I wasn't trying to compare Shaw to Middlebrooks as hitters, but rather I was just trying to point out that hitters can look very good in a small sample, only to struggle in a larger sample.
I don't know what the answer will be. I won't be upset if Shaw is given the job. I also won't be upset if Hanley is given the job if the FO determines that he is capable of playing the position defensively. Lovullo and Dombrowski have both indicated that they think he can. I have serious doubts about that, but I will defer to the expertise of the powers that be.
Whichever route they decide to go, I just don't think it's a position that they need to spend a lot of additional money on.