He was an All Star. You do realize even the bench players on the All Star team are called All Stars, right? In fact, those are the players chosen to go based on performance and not popularity.
So now a line of .278/.353/.441 is considered "not very good"?
And it might not be in your best interest to bring up the Duvall Gold Glove thingy, which not an argument in which your displayed much beyond Olympic-caliber stubborness. You know, when you tried to argue Duvall was a former Gold Glove winner from two distant years previous, so therefore he was not a good defensive outfielder. Brief time passage aside, apparently you think the Gold Glove itself is the minimum bar for acceptable defense, as opposed to just admitting you were wrong. ..