Here is a summary of the middle infield roller-coaster ride for 2026. While this has been a reoccurring issue for years, we've actually gotten better results, this year with what I have called the "carrousel of clowns" in recent years.
SS:
We started the season with Story, who sucked even more than 2025's start of the season. As we awaited a repeat of a turn-around, he got hurt and went on the 60 day IL.
Monasterio and IKF took over for about a week, before we moved Mayer to SS (see the 2B log.) IKF played some SS when Mayer sat (vs LHPs,) but then he went on the IL just as he got his OPS up to .705.
Cheng took over shortly before our historic hot streak. Monasterio started playing about half the time after 5 games in a row by Cheng. A moth later, Cheng went down, and Monasterio became the FT SS from July 22 to today, when Story begins the next chapter.
2B has been a near free-for-all.
Mayer won the job, perhaps by default, to start the year with IKF playing against some LHPs. It became a straight platoon, until Story got hurt. Mayer moved to SS, and Sogard was given his first shot at keeping the 2B platoon with IKF, but by the start of June, Monasterio and Seigler replaced Sogard, and IKF went on the IL. It looked like Seigler won the FT job through June, with Romy playing a few games at 2B when not DH'ing. By the end of July, Sogard started his second stint at 2B (and some SS) with Seigler playing a few games at 2B. It was pretty much Sogard-Seigler for all of August, until today. Seigler was demoted and it looks like we will see Story at SS, Sogard at 2B and Monasterio giving Story a breather for a week or two. Maybe Monasterio plays 2B vs LHPs, but Sogard kills LHPs, too. Maybe Sogard plays for Story vs some tough RHPs.
Barring injuries, we will probably see this pattern continue until the season is over:
SS: Story FT with some days off vs RHPs. (Sogard at SS those days.)
2B: Sogard vs LHPs and most RHPs. Seigler may get called back up and play vs some RHPs.
v R- v L splits by Sox Middle Infielders
2026: R/L
.797/.550 Seigler
.773/.741 Sogard
.633/.851 Monasterio
.540/.566 Story, but 2025: .743/.734
Career:
.769/.916 Story
.685/.592 Seigler
.648/.883 Sogard
.638/.771 Monasterio
These numbers suggest we play:
v RHPs: Seigler, Story or Sogard (Never Monasterio)
v LHPs: Story, Monasterio or Sogard (Never Seigler)
There are only two slots, so maybe:
v R Story at SS (maybe Sogard some) and Seigler at 2B (maybe Sogard)
v L Story at SS and Monasterio at 2B (maybe Sogard)