I was on board with the deal. I was and am happy with the return. I know that some would have preferred Graterol, but for me, if Graterol only projects to be a reliever and not a starter, than Downs is the better value. Yes, we could have asked for another pitcher from the Dodgers. I'm guessing that Bloom did that and felt that Downs was the overall better get.
It's odd that I was against signing Price for his contract amount, yet I was also against trading him as part of the Mookie trade. In hindsight, the trade worked out very well, but at the time, I was looking to compete and we needed the starting pitcher.