Anthony's sample size is small, as I pointed out, but his career OPS is .800 vs LHPs. I'm not sure we have better RHB options, other than Contreras. (IMO, Contreras & Abreu should bat 4th based on the L-R pitcher. The other could bat 5th or 2nd.
I'm fine with Duran behind Anthony when we face a RH SP'er.
Looking at the 2025 numbers vs LHPs:
.863 Contreras (.869 career)
.770 Anthony
.734 Story
.731 Narvaez
.717 Durbin
.679 Rafaela
.676 Abreu
That being said, I'm not the one hoisting the protection flag. I'm fine with the L-R philosophy and also am fine with adjusting the line-up vs LH or RH SP'ers.
I'd also be fine with this...
v RHP
L Anthony
R Durbin
L Duran
R Contreras
L Abreu
R Story
L Mayer
R Narvaez
R Rafaela
v L
L Anthony
R Durbin
L Abreu or R Story
R Contreras
R Story or L Abreu
L Duran
R Narvaez
L Mayer
R Rafaela