like Cora has said that what you do, or don’t do in October is what’s most IMPORTANT, and not what the farm ranking is. If the Red Sox do not play in the postseason again this year that will make it three years in a row, which is totally unacceptable IMO. Just imagine the Gaul of those fans that want to win now.🙈🤭
-
No one is saying Criswell is a 100 pitch guy. He had thrown 72, 79, and 80 pitches his last 3 starts, and only 52 today, and hadn’t been touched with 5 K’s. Detroit is far away from a murderers row, which they mentioned more than once today also on the telecast. Like I said it was all predetermined, and as good as Criswell was pitching it should have been changed. Having Hill as your next up guy didn’t seem like a good idea either. He just pitched yesterday, and just because he throws LH, which Criswell doesn’t, and had no problem mowing them down think Hill was a better option under the circumstances just seems like over managing, and after it was all said, and done it blew up in Cora’s face.
-
The guy most importantly had only thrown 52 pitches, and hadn’t given up anything, and I don’t think if they hadn’t shown Hill warming up no one would have expected that he would have been taken out. If Criswell would have come out, and given up 3 HR to start the 5th I don’t think many would have said he never should have started the 5th. Even the Yuckers in the NESN booth questioned the decision more than once. A predetermined over managing. IMO.
-
In that situation with the way he was pitching, and for a predetermined reason not only yes, but hell yes. Cora Over Managing once again, and NOT working out.
-
May be more enjoyable to watch, but that’s setting the bar pretty low if the Red Sox don’t make the postseason for the third year in a row. How’s it been since the AS break? How’s it been since Cora signed his extension? How’s it been since the trade deadline? It was thought the Red Sox did pretty good on the road trip though Baltimore, and Houston even though the Red Sox lost ground in the wildcard standings. Funny thing the standings don’t know, or care who you beat. Finally how’s it been since that road trip through Baltimore, and Houston. The Red Sox are now closer to teams behind them then they are to teams ahead of them like Detroit after taking 2-3 from Boston.
-
Cora said it was a predetermined plan to take Criswell out before the game even started for matchup purposes. Just an example of over managing, which Cora does often.
-
Picking up O’Neil was no big deal. Duval last year, and Renfroe, and his 96 RBI were added 2 years ago, so those kind of OF are easy to pick up. Weissert, Campbell, and Criswell is depth, but quantity, and not quality.
-
Bad luck, or bad judgement, but the 2 BP guys he picked up has pitched worse after coming to Boston.
-
I don’t see the Red Sox trading much young talent away for any starting pitcher.
-
Brez doesn’t get any atta boys for his trade deadline acquisitions either IMO. He looked pretty proud of himself at the time too.
-
How many Red Sox players were supposedly on the trading block last offseason, and are still with the Red Sox today? Story, Masa, Martin, and Jansen to name a few.
-
No one has said if Gio would have been signed without that Sale trade being made. IMO I don’t think so. Add it all up like I have mentioned before, and the Red Sox spent $35M instead of $27.5M on just Sale. Not a savings at all.
-
The D is legit, and good. Hopefully the O will improve game by game.
-
And with the 12th pick in the 2024 HOBO draft the Red Sox select Brez.
-
I don’t think anyone thought on the ND team going in to A&M was going to be easy especially with that young, inexperienced line. Not a great showing by the offense, but enough to come out with a win.
-
After all is said, and said again Chris Sale will win a Cy Young for another team, and the Red Sox will pay that team for him to do it. Win, win for the Braves. On the other side the Red Sox are in need, and still looking for starting pitching not named Hill, and Paxton who were picked up on the side of the road by Brez when they were hitchhiking. 🤭🙈.
-
And with the 12th pick in the 2024 HOBO draft the Red Sox select Brez.