I agree.
This really isn’t about Bogaerts. They felt Story’s elbow was good enough 10 months ago, and he didn’t need surgery then. Now he does, but a lot could have happened since. Actually a lot did happen.
That Bogaerts wasn’t re-signed was very likely because of his glove. Bloom and/or others didn’t think it would play out very well. Everyone knew the bat want the issue. I’ve theorized Bogaets might have been reluctant to move, which certainly explains the short term offer. But it’s a theory, since I don’t sit in on those things like some people do.
But now Story, whom I was never wild about anyway, is out and the Sox need to move forward and get two middle infielders. I don’t think anyone is considering Arroyo or Valdez as starters. More likely now the Sox do bring in Joey Wendle, who was recently displaced from his starting role in Miami. Royce Lewis also got pushed down a rung on the depth chart, but he still might not be available.
One guy who is available is St. Louis Paul DeJong, whom I’ve (unfairly) compared Story to. DeJong is a very good defensive SS with power, but he has had way too many issues actually making contact. Which is a pity as he is a definite Fenway Swing. I could see one of those “we’ll take him and his $9mill salary off your hands if you just throw in a prospect” type deals.
On offense, Story had a .737 OPS last year (OPS+ 102), and replacing that won’t be a killer task. (Wendle’s career 101 is roughly equal.) So really they just need a glove.