I also think you underestimate the bullpen plan. Given the Sox entered the lockout with 5 starters, both Houck and Whitlock were clearly destined for the bullpen. Add to that that despite man fans having done so, it’s possible the Sox had not completely given up on Barnes just yet. His collapse last year, no matter how much confidence in him you lost, still only spanned 9 innings. If I told you one year ago that on June 3, 2022, the Sox closer situation would be a season-long mess, your first thought would have been “what happens to Barnes? Injury? Trade? What?”