IMO, 5GG would defend that decision. He’s not one to look at a play and then decide if the decision/strategy was correct.
The thing is, it was one of those no man’s land plays. In the moment, a decision either way could be correct or wrong.
Matt Antonelli posted an analysis of the play today. He thought Hudson/Eaton made the mistake of not going farther down the line. He pointed out that the 3rd baseman was a mile from 3rd, so there was no way Eaton could have been put out there and he probably gets home from 60 feet wen the throw gets away.