It appears to me that in the 2018-2019 offseason they went to Betts first. When that fell through they went to Sale and Bogey. The Sale and Bogey extensions came together right at the end of that offseason.
I guess the puzzle will always be why they didn't make a bigger offer to Betts. $300 mill wasn't an insult by any means, but it wasn't what you'd call a strong opening offer.
The Mets and Lindor showed how one of these negotiations is supposed to go when both parties want to get it done.
And frankly, Lindor did a lot better than Mookie compared to his value.
If it was all about wasted money and luxury tax, the seeds of destruction were sowed sooner than that, with $256 million flushed on Pablo/Hanley/Rusney.
That would be Eovaldi, Sale and Bogey.
But they also let Kimbrel go and signed nothing in the way of relievers.
I think there's a lot more to it than that. It was an accumulation of things that bloated the payroll. Even a guy 'under control' like Mookie was suddenly quite expensive. Not that he wasn't worth it and more. But it has gotten really difficult to be a good team for long without the payroll mushrooming. Look at the Dodgers this year.
It's almost as if Cashman has some fundamental weaknesses in his understanding of the game of baseball.
With regard to the shortstop issue, he had a perfectly good shortstop and let him walk, and now Torres is shoehorned into the wrong position.
Joel Sherman says the opening day loss exposed the Yankees' two biggest weaknesses:
-"Gleyber Torres is a second baseman playing shortstop"
-"The Yankees remain challenged to score when the ball does not clear a fence"
Sometimes you have to wonder about Cashman's roster construction philosophy.
I don't know. But going into that series, whichever team won 2 of 3 would win the division. The Tigers won the first two to clinch. The Red Sox won the meaningless last game.
It was an exciting season though.