Nick

Since Day 1, Brez has advocated for not having a fixed DH. He wants to use rotation of players. I would prefer to start with Ref, Abreu and Romy along with 'resting' of Devers/Casas to having Yoshida as the DH. I rather first see Yoshida go before Abreu. Abreu will still be useful in the outfield, especially if someone gets hurt (Duran, Rafaela). Anthony should start in right.

The biggest problem is they are willing to simply admit, "We tried, we really did, but the price, whether in acquiring a free agent or trading for a player, the cost was too high."

Don't ask me to prove it, but I believe Bloom said something to the effect AFTER the trade yeah we could have signed Betts but as you said and Bloom said that the team would have been gutted, not enough supporting cast to put out a playoff team for three or four years. I would challenge the club now that we have enough pieces to put out a playoff contending team, spend some money to chase the title. Does JH really want to die and his epitaph to say well he was able to retain much of his wealth at the time of his death?

Los Angeles Dodgers outfielder Mookie Betts was left searching for answers following another hitless performance in a Game 2 loss to the San Diego Padres. "They're all outs. So, they're all terrible," Betts said postgame Sunday when asked about his at-bats during the 10-2 defeat, according to Bill Plunkett of the Orange County Register. "I don't know really what to say about it. I'm giving my best, doing my best. Obviously, it's not good enough right now." The eight-time All-Star is mired in a 3-for-44 postseason slump dating back to Game 4 of the 2021 NLCS. He's gone hitless in six at-bats to begin this year's NLDS. At least I can take comfort in this.

With Pivetta gone, I would be reluctant to trade away a starter that pitched 180 innings. He is not expensive as a first year arbitration guy. Certainly cheaper than Pivetta's $7.5 M. Just keep him as an insurance. Houck, Giolito, Kutter, Bello, Fitts, Criswell and Whitlock (yes, him). Just add Burnes at the top and work on rebuilding the pen.

Yes......where in the hell did I get Buddy Bell? Thanks

Per MassLive\ By now, it’s obvious that the Red Sox made a mistake in not retaining Kyle Schwarber after the 2021 season. At the time, Schwarber was somewhat redundant because of fellow DH J.D. Martinez. But the Sox should have eaten the necessary money needed to trade Martinez and and kept Schwarber, who has averaged 44 homers over the last three seasons with the Phillies, while scoring 318 runs and knocking in 302. He’s also established himself as a dynamic postseason performer, with a .987 OPS. He caught and batted 2nd for my IU Hoosiers. For me there's no hindsight. I was ecstatic when we acquired him and disappointed when we just let him walk away. Only other time I felt that way was when we let Buddy Bell walk after a rental year when he re-established his VALUE playing for the Sox.

I agree somewhat but I was all in for Schwarber. I really didn't see the downside.

Signing Corbin Burnes would go long way in getting the Sox Nation excited. Anyone hear me? Bueller? Bueller? Bueller?

So the Orioles are again two and out despite leading AL East at some point. I still say we made a horrible mistake letting Schwarber go despite having to carry him and JD Martinez for another year. That would have stopped us from signing Yoshida. Ugh We simply have not made good choices. It's not always about money. It's about how and where we spend the money we have.

Is there any point in giving Grissom at bats when Campbell clearly has more athleticism and power bat already? I would start Anthony and Campbell out of spring training. Play the high ceiling guys and let the chips fall.

OF: Jhostynxon Garcia, Red Sox (No. 12) A/A+/AA: .286/.356/.536, 107 G, 23 HR, 66 RBI, 78 R, 33 BB, 99 K, 17 SB, 151 wRC+ Like Campbell, Garcia began the season unranked on our Red Sox Top 30 and finished it as one of the most productive hitters in the Minors. He hit balls harder than ever and did a better job of launching them in the air in 2024, setting career highs in almost every category and pacing Boston farmhands with 23 homers -- more than double the 11 he totaled in his first three years as a pro. This kid made the All-MiLB Prospect 1st Team along with Campbell and Anthony.

Projected Opening Day Payroll 2024 $175M (cash basis, no benefits) Projected Opening Day Payroll 2025 $106M (cash basis, no benefits, no arb and non arb players) Let's say JH tells Bres I want the Opening Payroll to be the same. That means we have close to $70M to spend. Duran, Tanner and Kutter will cost around $12M more in 2025. I will guess $8M for remaining minimum wage guys. That leaves us with $50M to 'upgrade' the team. Starting Pitching, 2-5 should be set with Houck, Giolito, Kutter, Bello, Fits and Cooper. We need #1. Question. Can we secure someone like Corbin Burnes for $30M and still have money left over to improve the pen and get a quality right handed bat? We start the pen with Liam Hendricks, Whitlock, Fits, Cooper and other pre arbitration guys. If we can't have it all, will adding Burnes and the return of Giolito along with Liam and Whitlock get us going in the right direction with the playoffs the goal? We'll have full year of Story, Casas and Grissom in addition to possible addition of our fab 4. T

Great point.....4 year window for the management to surround more good players to 'go for it'. No point in extending every player 10 years, a la Devers.

PASS...BIG TIME PASS...GO WITH WHAT YOU KNOW. ANOTHER RISKY CONTRACT, UGH WE STILL HAVE STORY AND YOSHIDA ON THE BOOKS FOR 3 MORE YEARS.

Obviously location and movement factors in. Supposedly, Guerrero's 4 seamer tend to rise into right handed batters. He wants to throw it up high in the strike zone.

MassLive had an article on Luis Guerrero who spent last 24 days with the Sox. His 4 seam fastball averaged 97.5 mph, placing him in top 94th percentile. The club was 25th in average fastballs in 2023 and made it priority to improve in this area for 2024. But their ranking only improved to 20th this year. The article states Luis has chance to open with the Sox in 2025. What other bullpen arms do we have with elite fastballs?

I always think of luxury tax payroll. I believe the Management always deal in cash outlay payroll. Bello's high salary per luxury tax is not part of 2025 payroll. His cash payroll is.

Great starting point for discussion, Moon. Brez has the same information that we have as of now. When will he meet JH?

Moon, it's time for the Realistic View 2025, Part I Start with what we have, our probable 26 man roster, maybe our 40 man roster. Thanks

I thought 2024 was the "Year of Discovery". We found out that Duran is a real deal. Rafaela defensively alone can make him a legit center field in the majors. Abreu becomes a 'great get' for Valdez rental. Hamilton with his speed alone has a place on the roster as a utility guy. Wong will be serviceable 1 or 2 behind the plate. Also Houck, Kutter and Bello can be a legit 2, 4 and 5 guys in the starting rotation. My issue is couple of things. Introducing Mayer, Anthony, Teel and Campbell in 2025 will extend the "year of discovery". They look to be major league ready but we will not know until we see them on the field. With that, I'm not sure trading away Abreu is a good move. Oh I have no issues with getting rid of Yoshida. He does not fit in. We don't need a .280 guy who can't play the field and has no real power. The issue is other 29 teams also know it. At best we can get rid of few million dollars off of our payroll but I would not count much of a return in player(s) unless we eat all of his contract. He will become addition by subtraction. He needed to go yesterday. Another 5 year, $90M deal that John Henry can wrap around his middle finger to the fan base.

IP and fwar tie w Yankees stand out to me. Obviously our bullpen imploded. Any #"s there Moon?

I hate to think the'd lie to us but maybe that is the plan.