According to FanGraphs, 1 WAR costs you about $8 million on the free agent market. So for $10 million, you should expect to get about 1.25 WAR. That is way below the average WAR of 2.0. For starting pitchers, that's a #4, tops. For one season.
OK, let's make it $175-200 million as top level.
That still leaves $10 million as low level.
The Red Sox guaranteed $38 million to a guy who got lit up like a Christmas tree for the last 2 months of 2023.
They even threw in an opt-out.
OK, so there's a fun little spectrum of options for bargain hunters, from the thrift store to the dumpster behind the thrift store.
The highest contract ever given to a starter is $325 million.
$6.5 million is exactly 2% of that.
I would vehemently dispute that as midlevel, especially when it's only one year.
I mean the top level now is $325 million.
Midlevel would be more like a Kevin Gausman deal IMHO.
It's certainly not black and white.
I think the main point with the Sox is that $10 million was the MOST they signed a starting pitcher for in the years 2020-2023.
Some people think Devers is fat too, though. These are guys with big bodies no matter what they do.
You made me look up Vlad's season log, and he's not really doing much different than he did the last 2 years. 2021 is looking like a big outlier.
Yeah, I'm not really disagreeing. I'm just guessing that if he hooked up with a good hitting coach he might do better.
There's no room for him with the Sox.
Attendance has been picking up recently if I'm not mistaken.
Have to remember that a lot of those tickets are purchased a long time in advance, which is one reason the team's play doesn't always line up with ticket sales.
DD's approach is pretty simple: go for the prime cuts and pay them whatever you have to.
I would argue it's been a pretty successful approach over the years.
Starting pitchers just get less and less reliable and durable all the time.
Also let's not forget that DD left us Bello, Crawford and Houck.