OPS+ from 2023-2026. Big enough sample to matter, but not so large that numbers players put up at age 22 are treated equal to last year.
Contreras 129
Alonso 129
Bregman 120
Bichette 109
Yoshida 109
Bichette is far and away the youngest player on his list, but his hitting this year a very unhealthy .571 OPS. That’s Durbin Country, folks. Even without this year, Bichette is far from an elite hitter and barely a good ballplayer. And possibly not even an upgrade over Yoshida. Well, at least he costs twice as much.
But again, why are Bregman and Alonso elite hitters but not Contreras?